The Latest on the Seven-Figure Theft From PSA/FedEx
The hosts discuss a major theft of PSA-graded trading cards from a FedEx truck in Southern California, worth approximately $963,000-$1+ million. They also cover NFL/NBA preseason outlook, Mike Trout's new sports collectibles company, and various hobby-related topics including card values and collecting strategies.
Summary
The episode opens with sponsors and announcements before diving into the main story: a FedEx truck carrying PSA-graded cards was robbed on October 13th in Santa Ana, California. Guest Ben Burrows, a reporter who investigated the theft, provides details: the driver left the vehicle for 60-90 minutes, and upon return found the lock broken and approximately 250 packages stolen across three pallets (two completely, about 50 from a third). The confirmed value is $963,000 for the first two pallets, with additional value pending determination for the third. Three pallets each contained about 100 packages, with individual packages potentially containing multiple cards. Key unresolved questions include the driver's whereabouts during the absence, vehicle location, whether surveillance footage exists, and whether the theft was an inside job. PSA has deactivated certification numbers for stolen cards and alerted marketplaces, but declined to release a complete list of stolen cards or specify compensation amounts beyond what they reported to police. The hosts and Burrows discuss insurance liability, noting that compensation may be capped at declared value rather than fair market value, which complicates matters since collectors often under-declare values to avoid insurance fees. The discussion shifts to other hobby news: Mike Trout launching a sports collectibles company focused on live card breaking; the Ohtani game-worn jersey selling for $2 million at auction; and Panini's transition away from major sports licenses. The hosts then review recent NFL/NBA preseason performances, with Papa Geo recommending J.J. McCarthy as a sleeper pick and discussing Paul George's potential with the Celtics. They announce upcoming releases including Topps Heritage Football at $185/box on eBay Live and a charity auction for Vanderbilt Children's Hospital running through Tuesday evening. The episode includes extensive voicemail segments where callers ask about walk-in bathrooms, purchasing rookie cards, the Panini era, Ohtani card values, and various collecting strategies. The hosts provide guidance on buying/selling timing based on sports seasons, with the principle that hype drives value more than actual performance. Mount Rushmore standings are updated with Hans Gruber moving to fourth place after a clever Die Hard reference voicemail.
About this episode
Ben Burrows from The Athletic joins Mike and Jesse to give us the latest on the massive theft from a FedEx truck full of PSA slabs. The latest numbers are staggering. Over orders, seven-figures worth of cards, hundreds of slabs. Stolen in broad daylight from a locked FedEx truck that was suspiciously abandoned for 90 minutes. We wrap up with voicemails and have an updated Mt. Rushmore after Tuesday's show. 0:00 - Intro 3:50 - Ben Burrows from The Athletic joins to discuss the PSA/FedEx Theft 6:05 - The driver reported he left the vehicle for 60-90 minutes, but doesn’t know where he went. When he returned, the lock was broken and contents removed. 7:25 - The first two pallets were taken, and half of the final pallet was taken. Roughly $1M in stolen goods, minimum. 15:00 - PSA response is to pay the maximum insured value of the card, per emails from those affected. 22:00 - Police did not seem very familiar with trading cards or implied value. 29:00 - Mike Trout is opening his own breaking shop and platform with other athletes. 52:40 - Head to voicemails. 57:00 - Buying guide from Gio 1:01:20 - Selling or Grading, and why people are too willing to grade cards they shouldn’t 1:14:15 - Hans Gruber takes credit for PSA theft 1:25:30 - Would love to see more super-limited short-print sets from Topps Follow Sports Cards Nonsense: TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@sportscardsnonsense Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/sports_cards_nonsense/ Twitter: https://x.com/SCN_Pod Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/sportscardsnonsense Newsletter: https://collectibleslife.beehiiv.com/subscribe SCN Challenge: https://scnchallenge.com/ Linktree: https://linktr.ee/SportsCardsNonsense?utm_source=linktree_profile_share&ltsid=5764ed98-4893-4eae-bf91-0bd89949ed99 Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Key Insights
- The FedEx driver's 60-90 minute absence during the theft raises questions about either complicity or remarkable negligence, as this timeframe seems unusually long for a routine break at a shipping facility.
- PSA has declined to release specifics about stolen card contents, exact card counts, or compensation methodology to customers, citing potential impact on ongoing police investigation.
- Collectors who under-declare card values on insurance forms to avoid fees may receive significantly less in compensation than actual fair market value, penalizing their strategic cost-saving.
- The value discrepancy between declared insurance value ($963,000 reported to police) and actual market value is unknown, as PSA declined to specify whether this figure represents fair market value or insured value.
- Video surveillance at the theft location remains unconfirmed; PSA declined to answer whether the area was under surveillance, likely due to investigation constraints.
- The hosts believe the theft likely involved multiple perpetrators and possibly inside knowledge, given the precision and execution of stealing multiple pallets in broad daylight.
- Ben Burrows obtained police details through standard public records requests rather than exclusive sources, demonstrating that media outlets have access to information callers often assume is unavailable.
- Historical pattern shows Mike Trout's recognition level among general consumers (non-baseball fans) is significantly lower than NFL quarterbacks, potentially limiting his platform's initial appeal to mainstream audiences.
- NBA preseason hype drives card values more significantly than actual season performance; collectors should sell before seasons start rather than wait to see if players develop.
- Panini's 10-year exclusive run (2010-2020) produced iconic sets like Prism and Immaculate that collectors now view favorably, despite heavy criticism during that era following the same pattern of complaining about the current market leader.
- Panini has pivoted from major sports licenses to focus on WNBA, soccer, unlicensed products, and entertainment licenses (Sonic, Zelda, Nintendo), suggesting video games may become their primary entertainment collectibles category.
- Collectors buying low-value MLB game-used relics with specific game provenance (like Topps Tribute stamp cards at $5-10) may see appreciation similar to 20-30 year old memorabilia sets that increased from $5-10 to $20-30 prices.
Topics
Transcript
Before we start, a quick word from our sponsor, eBay Live. If you've never checked it out, eBay Live is eBay's live shopping experience built for collectors. It's where you find rare, exclusive, and hard-to-find items. Through live auctions and special drops, you can only get there. What makes it different is the energy in the community. Real sellers, engaging hosts like SportsCardsNonsense, and streamers that make it fun and interactive. It's all backed by eBay's protection and authenticity guarantees, so you can shop with confidence. Just download the eBay app and hit the eBay live button under the search bar and jump in. Now back to your show. You've got your hands full, but that doesn't mean you can't…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Sports Cards Nonsense
One New Chase + One Trivia Question = 2 Hours of Banter
A Sports Cards Nonsense episode featuring Mike, Brendan, and guest hosts discussing recent card acquisitions (including Mark Belanger cards and vintage photography), diving into Shohei Ohtani's all-time baseball ranking, exploring 500 home run club PC building, and comparing equivalent statistical milestones across sports (10,000 rushing yards in football).
The NFL Rookie Class is Getting a Much-Needed Boost | With Joe Bartel
The hosts discuss NFL rookie quarterbacks finally starting in Week 9, Kevin O'Leary's controversial sports card promotion, and a deep collection evaluation of a 20,000-card purchase. They also cover financial planning for card collections, produce pack battles, and reminisce about the show's early episodes from 2021.
Mike and Jesse Put Each Other on the Hot Seat
Mike and Jesse discuss their respective trips to card shows—Jesse attended the Toronto Expo with Upper Deck where he met Wayne Gretzky, while Mike visited the Boston Shriners show and acquired a large collection. They answer voicemails about lost mail, subscription services, and create a sports movie Mount Rushmore challenge.
If the Market is Slowing Down, What is the Main Reason?
The hosts discuss the slowdown in the sports card market, particularly in wax pricing and grading accessibility, while exploring factors affecting collector engagement. They provide advice for new collectors on budget allocation and introduce guest Cooper DeGene, an NFL player new to card collecting.
Are We Headed for a Market Downturn?
In this Monday episode of Sports Cards Nonsense, the hosts discuss market conditions showing both strength (record $1B monthly volume) and weakness (slower breaks, expensive wax), recap a tense card show incident, and feature an interview with Phil from Sealed Wax Nation about their charitable initiatives donating to children's hospitals.