The NFL Rookie Class is Getting a Much-Needed Boost | With Joe Bartel
The hosts discuss NFL rookie quarterbacks finally starting in Week 9, Kevin O'Leary's controversial sports card promotion, and a deep collection evaluation of a 20,000-card purchase. They also cover financial planning for card collections, produce pack battles, and reminisce about the show's early episodes from 2021.
Summary
The episode opens with sponsors (eBay Live and Gatorlite) before diving into the main content. The hosts discuss a 20,000-card collection purchase that has been broken down by player, with approximately 500 cards worth $25 or more. They've identified 55 cards for PSA grading and plan to vault them to facilitate sales through PSA vault offers. Notable finds include a Shaq Metal Planet die-cut worth $400-$500 and rare inserts like an Eyes on the Game Barry Sanders refractor and Peyton Manning stained glass card. They're planning eBay Live streams featuring 90s and early 2000s basketball cards (Kobe, MJ, Shaq, Duncan, etc.) and have already sold two cards for $1,600 combined profit.
The hosts bring on Joe Bartel, an NFL analyst, to discuss rookie quarterbacks Fernando Mendoza (Raiders) and Carson Beck (Cardinals) finally starting in the same week. While acknowledging this is typically positive for the hobby, they note both face tough defenses (Seahawks and Rams respectively). Joe provides analysis of playoff contenders across both conferences, rating teams as either contenders or pretenders. He identifies Jacksonville, Cincinnati, and Chicago as top contenders, while cautioning against Pittsburgh, Denver, and Philadelphia. The discussion includes analysis of individual players to buy on contending teams, with emphasis on star players like Josh Allen, Trevor Lawrence, Christian McCaffrey, and Jamar Chase.
A significant portion involves discussing Kevin O'Leary's involvement in sports card promotion. One host criticizes O'Leary's presentation as cringy and overly dramatic, though acknowledges his $400 million net worth gives him credibility. They debate whether his promotion of baseball cards as an alternative asset class will drive wealthy investors into the hobby, concluding that while his presentation is theatrical, his influence may still bring new money into the market.
The hosts discuss Paul George cards, noting he's been performing excellently with the Celtics but has a problematic injury history. One host explains he purchased Paul George rookie cards expecting to flip them but plans to sell soon given the player's age (36) and injury track record. They contrast this with Cooper Flagg and Victor Wembanyama, whom they'll hold despite current price dips, as these younger players have longer careers ahead.
A guest attorney named Nicole calls in via voicemail, criticizing the hosts for not having proper estate planning for their card collections. She pitches her services as an estate planning attorney who specializes in high-end collection trusts, explaining how collections can get tied up in probate without proper planning. This sparks discussion about what would happen to the collection if the hosts died, with one host suggesting his wife contact Russ and Tori to facilitate sales.
The show features multiple voicemails addressing various topics: Albert Pujols' underrated status in the hobby despite Hall of Fame credentials, potential celebrity-athlete crossover cards, Paul George's reliability concerns, collection transfer logistics, and advice on selling bulk cards (dollar boxes, Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist). One caller challenges the host about accidentally revealing collection location details (middle name, distance from house, proximity to studio) in a previous episode, leading to a playful wager about finding the collection's location.
The hosts discuss merch offerings, noting that new hoodies will be available for winter and that existing athletic wear runs large. They address AI-generated images of themselves appearing online and discuss issues with previous website imagery.
Toward the end, a listener replays audio from the very first episode (January 28, 2021), highlighting predictions Mike made about 2020 NFL wax boxes and Zion Williamson that proved accurate. This prompts a Rushmore ranking of past show producers, with Brendan, Dev, Farkas, and Carlos/Mike mentioned as top contributors.
The episode concludes with discussion of the 2026 MLB rookie class being exceptionally strong, teasing breakdown content for Monday's episode.
About this episode
Mike and Jesse open by discussing Kevin O'Leary's cringey CNBC appearance with his cards and why Mike doesn't take O'Leary seriously. Plus, we dive into the NFL rookie class and look at how Cooper Flagg and Wemby might carry the 2026 NBA rookie class until they start playing better. Joe Bartel from RotoWire and the SCN Challenge Show joins to look at the NFL market and how the rookies are playing. Will Fernando Mendoza and Carson Beck starting help the 2026 NFL products? Wrap up with voicemails! 0:00 - Intro to the show 1:15 - Kevin O’Leary was on Opening Bell discussing cards as assets. 8:20 - Mike looks at O’Leary and doesn’t take him seriously, but Jesse thinks enough people do that we should at least listen to him. 10:00 - NFL needs the two rookie quarterbacks starting this week to help the NFL product. Inception has tanked. 13:45 - Positive Mike is all aboard the Paul George hype train 16:45 - Cooper Flagg is coming out firing to start the season, and while his card market is down, Mike and Jesse wouldn’t sell him now. 21:20 - What happens to the show if Jesse dies? 27:00 - Joe joins the show 29:30 - Fernando Mendoza stepping into a difficult schedule before the bye. 32:10 - Carson Beck card market will struggle, like the Cardinals. 35:00 - 2026 NFL Rookie class has been really rough, so the PREM1ERE Patch Autos will help the 2026 product. 38:15 - Contender or Pretender 45:00 - Wrap up with Joe 46:00 - Mike’s update on his 25k collection 54:00 - Trove Pack Battle 56:50 - Voicemails presented by DCSports87 58:45 - Is Albert Pujols the most underrated player in hobby history? 1:06:00 - Interesting athlete/entertainer crossover dual autos 1:23:00 - All-Time Producer rankings and how Mike got the guys fired from The Ringer Use Code SCN10 for 10% off your first purchase of SCN Merch! Follow Sports Cards Nonsense: TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@sportscardsnonsense Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/sports_cards_nonsense/ Twitter: https://x.com/SCN_Pod Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/sportscardsnonsense Newsletter: https://collectibleslife.beehiiv.com/subscribe SCN Challenge: https://scnchallenge.com/ Linktree: https://linktr.ee/SportsCardsNonsense?utm_source=linktree_profile_share&ltsid=5764ed98-4893-4eae-bf91-0bd89949ed99 Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Key Insights
- The hosts argue that two rookie quarterbacks starting simultaneously is beneficial for the hobby because it provides consistent chase value across multiple products throughout the season, unlike limited product releases with individual player patches
- Kevin O'Leary's theatrical presentation style is criticized as cringy by hobby insiders, but his wealth and media platform may still drive new money into the market from older, affluent investors unfamiliar with cards
- Paul George cards present a timing dilemma where players should sell despite good current performance because his age (36) and documented injury history make future value uncertain, contrasting with younger players worth holding long-term
- Collections worth $7-figure amounts without proper estate planning create probate nightmares because heirs with no hobby knowledge cannot accurately value or sell specialized collectibles efficiently
- The show's audience consists primarily of existing collectors and sports fans, as evidenced by one listener expressing surprise that an actual woman listens to the podcast
- Dual-signature celebrity-athlete cards face limited market appeal because buyers typically specialize in either the celebrity or athlete, creating pricing conflicts that hurt overall value
- Albert Pujols and Miguel Cabrera are systematically undervalued in the hobby despite Hall of Fame credentials and 700-plus home runs, suggesting collective amnesia rather than market accuracy
- Brendan's six-month tenure as producer already qualifies for top-tier ranking based on longevity compared to previous producers who lasted weeks or months
- The first episode's predictions about 2020 NFL rookies and Zion Williamson proved accurate, suggesting early analysis had legitimate analytical foundation despite informal presentation
- Card grading costs ($200 for vintage packs) can eliminate profitability on otherwise valuable collections if grading doesn't authenticate or if cards come back inauthentic
- Sellers anchored to holding complete collections often miss profit windows because they refuse to separate high-end cards from bulk inventory, sacrificing negotiating power
- PSA vaults enable passive monetization of graded cards through automatic offers, reducing need for active selling and allowing cards to sit until premium offers arrive
Topics
Transcript
Before we start, a quick word from our sponsor, eBay Live. If you've never checked it out, eBay Live is eBay's live shopping experience built for collectors. It's where you find rare, exclusive, and hard-to-find items through live auctions and special drops you can only get there. What makes it different is the energy in the community, real sellers, engaging hosts like SportsCards Nonsense, and streamers that make it fun and interactive. It's all backed by eBay's protection and authenticity guarantees, so you can shop with confidence. Just download the eBay app and hit the eBay Live button under the search bar and jump in. Now back to your show. Low energy, unfocused, foggy, you might be dehydrated. Whether it's…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Sports Cards Nonsense
The One Card You Could Never Let Go | With Tory from DCSports87
A sports collectibles podcast featuring discussions about eBay's 2026 collectibles report, trading card market trends, an upcoming Andrew Jones autograph signing event on eBay Live, and pack battle games on the Trove platform. The hosts interview Tory from DCSports87 about their consignment service and Adam Ireland from eBay about collectibles trends, viral moments, and market data.
One New Chase + One Trivia Question = 2 Hours of Banter
A Sports Cards Nonsense episode featuring Mike, Brendan, and guest hosts discussing recent card acquisitions (including Mark Belanger cards and vintage photography), diving into Shohei Ohtani's all-time baseball ranking, exploring 500 home run club PC building, and comparing equivalent statistical milestones across sports (10,000 rushing yards in football).
Mike and Jesse Put Each Other on the Hot Seat
Mike and Jesse discuss their respective trips to card shows—Jesse attended the Toronto Expo with Upper Deck where he met Wayne Gretzky, while Mike visited the Boston Shriners show and acquired a large collection. They answer voicemails about lost mail, subscription services, and create a sports movie Mount Rushmore challenge.
If the Market is Slowing Down, What is the Main Reason?
The hosts discuss the slowdown in the sports card market, particularly in wax pricing and grading accessibility, while exploring factors affecting collector engagement. They provide advice for new collectors on budget allocation and introduce guest Cooper DeGene, an NFL player new to card collecting.
Are We Headed for a Market Downturn?
In this Monday episode of Sports Cards Nonsense, the hosts discuss market conditions showing both strength (record $1B monthly volume) and weakness (slower breaks, expensive wax), recap a tense card show incident, and feature an interview with Phil from Sealed Wax Nation about their charitable initiatives donating to children's hospitals.