Mike and Jesse Put Each Other on the Hot Seat
Mike and Jesse discuss their respective trips to card shows—Jesse attended the Toronto Expo with Upper Deck where he met Wayne Gretzky, while Mike visited the Boston Shriners show and acquired a large collection. They answer voicemails about lost mail, subscription services, and create a sports movie Mount Rushmore challenge.
Summary
The episode opens with Jesse returning from Toronto, where he attended the Toronto Expo card show sponsored by Upper Deck. He rates the show 8-9 out of 10, comparing it favorably to the National show. Jesse describes the venue as massive with over 1,000 tables, primarily featuring hockey cards (50-60%), followed by Pokemon TCG (25%), and mixed baseball, basketball, and football. The show benefits from favorable exchange rates for American buyers, with Canadian dollars appreciating significantly. Jesse emphasizes the show's quality inventory, including rare vintage cards and high-value pieces. He was surprised at SCN's limited recognition in Canada despite some fans recognizing him as the show progressed.
A major highlight was an exclusive event at the Toronto Maple Leafs practice facility and Hockey Hall of Fame, where Jesse met Wayne Gretzky for an Upper Deck announcement regarding a new Walter Gretzky resource center and Gretzky becoming Upper Deck's second legacy partner (alongside Michael Jordan). Jesse asked a humorous question referencing Michael Scott's famous "you miss 100% of shots you don't take" quote, noting the irony that this was actually Gretzky's father's wisdom. Jesse received a signed Wayne Gretzky hockey puck as a gift.
Mike then discusses his Boston trip, where he attended the Shriners card show with his family and friend Russ. He highlights three extraordinary cards: a rare 1915 Type 1 Babe Ruth rookie photograph (worth ~$150,000+), multiple raw Bobby Orr rookies from packs, and a raw Tom Brady Contenders rookie autograph worth $70,000-$80,000. Mike encounters his old acquaintance John Ryan, who in 2008 bought Mike's card collection for $1,000, enabling Mike's move to Nashville with his fiancée—a transaction that Mike credits with changing his life trajectory.
Mike also acquired a large collection from a local dealer named Kelly for $20,000, consisting of approximately 16-19 rows of cards, multiple binders, hockey boxes, sealed 1986 Fleer Jordan packs, and a case of 1998 Upper Deck Tiger Woods rookie cards. He plans to partner with DC Sports for an eBay Live auction of the hockey portion and systematically process lower-end cards for eBay Live content.
The show includes four voicemails: DJ reporting a missing PSA 9 1995-96 Finest Michael Jordan card allegedly taken by a postal worker; a caller asking why Card Ladder is better than Market Movers subscription service; a caller suggesting that doom-and-gloom market commentators are actually trying to buy the dip; and James matching all four Topps Chrome Cosmic inserts and donating a $100 Moby Dickies gift certificate.
For the Mount Rushmore sports movie characters challenge, the hosts attempt to guess James's four picks. Mike's picks include Norman Dale (Hoosiers), Roy Hobbs (The Natural), and Coach Herb Brooks (Miracle). Jesse selects Henry Rowengardner (Rookie of the Year), Happy Gilmore, Coach Herman Boone (Remember the Titans), and the Sandlot kid. Sterk contributes Lou Brown from Major League. They match two out of four (Happy Gilmore and Coach Boone), earning a donation to Sealed Wax Nation.
The episode concludes with discussion of ongoing Patriots struggles, potential Thursday show guests, and promotion of the SCN Challenge show, which has been reduced from over an hour to 50 minutes. Brendan sets a 42-minute target for upcoming episodes.
About this episode
Mike and Jesse are back from their respective trips. Jesse went to Toronto for the Toronto Sports Card Expo, and Mike went to Boston for some family time and a card show. So what was the scene like in Toronto for Jesse? It went so well that Mike and Jesse want the whole team to go next year. Jesse was hanging out with Jeremy Lee, who had an amazing showcase, and it spun into a conversation about how card shows need to hire security these days. Mike saw the guy who bought out the entire showcase, who helped him buy his engagement ring for his wife, and a card show 20 years later. Plus, we wrap up with an abbreviated Voicemails section. 0:00 - Intro to the show 3:00 - Jesse went to the Toronto Expo, and Upper Deck dominated the space 14:50 - Jeremy Lee had some incredible cards - over $6M in cards in one display alone 21:00 - The crowd was Hockey first, Pokémon second, the rest of the sports a distant third 24:30 - It was a much younger crowd than the National 30:15 - Need Shane to make a clip to send to Upper Deck to get Jason Masherah to put us up for a weekend in Toronto 33:10 - Jesse got to meet Wayne Gretzky and asked about the famous The Office meme. 43:00 - Mike in the hot seat after his weekend in Boston 46:55 - Three things Mike saw he’d never seen in person - Babe Ruth team photo, a raw Tom Brady Contenders auto, and something else big! 54:30 - Mike saw the dealer who bought him out so he could buy an engagement ring for his wife 58:10 - Mike bought 19 4-row boxes and multiple binders for 20 grand. 1:06:10 - Voicemails 1:13:00 - Is the market down, or are influencers trying to buy lower? Follow Sports Cards Nonsense: TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@sportscardsnonsense Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/sports_cards_nonsense/ Twitter: https://x.com/SCN_Pod Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/sportscardsnonsense Newsletter: https://collectibleslife.beehiiv.com/subscribe SCN Challenge: https://scnchallenge.com/ Linktree: https://linktr.ee/SportsCardsNonsense?utm_source=linktree_profile_share&ltsid=5764ed98-4893-4eae-bf91-0bd89949ed99 Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Key Insights
- Jesse found the Toronto Expo superior to other shows due to favorable exchange rates for American buyers, with $100 USD equaling ~$140 Canadian, making pricing advantages significant for international purchasers
- The Toronto Expo is Upper Deck-focused with minimal representation from Topps and Panini, creating a distinct market environment compared to National shows dominated by multiple card manufacturers
- Mike credits a single $1,000 card purchase decision by John Ryan in 2008 as life-altering, as it funded his engagement ring and move to Nashville, demonstrating the profound impact individual transactions can have on collectors' lives
- Raw high-grade cards sitting at shows create both opportunities and risks, as illustrated by the raw Tom Brady Contenders rookie worth $70,000-$80,000 that Mike chose not to purchase due to authentication concerns
- Wayne Gretzky is treated as a cultural icon in Canada comparable to or exceeding political figures, with media asking him questions about Trump and Canadian politics at a card-related event
- Security concerns at high-value card shows have increased, with dealers like Jeremy Lee employing armed guards and restricting photography due to fears of being targeted after home invasions
- Pokemon cards represent approximately 25% of inventory at the Toronto Expo, making them the clear number-two category after hockey and indicating strong Canadian collector interest in TCG products
- Large collection acquisitions (like Mike's $20,000 purchase) require strategic planning for monetization, with different platforms (eBay Live, PSA submissions, partner dealers) serving different inventory segments
- Sports movie character collectibility doesn't necessarily correlate with character prominence, with defensive linemen having more trading market presence than offensive linemen despite the latter's critical importance
- The exchange rate advantage created by Canadian currency appreciation makes the Toronto Expo a potentially profitable opportunity for American dealers who buy and resell domestically
- Card show characters and local dealer relationships create network effects where collectors encounter the same vendors across multiple decades and different geographic locations
- High-grade sealed products from the 1980s-1990s (like 1986 Fleer Jordan packs and 1998 Upper Deck Tiger Woods cases) represent significant value concentration in collection acquisitions
Topics
Transcript
Before we start, a quick word from our sponsor, eBay Live. If you've never checked it out, eBay Live is eBay's live shopping experience built for collectors. It's where you find rare, exclusive, and hard-to-find items through live auctions and special drops you can only get there. What makes it different is the energy in the community, real sellers, engaging hosts like SportsCards Nonsense, and streamers that make it fun and interactive. It's all backed by eBay's protection and authenticity guarantees, so you can shop with confidence. Just download the eBay app and hit the eBay Live button under the search bar and jump in. Now back to your show. He's like, you know, I buy in bulk if you're…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Sports Cards Nonsense
One New Chase + One Trivia Question = 2 Hours of Banter
A Sports Cards Nonsense episode featuring Mike, Brendan, and guest hosts discussing recent card acquisitions (including Mark Belanger cards and vintage photography), diving into Shohei Ohtani's all-time baseball ranking, exploring 500 home run club PC building, and comparing equivalent statistical milestones across sports (10,000 rushing yards in football).
The NFL Rookie Class is Getting a Much-Needed Boost | With Joe Bartel
The hosts discuss NFL rookie quarterbacks finally starting in Week 9, Kevin O'Leary's controversial sports card promotion, and a deep collection evaluation of a 20,000-card purchase. They also cover financial planning for card collections, produce pack battles, and reminisce about the show's early episodes from 2021.
If the Market is Slowing Down, What is the Main Reason?
The hosts discuss the slowdown in the sports card market, particularly in wax pricing and grading accessibility, while exploring factors affecting collector engagement. They provide advice for new collectors on budget allocation and introduce guest Cooper DeGene, an NFL player new to card collecting.
Are We Headed for a Market Downturn?
In this Monday episode of Sports Cards Nonsense, the hosts discuss market conditions showing both strength (record $1B monthly volume) and weakness (slower breaks, expensive wax), recap a tense card show incident, and feature an interview with Phil from Sealed Wax Nation about their charitable initiatives donating to children's hospitals.
An Update from PSA Collectors Have Wanted to Hear
Sports Cards Nonsense hosts interview Daylon and Amanda from Junk Wax Vintage about their journey from meeting on Coffee Meets Bagel to building a successful card content empire across multiple platforms, while discussing PSA's service tier reopening, celebrity involvement in the hobby, and the importance of consistency in content creation.