DiscussionOpinion

One New Chase + One Trivia Question = 2 Hours of Banter

Sports Cards Nonsense1h 42m

A Sports Cards Nonsense episode featuring Mike, Brendan, and guest hosts discussing recent card acquisitions (including Mark Belanger cards and vintage photography), diving into Shohei Ohtani's all-time baseball ranking, exploring 500 home run club PC building, and comparing equivalent statistical milestones across sports (10,000 rushing yards in football).

Summary

The episode opens with Mike receiving anniversary gifts from Jesse, including a rare 2002 Tom Brady card and Mark Belanger cards that were humorously inscribed with 'pervert' by Shep. This leads into a broader discussion about personal collection (PC) philosophy, with Mike defending his choices of Ken Griffey Jr., Larry Bird, and Tom Brady as collecting subjects, while acknowledging the importance of personal stories and texture in PC building versus collecting purely established greats.

Mike then showcases a collection of late 1970s and early 1980s baseball cards known for their distinctive photography, including players like Bobby Bonds, Lee Tunnel, Joe Patini, and Roger Craig, emphasizing the joy of purchasing bulk lots and sorting through cards—describing it as 'the greatest feeling of all time' in the hobby.

The hosts discuss Mike's new project: building a complete Topps Five Star 500 Home Run Club autograph set, targeting all 28 members with Five Star cards specifically. He's already secured Frank Robinson and Eddie Matthews as cut autos, with Mickey Mantle and Ted Williams offering booklet auto options. The challenge involves acquiring cards from deceased players with limited availability.

A substantial portion examines whether Shohei Ohtani, with four MVPs and two runner-up finishes in six seasons, plus the only 50-50 season, qualifies as a top-10 all-time hitter. The hosts conclude that while his peak is extraordinary, established careers from Willie Mays, Babe Ruth, Barry Bonds, Hank Aaron, Stan Musial, Mike Schmidt, and Alex Rodriguez still surpass his career totals to date. They debate how the pitch clock rule and larger bases have inflated Ohtani's stolen base numbers compared to historical context.

The conversation extends to comparing statistical milestones across sports: 500 home runs in baseball equals approximately 10,000 rushing yards in football. The hosts work through the top rushers (Emmitt Smith, Walter Payton, Frank Gore, Barry Sanders, etc.) and receivers (Jerry Rice, Terrell Owens, Randy Moss, Larry Fitzgerald, etc.) with similar longevity requirements.

Multiple voicemails are featured, including questions about opening a card shop (Mike is interested but time-constrained), equivalent PC opportunities in football (10,000 yards receiving/rushing), PSA grading thresholds and turnaround times, best practices for first-time submissions, and why quarterback cards command premium prices. Final discussion includes Drake May's season-ending injury and Mike Vrabel's pre-game drinking in Germany before a poor Patriots performance.

About this episode

With Jesse out, Mike Sterk and Brendan Darr are back with Mike Gio to discuss anything and everything hobby-related going on. Looking at the greatness of Shohei Ohtani and putting the proper context into how insane this recent run is and how it is impacting his market. Plus, how Mike's latest set build brought on the Ohtani discussion and whether Mike should prepare and get an Ohtani just in case. Plus, Mike, Mike, and Brendan look at other current players who could join the 500-homer club and what the equivalent chase would be for football. Is it 5,000-yard passers? 2,000-yard rushers? And some trivia to go along with those. Finally, we hit some voicemails to clear out the backlog. Follow Sports Cards Nonsense: https://www.tiktok.com/@sportscardsnonsense https://www.instagram.com/sports_cards_nonsense/ https://x.com/SCN_Pod https://www.facebook.com/groups/sportscardsnonsense https://collectibleslife.beehiiv.com/subscribe https://scnchallenge.com/ https://linktr.ee/SportsCardsNonsense?utm_source=linktree_profile_share&ltsid=5764ed98-4893-4eae-bf91-0bd89949ed99 Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Key Insights

  • Mike argues that personal connection and storytelling matter more in PC building than collecting purely based on player greatness, citing Mark Belanger as an example of a less famous player whose cards hold meaning through shared memories with his father.
  • The hosts claim that late 1970s and early 1980s baseball cards featured superior photography and aesthetic quality compared to modern production, making them valuable for set-building purely from a visual standpoint.
  • Mike asserts that going through bulk card lots and sorting them is the single greatest feeling in the hobby, ranking it above breaking, digital products, and all other collecting experiences.
  • The analysis concludes that Shohei Ohtani's four MVPs in six seasons represents an elite peak comparable only to Babe Ruth and Barry Bonds, but his career totals do not yet match established all-time greats.
  • The hosts argue that Ohtani's 50-50 season may be statistically inflated by MLB rule changes (pitch clock, larger bases, two-disengagement limit) compared to historical stolen base accomplishments.
  • Mike claims that building a Topps Five Star 500 home run club set is feasible but challenging due to limited availability of cut autos and booklet cards for deceased players, particularly Mel Ott and Babe Ruth.
  • The comparison reveals that approximately 28-32 players have achieved 10,000 rushing yards (football equivalent to 500 home runs in baseball), making it a comparable but slightly more common statistical milestone.
  • Mike argues that he would fund and partner with Shep's card shop but cannot personally operate a shop due to time constraints, potential conflicts of interest, and the difficulty of maintaining objectivity while running a retail business.
  • The hosts contend that in baseball more than other sports, cumulative milestone statistics (300 wins, 3,000 hits, 500 home runs) define all-time greatness more than peak performance alone.
  • Mike asserts that big men in basketball (centers) sell considerably less than guards playing the same positions, creating a market inefficiency where equivalent players at different positions have vastly different card values.
  • The discussion concludes that PSA grading turnaround times are improving for top-tier submissions but remain problematic for standard tier submissions, with some cards still being held for months without grading.
  • Mike recommends against grading unknown or unproven rookie cards immediately, advocating instead for selling them raw at market peak before grading, using Dylan Harper as an example where value dropped significantly mid-grading process.

Topics

Personal card collecting philosophy and PC buildingShohei Ohtani all-time ranking debate500 home run club autograph set projectLate 1970s/early 1980s baseball card photographyStatistical milestones comparison across sportsPSA grading turnaround times and submission best practicesCard shop opening possibilityFootball rushing yard milestonesMark Belanger's defensive excellenceCollectibility factors in sports cardsFootball season injuries and performanceMount Rushmore card discussions

Transcript

Before we start, a quick word from our sponsor, eBay Live. If you've never checked it out, eBay Live is eBay's live shopping experience built for collectors. It's where you find rare, exclusive, and hard-to-find items through live auctions and special drops you can only get there. What makes it different is the energy in the community, real sellers, engaging hosts like SportsCards Nonsense, and streamers that make it fun and interactive. It's all backed by eBay's protection and authenticity guarantees, so you can shop with confidence. Just download the eBay app and hit the eBay Live button under the search bar and jump in. Now back to your show. Get this. When you're with Xfinity, you're already a member.…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Sports Cards Nonsense

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.