Are We Headed for a Market Downturn?
In this Monday episode of Sports Cards Nonsense, the hosts discuss market conditions showing both strength (record $1B monthly volume) and weakness (slower breaks, expensive wax), recap a tense card show incident, and feature an interview with Phil from Sealed Wax Nation about their charitable initiatives donating to children's hospitals.
Summary
The episode opens with discussion of the recent Nashville card show, which was notably slower than previous years, attributed to Halloween weekend and families being occupied with kids. While the show had good foot traffic Friday, Saturday saw early departures and reduced energy. The hosts received multiple reports from vendors and attendees about slower breaks and reduced spending, though they note this is partly seasonal and partly due to wax pricing reaching $8,500-$9,000 per case for highly anticipated products like Cosmic Baseball.
A significant portion covers a confrontation at the show involving a new collector who was sold a quad patch Brady/Rodgers/Manning/Palmer card with a crease by vendors who refused to make it right. The host purchased the card from the collector for $100 compensation. The hosts express frustration with vendors taking advantage of newcomers and threaten to identify and blacklist the perpetrators.
Despite perceived market softness, the hosts contextualize October's $1 billion monthly card volume as a record high, noting this could represent a new floor rather than a downturn. They attribute market pullback factors to expensive wax pricing forcing selective purchases, weak NFL/NBA rookie classes lacking sought-after cards, concern about the baseball strike, and typical seasonal spending patterns. The single market shows selective weakness in GOAT rookie cards while vintage and non-rookie Brady cards remain stable.
The show features an interview with Phil Karnakis, president of Sealed Wax Nation, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit that breaks sealed wax boxes to raise money for children's hospitals. Phil discusses his 30-year legal career, previous collections sales, and plans for nationwide charitable donations with stops already completed in Connecticut, New York, Atlanta, and Nashville. The break of a Disney Sapphire box yielded a rare Elsa card valued around $20,000, with proceeds going to Vanderbilt Children's Hospital. Phil emphasizes introducing the hobby to children during difficult medical experiences and plans for additional fundraiser events in 2027.
Product release discussion covers an unusually compressed week with Topps Heritage Football, Topps Flagship Basketball, Cosmic Baseball, and Inception Football all releasing within days, with combined invoices exceeding $500,000. The Chrome Update pre-sale experienced technical failures including a 10-15 minute outage followed by 18-minute wait queues. Fanatics Fest 2027 was announced for June 24-27 at the Javits Center, shifted to align with the NBA draft.
The episode includes a pack battle on Trove (the new digital repack exclusive partner) and extensive voicemail segment featuring callers asking about beautiful cards, Mount Rushmore of baseball prospects, running backs for one-yard touchdowns, and proper pronunciation of 'raw cards' (not 'rock hard'). Larry returns with philosophical musings comparing SCN to biblical narratives. James questions whether private sales like the alleged $50M Mickey Mantle 1952 card matter to the hobby, with hosts dismissing the unconfirmed story as irrelevant to market health. Merchandise store launch is teased for Black Friday with hats, tees, hoodies, and other items.
About this episode
Mike and Jesse open the show discussing The Nashional and what the environment was like at the show. Plus, a story from Mike about having to intervene on behalf of a listener with a scummy dealer. Are we facing a market downturn, or are consumers just being more selective about what they buy? Phil from Sealed Wax Nation stops by after an event at Vandy Children's Hospital this morning. Plus, another disappointing drop from Topps. 0:00 - Show Intro, The Nashional Recap 6:50 - People are more selective about breaks these days. Are they holding out for their preferred product, or is it a sign of trouble in the market? 15:00 - Gio is furious and rants after a kid got ripped off at The Nashional 18:15 - Mike reveals a custom Bill Simmons/Mike Gio dual cut auto 23:15 - Another issue with a big release. 26:30 - Intro to Phil and what he’s doing with charity with Sealed Wax Nation 39:30- Getting to be part of the Vandy/Ryan Seacrest studio and giving kids packs 49:20 - Voicemails presented by Heystack and kicking off with Larry 1:06:30 - The Mickey Mantle $50M sale that has never been confirmed Follow Sports Cards Nonsense: Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/@sportscardsnonsense Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/sports_cards_nonsense/ Twitter: https://x.com/SCN_Pod Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/sportscardsnonsense Newsletter: https://collectibleslife.beehiiv.com/subscribe SCN Challenge: https://scnchallenge.com/ Linktree: https://linktr.ee/SportsCardsNonsense?utm_source=linktree_profile_share<sid=5764ed98-4893-4eae-bf91-0bd89949ed99 Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Key Insights
- The Nashville card show had its slowest attendance in years, primarily because Halloween fell on Saturday and many collectors stayed home with their families rather than attending.
- Wax pricing at $8,500-$9,000 per case for Cosmic Baseball is forcing collectors to be more selective about which products to purchase, causing some collectors to skip intermediate releases entirely.
- The hosts argue that October's record $1 billion in monthly card volume suggests the hobby has found a new price floor rather than indicating a downturn is beginning.
- Weak rookie classes in football (no sought-after stars), combined with baseball concerns about a potential strike, are contributing to reduced collector enthusiasm compared to previous years.
- The NFL and NBA have shifted to focus exclusive licensing with Fanatics, which represents a fundamental business change that attracted new money and collectors to the hobby.
- Sealed Wax Nation has completed four charitable hospital donations and plans a national tour with the specific goal of introducing children experiencing medical crises to the hobby as a form of escape.
- The hosts received at least 15 separate reports from card show attendees about breaks not filling as easily, suggesting a broader market perception of slowdown even if volume data shows strength.
- Private sales of ultra-rare cards like the alleged $50 million Mickey Mantle have no impact on the broader hobby market since such cards never re-enter public circulation.
- Topps' website infrastructure continues to fail during high-traffic pre-sale events, causing customers to wait 18+ minutes in queues, which the hosts characterize as a recurring problem.
- The hosts discovered a vendor/dealer connection at the show where a new collector was deliberately sold a damaged quad patch card, with the dealers refusing to acknowledge the defect or provide compensation.
- Fanatics Fest's relocation from July to late June aligns with NBA draft timing rather than market demands, suggesting strategic scheduling around basketball rather than collector convenience.
- The hobby's mainstream attention and billion-dollar valuations have attracted vendors with poor ethics, and the hosts pledge to use their platform to identify and exclude such vendors from future shows.
Topics
Transcript
Before we start, a quick word from our sponsor, eBay Live. If you've never checked it out, eBay Live is eBay's live shopping experience built for collectors. It's where you find rare, exclusive, and hard-to-find items through live auctions and special drops you can only get there. What makes it different is the energy in the community, real sellers, engaging hosts like SportsCards Nonsense, and streamers that make it fun and interactive. It's all backed by eBay's protection and authenticity guarantees, so you can shop with confidence. Just download the eBay app and hit the eBay Live button under the search bar and jump in. Now back to your show. I try to not get angry like that anymore because…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Sports Cards Nonsense
The One Card You Could Never Let Go | With Tory from DCSports87
A sports collectibles podcast featuring discussions about eBay's 2026 collectibles report, trading card market trends, an upcoming Andrew Jones autograph signing event on eBay Live, and pack battle games on the Trove platform. The hosts interview Tory from DCSports87 about their consignment service and Adam Ireland from eBay about collectibles trends, viral moments, and market data.
One New Chase + One Trivia Question = 2 Hours of Banter
A Sports Cards Nonsense episode featuring Mike, Brendan, and guest hosts discussing recent card acquisitions (including Mark Belanger cards and vintage photography), diving into Shohei Ohtani's all-time baseball ranking, exploring 500 home run club PC building, and comparing equivalent statistical milestones across sports (10,000 rushing yards in football).
The NFL Rookie Class is Getting a Much-Needed Boost | With Joe Bartel
The hosts discuss NFL rookie quarterbacks finally starting in Week 9, Kevin O'Leary's controversial sports card promotion, and a deep collection evaluation of a 20,000-card purchase. They also cover financial planning for card collections, produce pack battles, and reminisce about the show's early episodes from 2021.
Mike and Jesse Put Each Other on the Hot Seat
Mike and Jesse discuss their respective trips to card shows—Jesse attended the Toronto Expo with Upper Deck where he met Wayne Gretzky, while Mike visited the Boston Shriners show and acquired a large collection. They answer voicemails about lost mail, subscription services, and create a sports movie Mount Rushmore challenge.
If the Market is Slowing Down, What is the Main Reason?
The hosts discuss the slowdown in the sports card market, particularly in wax pricing and grading accessibility, while exploring factors affecting collector engagement. They provide advice for new collectors on budget allocation and introduce guest Cooper DeGene, an NFL player new to card collecting.