DiscussionOpinion

Now is the Time to Reinvest in PC Cards

Sports Cards Nonsense1h 26m

Sports Cards Nonsense podcast discusses reinvesting in PC (personal collection) cards, noting market cooling after recent highs makes it a good buying opportunity. The show covers product releases, voicemail segments from listeners, and interviews CEO Jared Cavley of Pristine Auctions about the memorabilia market.

Summary

The episode opens with sponsor announcements for eBay Live and Disney's Hexed movie. The hosts discuss why now is a good time to buy personal collection cards, noting that after the National card show, prices for established players like Brady and Griffey have cooled significantly from recent highs. Brady's high-end cards have dropped substantially (e.g., from $35,000 to $22,000 for certain cards), making this a better entry point for collectors than the frenzied market of recent months. The hosts attribute this partly to market saturation and fatigue, and note they're personally motivated to rebuild PC collections due to a combination of holiday nostalgia and concerns about rapid technological change (AI) making people seek connection to familiar things.

The show features extensive voicemail segments addressing various topics: V&A asks about tracking inventory and profit for card sellers with growing collections; James from South Carolina asks for the top five events impacting the hobby since COVID (answers include stimulus checks, Fanatics acquiring Topps licensing, PSA consolidation, influencer marketing, and nostalgia-driven spending from older collectors); Tanner from Nashville asks about favorite card brands aesthetically (hosts cite Cosmic Baseball and EX Century from the past). A tragic story surfaces about a vendor whose car was broken into at a Starbucks, resulting in $200,000 in stolen cards and inventory.

Product reviews highlight 2026 Topps Five Star Baseball (releases Wednesday, expensive at $2,000/box but includes six encased cards), and especially Cosmic Baseball (releases next Wednesday, described as the hosts' favorite product of the year). The hosts plan aggressive breaks and personal box sales for Cosmic.

Sean O'Neill contributes throwback audio clips from the podcast's first episode (January 28, 2021) discussing the Super Bowl matchup between Buccaneers and Chiefs, with discussion of Brady card pricing from that era compared to current values. The hosts use this to reflect on how predictions and card values have evolved.

The episode culminates with an extended interview with Jared Cavley, CEO and founder of Pristine Auctions. Cavley discusses how he started in the hobby as a kid, got frustrated ripping packs, pivoted to getting memorabilia signed at spring training, and eventually launched Pristine Auctions with his wife. He emphasizes that Pristine focuses on accessibility for everyday collectors, offering pieces across all price points from $72 Ray Lewis jerseys to six-figure presidential signed pieces. Notable recent sales include a Jackie Robinson rookie graded 7, Jordan Nike rookie graded 10, and a presidential piece signed by every U.S. president. Cavley runs 10-minute timed auctions throughout the day (noon to midnight Arizona time) and emphasizes building an entry-level collector base. His personal basketball Mount Rushmore includes Michael Jordan, Steve Nash (his favorite player and PC focus), Kobe Bryant, and Devin Booker, and his white whale card is a Jordan graded 10.

About this episode

After a busy weekend, Mike and Jesse are back, and Mike takes a trip down Nostalgia Lane to explain why buying PC cards again is the right idea in today's market. Plus, we look ahead to a few upcoming baseball products, including Mike's favorite set of the year. We hit voicemails, and interview Jared with Pristine Auctions! 0:00 - This is the perfect time to buy PC cards again 5:25 - Some individual cards and players got out of whack over the summer, but things have slowed down a bit post-National 12:20 - Will the new Dak Prescott “F*ck Cancer” card be the new Billy Ripken error card? 16:00 - Card Show safety etiquette after a dealer was robbed of over $200k of cards leaving a show.  21:55 - Looking back at Consiglieri Corner 28:00 - Topps Five Star Baseball preview and looking ahead to Cosmic Chrome Baseball 33:00 - Voicemails presented by eBay 41:35 - Best way to keep track of buying/selling at shows or in general 44:00 - Mike is still waiting on a redemption from Panini 52:15 - How AI is impacting the card hobby 56:15 - The biggest factors for the hobby boom 1:05:50 - How Jared wanted to get into selling collectibles 1:14:40 - Art and coins are two of the areas that Pristine is really looking to grow.  1:19:20 - Basketball Mt. Rushmore: Jordan, Kobe, Steve Nash, and Devin Booker Follow Sports Cards Nonsense: Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/@sportscardsnonsense Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/sports_cards_nonsense/ Twitter: https://x.com/SCN_Pod Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/sportscardsnonsense Newsletter: https://collectibleslife.beehiiv.com/subscribe SCN Challenge: https://scnchallenge.com/ Linktree: https://linktr.ee/SportsCardsNonsense?utm_source=linktree_profile_share&ltsid=5764ed98-4893-4eae-bf91-0bd89949ed99 Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Key Insights

  • The hosts argue that after recent market peaks, cooling prices for established players like Brady and Griffey represent better buying opportunities for personal collection builders without the risk of immediate depreciation.
  • Brady's high-end cards have experienced significant declines from recent highs, with some ultraviolet inserts dropping from $35,000 to $22,000, suggesting broader market fatigue rather than product-specific issues.
  • The hosts believe nostalgia-driven collecting is being amplified this year partly due to widespread anxiety about AI and technological change, causing people to seek comfort in familiar hobby pursuits.
  • Tracking profits in card dealing requires systematic spreadsheet management by deal or lot, with the hosts noting that without organization, sellers can lose visibility into whether they're actually profitable despite feeling busy.
  • Stimulus checks, Fanatics' acquisition of Topps licensing, influencer marketing, PSA consolidation, and generational wealth of aging collectors are cited as the five most impactful events on the hobby since 2020.
  • Jared Cavley attributes Pristine Auctions' success to deliberately building an entry-level collector base through marketing and accessible pricing rather than chasing only high-end seven-figure memorabilia pieces.
  • Pristine Auctions' 10-minute timed auction format (12 auctions every 10 minutes) is designed to create urgency and move volume, making it fundamentally different from traditional longer auction formats.
  • The hosts note that while 2021 predictions about Brady and Mahomes cards holding significant value have been partially correct, Mahomes' pricing has not appreciated as dramatically as initially projected.
  • Card grading impacts value significantly, with PSA 10 versions of the same card often commanding double or more the price of PSA 9 versions, exemplified by Brady Contenders rookies.
  • The podcast's first episode in January 2021 discussed Brady Bowman Chrome BGS 9.5 rookies at $4,500-$11,000, which are now worth approximately $20,000 for PSA 10s, illustrating significant appreciation over five years.
  • Jared Cavley emphasizes that his personal preference for memorabilia over cards stems from the desire to get closer to the sport itself, prioritizing meeting players and obtaining signed pieces over owning unsigned collectibles.
  • The hosts argue that without organized inventory tracking and profit documentation, card dealers operating with large collections tend to operate on instinct and rough estimates rather than precise financial data.

Topics

Personal collection (PC) card buying strategy and market timingCard pricing trends and market cooling after recent highsTracking inventory and profitability for card sellersHobby trends since COVID-19 pandemicCosmic Baseball product release and expectationsPristine Auctions business model and accessibilityPodcast history and evolution since 2021Sports card market nostalgia and AI-driven sentimentMemorabilia vs. sports cards collectingUpcoming Nashville card show and eBay Live selling

Transcript

Before we start, a quick word from our sponsor, eBay Live. If you've never checked it out, eBay Live is eBay's live shopping experience built for collectors. It's where you find rare, exclusive, and hard-to-find items. Through live auctions and special drops, you can only get there. What makes it different is the energy in the community. Real sellers, engaging hosts like SportsCardsNonsense, and streamers that make it fun and interactive. It's all backed by eBay's protection and authenticity guarantees, so you can shop with confidence. Just download the eBay app and hit the eBay Live button under the search bar and jump in. Now back to your show. From the creators of Zootopia and Frozen comes Disney's Hexed. Welcome…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Sports Cards Nonsense

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.