DiscussionOpinion

Navigating a Potential Ohtani Market Crash

Sports Cards Nonsense1h 43m

A sports cards and collectibles podcast discussing Shohei Ohtani's declining market value, the 2024 NFL season outlook with guest Joey Bartle, and a blind ranking of six items from Pristine Auctions. The hosts also cover WNBA card market trends with guest Meg and announce Jesse's upcoming trip to Toronto for Upper Deck hockey announcements.

Summary

The episode opens with sponsors eBay Live and HubSpot before diving into the main topic of Shohei Ohtani's card market correction. The hosts debate whether this represents a genuine crash or normal market fluctuation, noting that while Ohtani's cards have dropped 15-20% over the past 45 days, he remains a first-ballot Hall of Famer with four MVPs. They argue both things can be true: he can be an all-time great while experiencing temporary market corrections. The comparison is made to Patrick Mahomes, whose market recovered after similar concerns. The hosts emphasize that now is not the time to sell if holding long-term, but also not ideal for buying yet as there may be more room to fall.

Guest Joey Bartle provides a six-week NFL season assessment, characterizing it as underwhelming with limited rookie impact outside of CJ Stroud. Major injuries to quarterbacks like Jalen Hurts have reshaped the landscape. Bartle discusses Brock Purdy's 142% increase in value over six months, making him likely a top-8 most valuable quarterback by season's end, though this partly reflects the decline of others. The discussion covers Marvin Harrison Jr.'s trade to Houston, comparing it unfavorably to Emmanuel Sanders' mid-season move in 2019, and notes that mid-season receiver trades historically don't pan out. Bartle advocates for buying CJ Stroud over Jordan Love or Trevor Lawrence, citing the Texans' defensive potential.

The show features a blind ranking segment of six Pristine Auction items: a Sammy Sosa signed card (ranked 2nd by Sterk, 3rd by Jesse, 4th by Gio), a Craig T. Nelson autographed Mr. Incredible card (5th by Sterk), a 1986 Fleer Larry Bird PSA 10 (1st by Sterk, 4th by Jesse, 2nd by Gio), dual-autographed 1993 Star Wars Darth Vader card (4th by Sterk, 1st by Jesse, 3rd by Gio), a 1986 Fleer Basketball pack PSA 8 (6th by Sterk, 6th by Jesse, 5th by Gio), and an autographed photo from the TV show Newsroom (1st by Gio, 5th by Jesse, 6th by Sterk). The exercise reveals differing collecting philosophies among the hosts.

Guest Meg from We The Hobby discusses WNBA card markets, noting that Caitlin Clark's market dominance has peaked while other rookies like A'ziah Fudd and Olivia Miles are gaining value. She explains that while Clark's cards remain saleable, the market has begun diversifying. The hosts discuss Paige Beckers, Cameron Brink, and Angel Reese's market positions, with Meg noting that Clark's presence changed the women's game similarly to how Steph Curry changed the NBA. She expresses concern about the WNBA's missed marketing opportunities post-Clark entry, though the league did better this season in promoting other players. The discussion covers Panini's licensing agreement and product release schedule for WNBA cards.

Voicemails include Beefcake from Boston noting significant increases in 1990s basketball inserts, particularly the 1992-93 Beam Team set, with a PSA David Robinson selling for over $100 compared to previous $20-50 range. Franco, not Wander, congratulates Gio on an anniversary and proposes couples jiu-jitsu lessons. The hosts close by announcing the charity auction starting November 7th on eBay for 2024 Disney Sapphire box characters, with 66.6% of proceeds going to Vanderbilt Children's Hospital. Jesse also announces an upcoming trip to Toronto on November 6th to cover Upper Deck's hockey announcements at the Hockey Hall of Fame during an expo.

About this episode

Shohei Ohtani is struggling, and the Dodgers are on the verge of elimination. How to deal with the Ohtani market crash. Plus, will we ever hear from Justin Steele again? Tough to say! Geoff Wilson's latest comments have caught the ire of Mike, and he tees off on them. Joe Bartel from RotoWire joins to look ahead to Week 6 in the NFL. Who is a buy and sell right now? Plus, we do a Top 6 Blind Ranking courtesy of Pristine Auctions. 0:00 - Ohtani's market is crashing, but is it time to sell? 11:50 - Can Ohtani catch Bonds’ MVP record? That looks like the only way his market goes up exponentially again 19:15 - Will we ever hear from Justin Steele again? 22:30 - Grading sketch cards, is it worth it? 27:00 - Getting at Geoff Wilson over some incredibly dumb tweets 31:00 - Everyone hates redemptions; this isn’t new 33:45 - Joe Bartel of RotoWire  40:40 - The Trevor Lawrence conundrum - time to buy back in? 50:00 - Who would you sell right now? 57:05 - We need sports/non-sports crossovers 1:02:00 - Pristine Auctions Top 6 1:14:00 - Voicemails brought to you by Arena Club 1:15:30 - Meg from We The Hobby on the WNBA Market Follow Sports Cards Nonsense: https://www.tiktok.com/@sportscardsnonsense https://www.instagram.com/sports_cards_nonsense/ https://x.com/SCN_Pod https://www.facebook.com/groups/sportscardsnonsense https://collectibleslife.beehiiv.com/subscribe https://scnchallenge.com/ https://linktr.ee/SportsCardsNonsense?utm_source=linktree_profile_share&ltsid=5764ed98-4893-4eae-bf91-0bd89949ed99 Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Key Insights

  • Ohtani's 15-20% market decline over 45 days represents significant correction but not catastrophic crash, with most believers expecting further temporary decline before recovery
  • Being an all-time great player and experiencing temporary market corrections are not mutually exclusive conditions, as demonstrated by historical comparisons to active GOATs like LeBron James
  • The gambling controversy surrounding Ohtani's interpreter could theoretically impact long-term value if the player became implicated, though some believe sufficient financial incentives exist for others to take responsibility
  • Mahomes' market experienced similar correction in 2023 before rebounding, suggesting patient holders of premium quarterback cards can recover losses
  • The 2024 NFL season has produced limited rookie impact outside of CJ Stroud, with injuries and underperformance creating what one guest characterized as an underwhelming landscape
  • Brock Purdy's 142% six-month value increase significantly outpaces other quarterbacks partly due to low initial expectations and lack of early career availability of cards
  • Mid-season receiver trades historically fail to produce fantasy or card value improvements, with Emmanuel Sanders in 2019 being the last meaningful exception that coincided with a Super Bowl run
  • Caitlin Clark's entry into WNBA changed the sport's trajectory similarly to Steph Curry's impact on the NBA, establishing her as singular generational talent rather than one of many
  • WNBA card market is diversifying away from Caitlin Clark dominance, with rookie classes of 2024 gaining value even as Clark's market caps, unlike typical single-star correction patterns
  • 1990s basketball insert cards experienced significant price appreciation driven by nostalgia-fatigued collectors pivoting from new product or price-shocked younger investors seeking established players
  • Panini releases approximately three WNBA products annually, providing limited product variety compared to legacy sports
  • Upper Deck's hockey licensing represents strategic investment in market segment with embargoed announcements suggesting significant category expansion

Topics

Shohei Ohtani card market correction2024 NFL season overview and rookie performanceBrock Purdy market value trajectoryMid-season NFL trade impact on card valuesBlind ranking exercise with Pristine Auctions itemsWNBA card market trends and Caitlin Clark saturation1990s basketball insert price increasesCharity auction for Vanderbilt Children's HospitalUpper Deck hockey expansion announcementCollectibles market diversification

Transcript

Before we start, a quick word from our sponsor, eBay Live. If you've never checked it out, eBay Live is eBay's live shopping experience built for collectors. It's where you find rare, exclusive, and hard-to-find items. Through live auctions and special drops, you can only get there. What makes it different is the energy in the community. Real sellers, engaging hosts like SportsCardsNonsense, and streamers that make it fun and interactive. It's all backed by eBay's protection and authenticity guarantees, so you can shop with confidence. Just download the eBay app and hit the eBay Live button under the search bar and jump in. Now back to your show. Running a growing business means doing all the things. Campaign things.…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Sports Cards Nonsense

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.