DiscussionNews

Survey Says…

Moody's Talks - Inside Economics1h 9m

Mark Zandi and co-hosts discuss recent inflation data showing CPI rose 0.6% month-over-month and 3.7% year-over-year, driven primarily by energy prices from the Iran war. While acknowledging inflation concerns, they explore whether inflationary pressures are broadening beyond energy, examine weak consumer sentiment despite resilient spending, and discuss how AI and geopolitical uncertainty are reshaping economic expectations.

Summary

The podcast opens with banter about Chris's absence in Bermuda before diving into economic data. The main focus is September's inflation report, where CPI came in hotter than expected at 0.6% month-over-month (up from expected levels) and 3.7% year-over-year (up from 3.4%). Matt Collier, the data analyst, attributes the primary driver to energy costs, with gasoline up 9% and averaging $4.35-$4.36 per gallon in September, up 30 cents from August.

A key surprise was that food-at-home prices (groceries) fell 0.1% despite energy increases, suggesting consumers are trading down to cheaper alternatives and retailers lack pricing power due to consumer demand destruction. Coffee prices rose nearly 1% due to weather, while beef declined for three consecutive months, possibly due to relaxed tariffs on Brazilian beef. Core CPI, excluding food and energy, rose 0.33% month-over-month and 2.6% year-over-year, showing an acceleration from the 2.4% recorded earlier.

The hosts debate whether the Iran war is the primary inflation driver or if broader inflationary pressures are emerging. Matt argues that if you remove the war's impact, headline CPI would be around 2.5% year-over-year—still above the Fed's 2% target but in a "tolerable" range. He notes second-order effects appearing in transportation and warehousing costs as businesses pass through diesel expenses. However, he hasn't yet observed a wage-price spiral, which would be the transmission channel for persistent inflation.

John Lear from Morning Consult provides consumer sentiment data, noting that sentiment has declined from early 2026 levels, with the Iran war and elevated gas prices serving as the "straw that broke the camel's back." He observes significant heterogeneity across regions and income groups, with a fragmentation score reaching series highs. Notably, Republican sentiment has deteriorated recently as the Iran war persists longer than the expected three-month duration, whereas Republicans held out hope during the tariff disputes of 2025.

The group discusses the disconnect between weak sentiment and resilient spending. John explains that while sentiment has weakened, employment remains strong, and consumers have become "very thoughtful" in their spending allocations, particularly lower and middle-income households who trade down on groceries and manage gas expenses carefully. Some cash-flush renters—those who saved down payments but couldn't afford homes due to affordability crisis—maintain spending despite sentiment weakness.

On the Fed's policy stance, John argues that current interest rates are not restrictive despite headline concerns, noting that real rates remain low by historical standards and financial conditions don't show signs of restraint given massive AI infrastructure investment. Marissa pushes back, noting that mortgage rates have risen, representing tightening in housing conditions, though John attributes housing challenges more to fiscal issues than Fed policy.

The group addresses AI's dual role: contributing more to growth than inflation currently, but also creating demand-side inflationary pressures through data center construction and chip demand. They debate whether the Fed should slow AI investment to combat inflation, with concerns that targeting AI specifically while leaving the non-AI economy vulnerable could create asymmetric slowdown risks.

On political implications, John notes that Trump is now underwater in traditionally Republican strongholds like Texas and Kansas based on Morning Consult's state-level data. Interestingly, data center regulation has emerged as a bipartisan priority, with Republicans and Democrats strongly agreeing that banning data centers should be a top Congressional priority—though this reflects concerns about cost pressures rather than pure regulation.

Positive notes include strong sentiment among AI-using workers, who view AI as complementary and productivity-enhancing. Additionally, approximately 4% of the population reports starting or considering starting businesses due to AI's cost reduction in business formation. The group emphasizes that while housing affordability and energy prices dominate complaints, innovation and business optimism provide counterbalancing factors.

The podcast concludes with a trivia game on generational slang (where "the ick" and "skibidi" appear as correct answers) and a discussion of upcoming data releases, including Conference Board and Michigan consumer sentiment surveys, FOMC meeting preparations, and earnings season from bellwether companies like 3M and Moody's.

About this episode

John Leer, Chief Economist at Morning Consult, joins Inside Economics to discuss the mood of the consumer. John shares some interesting nuggets from Morning Consult’s survey, including differences in sentiment across regions, how consumers are feeling about AI and data centers, the job market, the War in Iran, and what this may mean for the upcoming Midterm Elections. Matt Colyar also makes an appearance and gives the group the run-down of this week’s CPI and PPI reports, which both came in hotter than expected. But first, Mark quizzes the Millennials in the group on their knowledge of Gen Z slang words.

Key Insights

  • September's 0.6% monthly CPI increase was primarily driven by energy prices, with gasoline rising 9% to average $4.35-$4.36 per gallon, up 30 cents from August, reflecting the Iran war's direct impact on fuel markets.
  • Grocery prices fell 0.1% month-over-month despite elevated energy costs because consumers engaged in demand destruction and trading down to cheaper alternatives, preventing retailers from passing through full cost increases due to lack of pricing power.
  • Removing the Iran war's impact from current inflation would lower headline CPI to approximately 2.5% year-over-year, still above the Fed's 2% target but in a 'tolerable' range that wouldn't necessarily warrant aggressive rate hiking.
  • A wage-price spiral transmission channel has not yet emerged, as the labor market is currently weaker than in 2022 and consumers are not demanding raises at elevated rates compared to previous years.
  • Consumer sentiment has weakened significantly in 2026, with the Iran war serving as the primary catalyst, whereas 2025's sentiment challenges were concentrated among lower-income adults due to tariff uncertainty.
  • Republican sentiment has recently deteriorated as the Iran war extended beyond the expected three-month duration, contrasting with their more optimistic outlook during 2025's tariff disputes when they held hope for positive outcomes.
  • Morning Consult's daily sentiment survey data shows 104 out of 106 major metropolitan areas experienced 10 percentage point or higher declines in consumer sentiment over two years, indicating a broad geographic deterioration.
  • Current Federal Reserve interest rates are not restrictive by multiple measures: real rates remain low by historical standards, financial conditions show no signs of restraint given massive AI investment, and loan activity remains robust.
  • AI is contributing to economic growth at approximately double the magnitude of its inflation contribution, creating a policy dilemma where slowing AI to combat inflation would require slowing the non-AI economy below potential growth rates.
  • Data center regulation has emerged as a rare bipartisan priority, with both Republicans and Democrats ranking it among top Congressional priorities, reflecting underlying concerns about cost pressures rather than purely ideological opposition.
  • Employed workers using AI in their workplaces report strong optimism about AI as a complement to their work, claiming increased productivity, though this may reflect adverse selection bias as these are self-selected AI adopters.
  • Approximately 4% of the U.S. population reports starting or considering starting a business due to AI's reduction in the cost of capital required for business formation, suggesting AI may unlock a period of broad innovation.

Topics

Inflation data and CPI reportEnergy prices and Iran war impactConsumer sentiment and spending behaviorFederal Reserve monetary policyAI infrastructure and economic growthHousing affordability crisisWage growth and real earningsRegional and income-group economic heterogeneityPolitical implications and 2026 electionsTariffs and trade policyData center regulationConsumer behavior and demand destruction

Transcript

. Welcome to Inside Economics. I'm Mark Zandi, the Chief Economist of Moody's Analytics, and I'm joined by one of my trusty co-hosts, Marisa, Marisa Giannattali. Hey, Marisa. Hey, Mark. How are you doing? I'm doing well. Good morning. Good morning. I hear Chris is in Bermuda. That's what I heard. Is that right? Do you know? I didn't know that. But he does this every year. Why does he get to go to Bermuda? Why don't I ever get to go to Bermuda? Well, that's a great question. I think he's there for the insurance industry hangs out in Bermuda, I think on a regular basis. I think, and I think so he goes for incoming hurricanes, I guess.…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Moody's Talks - Inside Economics

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.