Surprise Surprise
Inside Economics hosts discuss October's surprisingly strong jobs report showing 165,000 payroll gains with significant upward revisions, debating whether the strength is real or noise-driven. The panel also analyzes the 2026 midterm election results showing major Democratic gains, particularly in traditionally Republican areas, and explores potential legislative gridlock and macroeconomic implications.
Summary
The episode opens with a detailed examination of October's employment data. The payroll survey showed 165,000 jobs added with total revisions of 84,000 across prior months, suggesting nearly 250,000 jobs of improvement. However, panelists express skepticism about the headline number, noting unusual concentration in professional business services (70,000 gains) and healthcare. Dante D'Antonio was forecasting 50,000 jobs prior to the report and maintains that underlying job growth remains around 50,000 despite the headline surprise. The panel notes significant divergence between the payroll survey and other labor market indicators like ADP (which showed professional services declining 27,000) and Revealio Labs (showing nearly flat private sector growth). Marissa Di Natale highlights historically elevated volatility in monthly payroll figures and points to a concerning rise in part-time workers for economic reasons (up 300,000), which the BLS specifically called out. The household survey showed the unemployment rate ticking lower on the strength of both labor force participation gains and employment increases, with the adjusted household employment measure showing 850,000 jobs added—increasingly aligned with payroll figures after months of divergence. Break-even unemployment discussion reveals disagreement: Dante sees 50,000 as the neutral rate, while Chris Tarides argues for 40,000, suggesting current underlying growth exceeds break-even. The panel's consensus on underlying trend remains 60,000-70,000 jobs monthly, with acknowledgment that the report overstates actual labor market strength despite containing real information.
About this episode
Colleagues Brendan La Cerda and Dante DeAntonio join Inside Economics to discuss surprising results on both the midterm election and the October jobs report. The discussion focuses on jobs first, and it was hard to find a blemish in the latest data, as job growth far exceeded expectations and the unemployment rate ticked lower. The conversation then turned to the midterm elections as Brendan detailed the magnitude of the Democratic swing in the House and Senate. However, the large margin of victory will do little to move the macroeconomic needle as legislative gridlock remains the baseline expectation.
Key Insights
- October's 165,000 payroll gain appears significantly inflated with nearly half (49%) attributable to a single industry—professional business services (70,000 jobs)—which contradicts ADP data showing declines of 27,000 in the same sector.
- The panel identifies historically elevated volatility in monthly payroll figures as unusual outside of recession/recovery periods, suggesting data quality issues or structural changes in survey methodology.
- Despite strong headline job gains, alternative labor market indicators (ADP, Revealio Labs, JOLTS) signaled much weaker growth prior to the report, suggesting the market consensus for 50,000 monthly jobs is more accurate than the headline.
- The household survey and payroll survey gap has narrowed from 2.5 million in June to 1.2 million in October, indicating improved data consistency and suggesting the recent strength is partially real rather than purely statistical noise.
- Underlying trend job growth likely remains 60,000-70,000 monthly according to panel consensus, contradicting the headline 165,000 figure and suggesting the report provides mixed signals rather than confirmation of labor market acceleration.
- Democrats gained control of congressional districts won by Trump by 7.6 percentage points in the previous presidential election, indicating electoral shifts in traditionally conservative areas rather than uniform partisan realignment.
- With only one district where Biden won now represented by a Republican, Democrats face an asymmetric advantage in House-Senate alignment that protects their majority despite razor-thin margins.
- Republicans control the legislative calendar through December with only 60% probability of passing a reconciliation budget that would lock Democrats out of budget leverage for fiscal year 2027.
- If Republicans fail to pass a reconciliation bill in the lame duck, Democrats gain significant leverage in 2027 through simultaneous control of both budget and debt ceiling negotiations.
- Brendan identifies federal debt ceiling increase as unlikely inclusion in lame-duck reconciliation, with some Republicans potentially preserving it as future minority leverage against Democratic negotiations.
- Fed independence gained protections through Democratic Senate control, preventing Trump appointees lacking independence commitments from reaching confirmation as previously expected.
- Trump's extreme unpopularity on data center deregulation (polling below 'abolish ICE' and comparable to unpopular positions like trans athlete restrictions) may constrain his ability to sustain deregulation policy against Democratic state-level regulation.
Topics
Transcript
Welcome to Inside Economics. I'm Mark Zande, the Chief Economist of Moody's Analytics, and I'm joined by my two trusty co-hosts, Marissa Di Natale, Chris Tarides. Hi, guys. Hey, Mark. Hey, Mark. Hi, Chris. Good to see you guys. Good to see you guys. And let's not beat around the bush. Let's introduce our other guests, Dr. D'Antonio. Dante D'Antonio. Doctor, how are you? I'm doing all right, Mark. How are you? Good, good. It's Jobs Friday, obviously, and got to talk jobs and all the things related to that. And we've got another guest, Brendan Lucerta. Hey, Brendan. Great to be here. Thanks for having me. Oh, geez. Dante, what the hell? I don't know. He hasn't read the…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Moody's Talks - Inside Economics
Are We in a Disaster Movie?
Mark Zandi and his team at Moody's Analytics discuss recent market turbulence driven by AI stock corrections, outages, and cybersecurity concerns, while welcoming sales leader Noah Berliner to explain how economic intelligence now fuels the modern sales process and that despite confusion about AI implementation, businesses remain focused on growth.
Wending Our Way Through the CPI
The Inside Economics podcast team discusses a surprisingly hot October CPI report showing headline inflation at 0.4% monthly (4% year-over-year) and core CPI at 0.3% monthly (2.8% year-over-year), both exceeding expectations. The hosts debate whether this signals persistent inflation driven by energy and tariffs or emerging demand-side pressures, with Fed officials signaling potential rate hikes in December and beyond.
Charlie Cook on the Election
Charlie Cook, a renowned political analyst, discusses the 2024 midterm elections with Moody's Analytics economists, explaining how the race shifted dramatically in late summer when Republican support collapsed in rural farming areas. He predicts Democrats will gain approximately 20+ House seats and potentially win 5+ Senate seats, making it a surprisingly strong performance given typical midterm dynamics.
Strong on Paper
The Moody's Analytics team discusses strong Q3 GDP growth of 3.4%, driven by consumer spending and AI investment, but express concerns about weakening momentum heading into Q4 with falling savings rates and flat September spending. They debate whether the Fed should raise rates in December given that most inflation appears supply-driven rather than demand-driven, with the Fed characterizing growth as 'strong' despite signs of consumer stress.
AI Series: Live From New York
A panel of economists from Moody's Analytics discusses four AI scenarios for the economy: a baseline graceful integration, a stock market correction, job dislocation, or an upside boom. While they largely agree AI won't cause job apocalypse, they assign significant probabilities to market corrections and express concern about uniform thinking across the industry.