Charlie Cook on the Election
Charlie Cook, a renowned political analyst, discusses the 2024 midterm elections with Moody's Analytics economists, explaining how the race shifted dramatically in late summer when Republican support collapsed in rural farming areas. He predicts Democrats will gain approximately 20+ House seats and potentially win 5+ Senate seats, making it a surprisingly strong performance given typical midterm dynamics.
Summary
Charlie Cook, founder of the Cook Political Report, joins Mark Zandi, Marissa Di Natale, Chris, and Justin Begley from Moody's Analytics to analyze the 2024 midterm elections. Cook explains his background, having worked in politics for over 50 years and transitioning from party-affiliated work to independent analysis by starting his business in 1984 with just $16,000 in combined personal savings and bank loans.
Cook describes how midterm elections typically disadvantage the sitting president's party, but this election presented structural guardrails that seemed to protect Republicans: fewer competitive congressional districts than 20 years prior and a favorable Senate map with Republicans defending seats in Trump-won states. However, the race fundamentally transformed in August-September when Republican support, particularly in rural and farming-adjacent areas, collapsed. This shift was driven by economic factors including elevated energy costs from the Strait of Hormuz disruption, tariffs affecting farmers and ranchers disproportionately, and fertilizer costs.
On House elections, Cook predicts Democrats will gain north of 20 seats (bringing them to 230+), which he calls "a done deal" and "bigger upset than Hillary Clinton in 2016" if Republicans hold the majority. The House gains would give Democrats enough seats to avoid being held hostage by 3-4 members. On Senate elections, Cook predicts Democrats will achieve a 5-seat net gain (51-49), creating what he calls a "Fetterman-proof" majority to account for the Pennsylvania senator's unpredictability. This contradicts his earlier assessment from six months prior.
Cook identifies Michigan's Senate race as the most consequential for the Democratic Party's future direction. If progressive candidate Abdul El-Sayed beats Republican Mike Rogers, it signals to progressives they can run candidates anywhere; if he loses decisively, it sends the opposite message about candidate compatibility with state electability. On Texas, Cook expects Democrat James Tallarico to win the Senate race primarily because Republican nominee Ken Paxton has excessive ethical baggage, making it more about candidate quality than partisan trends. He notes that if generic Republicans held the presidency, several Senate races (North Carolina, Georgia, Texas) would likely be safely Republican.
Cook emphasizes that polling quality has dramatically declined due to methodological challenges—high costs of quality research, caller ID, and panel effects. He recommends only trusting high-quality polls from New York Times/Siena, CNN, Fox, NBC/Wall Street Journal, and Pew Research, dismissing most public polling as "junky." He critiques relying on national generic ballot tests and prediction markets, arguing they're less valuable than understanding state-specific dynamics and monitoring where party organizations spend their research budgets.
Regarding 2028 presidential prospects, Cook suggests Democratic nominees will likely be pragmatically focused on candidates who've won statewide in purple states like Pennsylvania, Michigan, Arizona, or North Carolina—candidates who've had to appeal beyond their party base. He dismisses prediction markets as thinly traded and easily manipulated, expressing skepticism toward incorporating them into quantitative models.
About this episode
Charlie Cook, founder of the Cook Political Report and Washington’s “election oracle,” joins the Inside Economics crew to preview the upcoming midterm elections. Charlie shares how he got his start, the story behind founding the Cook Political Report, and how he became one of the most trusted voices in election forecasting. He then digs into the dynamics of the House race and the key Senate contests, predicting that Democrats will win both chambers. Charlie also explains why this cycle is unusual. Our own election forecaster Justin Begley joins the conversation to give the Moody’s Analytics outlook.
Key Insights
- Cook argues that Republican support collapsed in rural farming areas during August-September specifically due to compounding economic pressures from energy costs following the Strait of Hormuz disruption, tariffs affecting farmers and beef imports, and elevated fertilizer and diesel costs that disproportionately harmed people with pickup trucks and farm equipment.
- Cook contends that 90-95% of publicly available polling, particularly state-level polling, is of poor quality because news organizations stopped paying for expensive quality research, and recommends only using high-quality polls from organizations like New York Times/Siena, CNN, Fox, and Pew Research.
- Cook claims that party campaign organizations spending patterns reveal their internal polling more accurately than public polls do, and that observing where Democrats unexpectedly invested resources (like Mississippi and South Carolina) indicated the race had fundamentally shifted.
- Cook argues that Michigan's Senate race outcome will determine the Democratic Party's strategic direction in 2026-2028, with Abdul El-Sayed's victory signaling progressives can run ideologically extreme candidates anywhere, versus a loss signaling they cannot.
- Cook asserts that prediction markets are thinly traded, easily manipulated, and reflect the biases of their participants rather than genuine information advantage, with few Democrats betting on Republicans or vice versa, making them unsuitable for incorporating into quantitative election models.
- Cook maintains that national generic ballot tests have declined in predictive value as competitive races have become geographically concentrated and unrepresentative of actual swing districts, with generic Democrat leads of 7-13 points not reflected in polls of likely voters in lean-Republican and toss-up races (showing only 2-3 point leads).
- Cook explains that candidate quality has become more critical in adverse midterm environments, with mediocre Republican candidates who previously won in safe Republican areas now struggling because "in a bad year, when your side's under a lot of pressure, mediocrity doesn't cut it so well."
- Cook proposes that successful 2028 presidential nominees should have prior statewide electoral experience in purple or swing states where they had to appeal beyond their partisan base, arguing this criteria should matter more than ideological purity or popularity metrics among party activists.
Topics
Transcript
Welcome to Inside Economics. I'm Mark Zandi, the Chief Economist of Moody's Analytics, and I'm joined by one of my trusty co-hosts, Marissa Di Natale. Hey, Marissa. Hey, Mark. How are you doing? I'm doing well. You know, I'm a new grandfather. I am happy to say. I know. That's so exciting. Congratulations. Yeah. Wesley Williams Zandy Young. What do you think? It's a mouthful, but I like it. You do like it. Yeah, I like it a lot. You wouldn't say otherwise. I would off tape. Off tape. No, I like it a lot. Well, I was joking. That's really nice. I was talking to my brother, Carl, who we all know. And Carl said he's going to call…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Moody's Talks - Inside Economics
Are We in a Disaster Movie?
Mark Zandi and his team at Moody's Analytics discuss recent market turbulence driven by AI stock corrections, outages, and cybersecurity concerns, while welcoming sales leader Noah Berliner to explain how economic intelligence now fuels the modern sales process and that despite confusion about AI implementation, businesses remain focused on growth.
Wending Our Way Through the CPI
The Inside Economics podcast team discusses a surprisingly hot October CPI report showing headline inflation at 0.4% monthly (4% year-over-year) and core CPI at 0.3% monthly (2.8% year-over-year), both exceeding expectations. The hosts debate whether this signals persistent inflation driven by energy and tariffs or emerging demand-side pressures, with Fed officials signaling potential rate hikes in December and beyond.
Surprise Surprise
Inside Economics hosts discuss October's surprisingly strong jobs report showing 165,000 payroll gains with significant upward revisions, debating whether the strength is real or noise-driven. The panel also analyzes the 2026 midterm election results showing major Democratic gains, particularly in traditionally Republican areas, and explores potential legislative gridlock and macroeconomic implications.
Strong on Paper
The Moody's Analytics team discusses strong Q3 GDP growth of 3.4%, driven by consumer spending and AI investment, but express concerns about weakening momentum heading into Q4 with falling savings rates and flat September spending. They debate whether the Fed should raise rates in December given that most inflation appears supply-driven rather than demand-driven, with the Fed characterizing growth as 'strong' despite signs of consumer stress.
AI Series: Live From New York
A panel of economists from Moody's Analytics discusses four AI scenarios for the economy: a baseline graceful integration, a stock market correction, job dislocation, or an upside boom. While they largely agree AI won't cause job apocalypse, they assign significant probabilities to market corrections and express concern about uniform thinking across the industry.