DiscussionNews

Wending Our Way Through the CPI

Moody's Talks - Inside Economics1h 9m

The Inside Economics podcast team discusses a surprisingly hot October CPI report showing headline inflation at 0.4% monthly (4% year-over-year) and core CPI at 0.3% monthly (2.8% year-over-year), both exceeding expectations. The hosts debate whether this signals persistent inflation driven by energy and tariffs or emerging demand-side pressures, with Fed officials signaling potential rate hikes in December and beyond.

Summary

The podcast opens with Mark Sandy, Marissa DiNatelli, and guest Matt Collier (calling in from Moody's new London office) analyzing the October CPI report released the previous day. Matt characterizes the consecutive months of disappointing inflation data as falling into the 'borderline disturbing' territory cited by Chicago Fed Chair Goolsbee.

On headline numbers, the October CPI came in at 0.4% month-over-month (rounded up from 0.35%), exceeding the 0.28% consensus expectation. Core CPI surprised even more, hitting 0.3% versus an expected 0.17-0.22%. Year-over-year rates show headline CPI at 4% and core CPI at approximately 2.8% when extrapolated with available data (since year-over-year comparisons to October 2024 were unavailable due to last year's federal government shutdown).

The team identifies several upside surprises. Food inflation, which had been dormant, surged 0.5% month-over-month with broad-based increases across proteins (0.5%), eggs (0.6%), dairy (0.6%), and produce (0.6%). Matt attributes this partly to higher diesel costs affecting transportation through supply chains, citing consistency with hot September PPI transportation numbers. However, he notes this is only one month of data and food inflation remains near 2% year-over-year.

Services inflation proved concerning across multiple categories. Owner's equivalent rent (OER) was stronger than expected at 0.32% monthly, with particular strength in Midwest housing markets, though this is characterized as likely a measurement artifact rather than fundamental trend. Regular rent came in at a more modest 0.2% monthly, consistent with weak market rents at 2.8% year-over-year. Lodging away from home (hotels/motels) surged 0.6%, which the hosts interpret as demand-driven rather than supply-side, reflecting wealth effects from stock market gains enabling travel.

'Supercore' services (excluding food, energy, and shelter) accelerated at 0.45% monthly, with notable contributions from motor vehicle insurance (0.7%), intercity transportation (0.6%), and medical care services (0.3%). Transportation service inflation is partially attributable to energy costs, but medical care increases appear more fundamental and persistent.

Marissa adds that these service price increases are appearing across broader categories—recreation, personal services, veterinary services, and education—suggesting the inflation is spreading beyond energy-related components. This breadth concerns her because it could signal the beginning of a wage-price spiral if businesses continue passing through costs and employees demand higher compensation.

The team debates causation. Mark argues that transportation cost inflation is tied to energy and would moderate as oil prices decline. Marissa counters that non-energy services like medical care, education, and lodging suggest a more persistent, demand-driven component. Matt emphasizes that the key concern is breadth: increasing percentages of goods and services showing prices rising above 3%, which is worse than previous reports.

On downside surprises, used vehicle prices fell 0.7% (versus September's 0.7% increase), providing modest disinflationary offset. Otherwise, the report was characterized as broadly weak across most categories.

Regarding the PCE deflator (the Fed's preferred inflation measure), the team projects 0.4% headline PCE inflation for October (3.9% year-over-year) and 0.3% core PCE (3.3% year-over-year), representing an uptick from the mid-3% range that had appeared to be moderating.

Fed reaction has been swift and hawkish. Fed Governor Chris Waller provided unusual specificity in forward guidance, suggesting two potential rate hikes (or one 50-basis-point hike) if core CPI exceeds 0.3%—a threshold that was breached. Dallas Fed Chair Logan echoed this, calling for at least two rate hikes. Two-year Treasury yields spiked 20 basis points, and the 10-year yield moved to 5% on the news. CME Fed Funds futures now price in 100% probability of a December rate hike with 15% odds of a 50-basis-point move.

In the stats game segment, Marissa presents data showing 37% of small businesses (NFIB survey, October) plan to raise prices over the next six months—the highest in four years, coinciding with 2022's peak inflation. Matt highlights that health insurance costs rose 6.3% year-over-year in the consumer expenditure survey (2024-2025), but the CPI health insurance component fell 1.8% month-over-month due to how the BLS measures it based on health insurer retained earnings rather than actual premiums paid. Mark presents baby formula prices surging 5.1% monthly, attributed to reduced discounting by Abbott Labs as demand improved, potential 50% tariffs on imported whey from Canada, and small sample size effects in the data.

A listener question addresses whether gig workers distort unemployment metrics. Marissa explains that gig workers working even one hour count as employed in household surveys, potentially masking true labor market weakness. She notes gig work may replace unemployment insurance given UI's low replacement rate (~33% of wages) and lack of indexing to inflation. However, she observes self-employment rates haven't dramatically increased, and part-time-for-economic-reasons increased in October, suggesting gig work isn't robustly replacing traditional employment.

Mark presents analysis showing AI has been roughly neutral for employment over the past four years (790,000 of 4 million new jobs are AI-related), with wealth effects from rising stock prices contributing more job creation than productivity losses. However, he acknowledges this could reverse once AI's productivity benefits materialize, drawing parallels to the internet boom-bust cycle of the late 1990s and early 2000s.

On wealth inequality, Matt suggests property taxes as a form of wealth tax, while Mark proposes raising or eliminating the Social Security payroll tax cap (currently $136,000-$137,000) to make it apply to earnings above $400,000, improving system solvency while taxing high earners. He also emphasizes education investment and urges deep consideration of policies like wage insurance or universal basic income if AI significantly disrupts income distribution.

About this episode

Matt Colyar joins Mark & Marisa to discuss this week’s CPI report, which came in hotter than expected; some may even say it was “disturbing.” The team discusses the reasons for the upside surprise and debates how much this should worry the Fed. Mark seems more concerned about persistent inflation after playing the stats game. Finally, the team takes a few listener questions about measuring unemployment, AI’s effect on the job market, and how best to address income inequality. Keep the questions, comments, and ratings coming!

Key Insights

  • October's CPI report showed headline inflation of 0.4% monthly (4% year-over-year) and core inflation of 0.3% monthly (2.8% year-over-year), both exceeding consensus expectations, with Chicago Fed Chair Goolsbee characterizing consecutive months of hot data as 'borderline disturbing.'
  • Food inflation surprised to the upside at 0.5% monthly with broad-based increases across proteins, eggs, dairy, and produce, which Matt attributes to higher diesel transportation costs beginning to pass through supply chains after several months of dormancy.
  • Owner's equivalent rent (OER) increased 0.3% monthly, stronger than expected, but this is characterized as likely a measurement artifact by the BLS rather than a fundamental shift, as actual market rents (0.2% monthly) remain consistent with weak fundamentals.
  • Lodging away from home (hotels/motels) surged 0.6% monthly, which the hosts interpret as demand-driven inflation reflecting wealth effects from stock market gains enabling consumer travel rather than supply-side energy cost pass-through.
  • Supercore services (excluding food, energy, and shelter) accelerated at 0.45% monthly with concerning breadth, including motor vehicle insurance (0.7%), intercity transportation (0.6%), and medical care services (0.3%), suggesting inflation is spreading beyond energy-related components.
  • The health insurance component of the CPI fell 1.8% month-over-month for the 11th consecutive month because the BLS measures it based on health insurer retained earnings rather than actual premiums, masking that average households spent $600 more annually on health insurance (a 6.3% increase from 2024-2025).
  • Small businesses' pricing intentions have reached a four-year high, with 37% of NFIB survey respondents planning price increases over the next six months, the highest level since 2022 when headline inflation peaked at 9%.
  • Fed Governor Chris Waller provided unusually specific forward guidance, indicating two potential rate hikes (or one 50-basis-point hike) if core CPI exceeds 0.3%, a threshold that was breached by the October report, signaling market expectations for hawkish December action.
  • AI employment has been roughly neutral over the past four years, with 790,000 of 4 million new jobs AI-related, but wealth effects from rising stock prices have contributed more job creation than productivity losses; however, this dynamic could reverse once AI's productivity benefits materialize.
  • Gig workers and 1099 earners are underrepresented in unemployment statistics because the household survey counts anyone working even one hour as employed, and gig work may be replacing unemployment insurance claims given UI's low 33% replacement rate and lack of inflation indexing.
  • Baby formula prices surged 5.1% monthly, the highest on record, attributed to reduced discounts by Abbott Labs as demand improved, potential 50% tariffs on imported whey from Canada, and small sample size effects in CPI data collection.
  • Mark proposes raising or eliminating the Social Security payroll tax cap (currently $136,000-$137,000) to tax earnings above $400,000, which would improve system solvency while making the income tax more progressive and restoring the tax to cover a similar share of earnings as when it was created in the 1930s.

Topics

October 2025 CPI Report AnalysisInflation Persistence and BreadthFederal Reserve Policy ResponseEnergy Costs and Food InflationServices Inflation and ShelterHealth Insurance Measurement IssuesAI and Employment ImpactWealth Inequality and Policy SolutionsGig Economy and Labor Market MeasurementPCE Deflator ProjectionsFed Forward Guidance and Market ReactionWage Growth and Real Wages

Transcript

Welcome to Inside Economics. I'm Mark Sandy, the Chief Economist of Moody's Analytics, and I'm joined by one of my trusty co-hosts, Marissa DiNatelli. Hey, Marissa. Hey, Mark. How are you doing? I am okay. How are you doing? I'm great. Good, good, good. And where's our other trusty co-host, Chris? I believe he's on business in New York this week. Oh, we'll miss him. We'll miss him. But we've got Matt Collier, our colleague Matt. Hey, Matt. Hey, Mark. Hello, Marissa. Nice to be here. Hey, Matt. You sound clearer than normal. Is that, you got a new mic or something going on or what's going on? You look like you're in a very fancy studio. No, this is…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Moody's Talks - Inside Economics

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.