DiscussionNews

Strong on Paper

Moody's Talks - Inside Economics47m 17s

The Moody's Analytics team discusses strong Q3 GDP growth of 3.4%, driven by consumer spending and AI investment, but express concerns about weakening momentum heading into Q4 with falling savings rates and flat September spending. They debate whether the Fed should raise rates in December given that most inflation appears supply-driven rather than demand-driven, with the Fed characterizing growth as 'strong' despite signs of consumer stress.

Summary

The podcast opens with discussion of Q3 GDP growth coming in at 3.4% annualized, exceeding expectations of 3% and consensus of 3.2%. The team breaks down the components: consumer spending contributed 2.5 percentage points, non-residential business investment (largely AI-related data center spending) added 1.8 points, while trade deficits subtracted over 3 percentage points due to imports of AI infrastructure components. Inventory gains of 1.6 points were notably large, potentially related to oil inventory rebuilding following the Iran conflict. Mark raises concerns that despite strong quarterly GDP, underlying year-over-year growth remains around 2%, below potential, and September personal spending data showed real consumer spending flat month-over-month with declining real disposable income. The team debates whether consumer resilience will persist, with Chris arguing the labor market's strength and wealth effects support continued spending, while Mark points to falling savings rates (3.8%, lowest in 4 years) and weak after-tax disposable income growth as warning signs. On inflation, the PCE deflator rose to 3.6% year-over-year (up from 3.4%), with core PCE at 3.1% (up from 3%), both highest since May. Matt attributes much of this to supply shocks: energy prices (up 5.5% month-over-month), AI-related component inflation, and services like hotels and air travel. Mark argues approximately 50-60 basis points of the 110-basis-point gap from the 2% target stems from supply-side factors the Fed cannot address through rate hikes, leaving only 50 basis points attributable to demand. The team notes that wage growth continues to decelerate (ECI at 3.4% year-over-year), inflation expectations remain well-anchored at 2.35% on 10-year break-evens, and there's no evidence of inflation bleeding into broader wage-price dynamics. Regarding Fed policy, Chair Powell (referred to as Warsh in error) held rates steady but upgraded growth language from 'solid' to 'strong,' which Mark finds excessive. The Fed announced starting in 2027, one of eight annual meetings will become a strategy session without a rate decision, with an additional strategy meeting added in 2028. The team views this change skeptically, questioning what problem it solves. Market discussion centers on equity weakness, particularly in AI and tech stocks, with credit default swap spreads widening for hyperscalers. Chris attributes this to investor scrutiny of negative cash flows at some major AI companies, though notes the pattern of drawdowns and buybacks has repeated several times in 2024. Ten-year Treasury yields have fallen below 5% due to flight-to-quality, but Mark expects they'll hover around 5% unless the Iran conflict resolves and oil prices fall significantly.

About this episode

Big news: Mark became a grandpa, and unlike most data this week, this one won’t be revised. Mark, Marisa, Cris, and colleague Matt Colyar digest the bevy of data released this week, including GDP, PCE, spending, income, and the employment cost index. Mark makes the case for future weakness in spending and growth due to negative real incomes and low saving rates. The rest of the team points out what even a happy new grandpa may be missing: a labor market holding together with low layoffs and spending supported by wealthier households. While Mark is cautious on the economy, the outlook for his grandchild is the one forecast with no downside scenario.

Key Insights

  • Q3 GDP of 3.4% was driven primarily by large inventory gains (1.6 percentage points) and AI-related business investment, but underlying growth excluding these factors would have been closer to 2%, below potential GDP.
  • Real consumer spending was flat in September despite strong Q3 performance, suggesting consumer momentum is fading as stimulus effects from earlier in the year have fully dissipated.
  • Real disposable income after taxes fell 0.3% in September and is only 1% year-over-year, well below the historical 2.5-3% trend, indicating household purchasing power is significantly constrained.
  • The 110 basis point gap between current core PCE inflation (3.1%) and the Fed's 2% target is approximately 50-60 basis points attributable to supply shocks (energy, tariffs, AI components) that monetary policy cannot address, leaving only 50 basis points of demand-driven inflation.
  • Wage growth as measured by the Employment Cost Index continues to decelerate at 3.4% year-over-year, below inflation levels, and shows no signs of accelerating despite tight labor market conditions.
  • Long-term inflation expectations measured by 10-year break-even inflation rates remain stable at 2.35%, suggesting the public does not view current inflation pressures as becoming embedded in the economy.
  • The Fed's characterization of growth as 'strong' rather than 'solid' appears disconnected from underlying economic data showing consumer stress, falling savings rates, and weakening income growth heading into Q4.
  • Equity market weakness in AI and tech stocks may reflect genuine investor concerns about negative cash flows at hyperscalers rather than temporary volatility, representing a shift from earlier 2024 patterns of sustained buying rallies.

Topics

Q3 GDP Growth and ComponentsConsumer Spending and Savings TrendsInflation Analysis (PCE Deflator)Federal Reserve Policy DecisionSupply-Side vs. Demand-Side InflationLabor Market ConditionsEquity Market Correction and AI Stock WeaknessInterest Rate Expectations and Market Pricing

Transcript

welcome to inside economics i'm mark zandy the chief economist of moody's analytics and i'm joined by my two trusty co-hosts marissa di natale chris dreides hi guys hey mark hi mark and we've We got Matt Collier. Hey, Matt. Hello, Mark. How's everybody doing? Everyone is doing very, very well. I was asked to let everyone know that this is, I think, unprecedented. I think we have two podcasts released on the same day. So we earlier taped a conversation with Charlie Cook of the Cook Political Report. It was great. Great timing, obviously, talking about the election that's dead ahead and how that's all going to play out. And now, of course, this podcast where we're going to…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Moody's Talks - Inside Economics

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.