Bending, Not Breaking
Mark Sandy and Chris Dridis from Moody's Analytics discuss lending market trends with John Tuig from Raymond James, covering residential mortgages, commercial real estate, auto loans, and HELOCs. The conversation reveals a bifurcated 2024 with strong first-half lending activity followed by second-half slowdown due to rising rates, while credit quality remains stable despite economic headwinds.
Summary
The podcast opens with the hosts reflecting on a successful New York Outlook conference before introducing guest John Tuig, managing director and loan trading head at Raymond James. Tuig explains whole loan trading—the business of selling complete loans rather than securitized tranches to depositories, private credit firms, and insurance companies. The market operates largely manually through negotiated contracts rather than automated trading.
On current lending conditions, Tuig reports that 2024 shows a stark divide: the first and second quarters were robust with strong origination volumes across most products, but the second half is slowing significantly. Mortgage rates have climbed from 5.9% in March to approximately 7.25% today, directly impacting residential lending. He notes that commercial real estate saw strong growth momentum through mid-year but now faces headwinds as cap rates have risen roughly 50 basis points in the past month, causing deals in the pipeline to require repricing.
Auto lending remains unexpectedly resilient despite affordability concerns. Tuig highlights that roughly 20% of auto payments now reach $1,000 monthly—equivalent to pre-pandemic mortgage payments—yet vehicle sales remain managed around 16 million units annually. Unsecured consumer lending is down due to doubled rates (from 8% to 16%), but credit cards surprisingly show improving delinquencies despite higher gas prices and economic stress.
The most striking trend is the explosive growth of HELOCs, up 13.3% year-over-year—the fastest-growing lending product. Homeowners locked into 3% mortgages are extracting equity through lines of credit rather than refinancing, avoiding the impact of higher rates while accessing needed funds. This benefits depositories as floating-rate HELOCs provide a hedge against their fixed-rate mortgage assets.
On credit quality, mortgage lending has been "too tight" since Dodd-Frank (2014). Residential mortgages show strong underwriting standards. The problematic 2022 auto vintage is aging out, with newer vintages showing better quality. Commercial real estate shows emerging stress, particularly in office properties, though Tuig notes a surprising 47% year-over-year increase in office origination volumes—a bounce off near-zero 2023-24 levels as properties reach bottom valuations and offer meaningful yield spreads over multifamily.
Deposit dynamics are shifting rapidly. Banks are becoming more aggressive about raising deposit rates to combat potential flight, as customers gain easier access to rate information and can move funds more quickly. AI-powered tools could accelerate this trend, though Tuig suggests relationship lending and branch presence still matter, particularly for older generations. Cyber security concerns add another layer of risk, potentially triggering bank runs if major breaches occur at smaller institutions.
Regarding broader economic risks, Sandy identifies two key threats: a correction in equity markets (which could curtail high-net-worth consumer spending driven by AI stock appreciation) and persistently higher rates, which would force borrowers unable to refinance into default situations. Tuig concurs that commercial real estate faces particular vulnerability to rate persistence.
Looking five to ten years ahead, Tuig expects gradual digitalization of loan processes through e-notes, tokenization, and blockchain, requiring massive core system upgrades at depositories. He emphasizes that full digitalization remains years away due to data capture limitations at origination.
About this episode
John Toohig of Raymond James joins Mark and Cris to tell the whole story on whole loan trading and what it says about the health of bank lending. The conversation covers consumer credit, mortgages, and commercial real estate. Activity was strong in the first half of 2026 and weak in the second. John explains why next year may flip the script given high rates. The discussion concludes with concerns about deposit flight and cyber risks in the age of AI. In a rarity, every statistic in the stats game earned Mark’s stamp of approval for relevance and difficulty.
Key Insights
- John Tuig reports that Raymond James' loan trading desk alone traded $8 billion in 2024, and estimates the total whole loan market at hundreds of billions annually, though exact sizing is difficult because the market remains largely manual and negotiated rather than exchange-traded.
- Mortgage origination has bifurcated dramatically: first and second quarter 2024 volumes were robust, but rising rates from 5.9% in March to 7.25% today have caused residential lending to 'hit the skids' in the second half, with mortgage originators expecting further deterioration into Q4.
- HELOCs have become the fastest-growing lending product at 13.3% year-over-year growth, driven by homeowners locked into 3% mortgages who prefer extracting home equity to refinancing at current 7%+ rates, though the HELOC market remains small at approximately $460 billion outstanding compared to $1.6 trillion in auto loans.
- Commercial real estate origination volumes showed strong momentum through mid-2024 but have stalled as cap rates rose approximately 50 basis points in the past month, forcing loans in pipeline for three months to undergo significant repricing moments, creating potential distress.
- Office property lending has rebounded with a 47% year-over-year increase in origination volume according to the MBA, representing a bounce off near-zero volumes in 2023-24 as properties have hit bottom valuations and now offer spreads of SOFR plus 200+ basis points compared to multifamily at SOFR plus 160-175 basis points.
- Auto lending remains resilient despite affordability stress, with approximately 20% of auto payments now reaching $1,000 monthly (the previous benchmark for mortgage payments), yet vehicle sales remain managed at approximately 16 million units annually, suggesting borrower commitment to vehicle ownership.
- Credit card delinquencies have declined despite higher gas prices and economic stress, which Tuig characterizes as a 'head scratcher' and suggests reflects a resilient consumer, contrary to what rising rate environments typically produce.
- Banks are becoming increasingly sensitive to deposit rate competition and are raising rates more aggressively than before, as customers gain easier access to rate information and can move funds more quickly, creating competitive pressure on smaller depositories.
- Torsten Slocke's concerns about AI-powered deposit agents potentially enabling rapid flight to highest-rate providers resonate with Tuig, though he suggests the real driver of current deposit sensitivity is the rate environment itself rather than AI adoption.
- Cybersecurity breaches at smaller banks could potentially trigger a form of bank run as customers flee to larger institutions with better defensive capabilities or to money market funds, though regulators' response mechanisms to such scenarios remain unclear and untested.
- Whole loan market participants are concentrated in mid-sized depositories ($50 billion and down) and community banks, whereas tier-one banks typically operate their own desks; merger activity drives a significant portion of whole loan trading as acquiring institutions divest non-core portfolio segments.
- Full digitalization of loan processes through e-notes, tokenization, and blockchain will require massive core system upgrades at depositories to capture sufficient information at origination, and Tuig estimates this transition will take five to ten years rather than occurring within the next one to two years.
Topics
Transcript
Welcome to Inside Economics. I'm Mark Sandy, the Chief Economist of Moody's Analytics, and I'm joined by one of my trusty co-hosts, Chris Dridis. Hey, Chris. Hey, Mark. It was good to see you yesterday at the conference in New York. Yeah, same here. Same here. Yeah. Doesn't happen that often, so. No, doesn't happen. You get taller every time I see you, though. What's that all about? I don't know. What are you eating? Some kind of special Italian veggie fufu kind of food or something that makes you grow uh you know it's always foo-foo food for me along with a little kombucha all the kombucha yeah yeah that's what it is that's what it is so uh…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Moody's Talks - Inside Economics
Are We in a Disaster Movie?
Mark Zandi and his team at Moody's Analytics discuss recent market turbulence driven by AI stock corrections, outages, and cybersecurity concerns, while welcoming sales leader Noah Berliner to explain how economic intelligence now fuels the modern sales process and that despite confusion about AI implementation, businesses remain focused on growth.
Wending Our Way Through the CPI
The Inside Economics podcast team discusses a surprisingly hot October CPI report showing headline inflation at 0.4% monthly (4% year-over-year) and core CPI at 0.3% monthly (2.8% year-over-year), both exceeding expectations. The hosts debate whether this signals persistent inflation driven by energy and tariffs or emerging demand-side pressures, with Fed officials signaling potential rate hikes in December and beyond.
Surprise Surprise
Inside Economics hosts discuss October's surprisingly strong jobs report showing 165,000 payroll gains with significant upward revisions, debating whether the strength is real or noise-driven. The panel also analyzes the 2026 midterm election results showing major Democratic gains, particularly in traditionally Republican areas, and explores potential legislative gridlock and macroeconomic implications.
Charlie Cook on the Election
Charlie Cook, a renowned political analyst, discusses the 2024 midterm elections with Moody's Analytics economists, explaining how the race shifted dramatically in late summer when Republican support collapsed in rural farming areas. He predicts Democrats will gain approximately 20+ House seats and potentially win 5+ Senate seats, making it a surprisingly strong performance given typical midterm dynamics.
Strong on Paper
The Moody's Analytics team discusses strong Q3 GDP growth of 3.4%, driven by consumer spending and AI investment, but express concerns about weakening momentum heading into Q4 with falling savings rates and flat September spending. They debate whether the Fed should raise rates in December given that most inflation appears supply-driven rather than demand-driven, with the Fed characterizing growth as 'strong' despite signs of consumer stress.