RenMac’s Jeff deGraaf: There Is Finally an Alternative to Stocks | #657
Jeff deGraaf from RenMac discusses how rising real yields above 2% finally provide alternatives to stocks, presents technical analysis methods for identifying market bubbles and timing allocation shifts, and highlights emerging credit deterioration in private credit markets that could signal broader economic stress.
Summary
Jeff deGraaf, Chairman and Head of Technical Research at Renaissance Macro, discusses several interconnected themes about market conditions and investment strategy. He begins by highlighting a historical parallel from 1873, when 'John Bull can't stand 2%' real yields drove investors to seek higher returns through risky Central American bonds. He argues this dynamic is reversing: with real yields now above 2-2.65%, bonds have become genuinely competitive with equities again after 15+ years of TINA (There Is No Alternative) policies that suppressed rates through quantitative easing. A 65-35 stock-bond portfolio can now deliver similar returns to an 80-20 allocation with significantly less volatility, offering a genuine alternative after a long period when bonds were unattractive.
DeGraaf explains RenMac's bubble indicator, which triggers when an index doubles within two years from an all-time high. This happened recently in semiconductors (late April 2024), biotech, and other sectors. His framework shows that after a bubble signal, the next three months typically see further upside 80% of the time, but the strategy is to 'shoot them in the back'—hold through the rise but exit on the way down rather than trying to pick tops. This avoids the psychological trap of FOMO that affected even Sir Isaac Newton during the South Sea bubble. For semiconductors specifically, the bubble triggered in late April, peaked June 22, but broader concerns about regulatory environment shifts (potential shifts in AI compute regulation) and credit deterioration in hyperscalers went unnoticed by one-dimensional market focus.
He describes how technical analysis combined with conditional factors (regime analysis) creates better allocation timing. Real yields moving above 2% is a condition suggesting bonds are attractive, but the technical trigger—waiting for actual trend confirmation rather than just hitting a threshold—improves allocation outcomes. He employs a 'market cycle clock' using inflation and growth measurements, currently showing the S&P in its worst historical zone (high inflation, high growth) with only 40 basis points annualized return historically—positive but weak. This is consistent with higher real rates, flattening curves, and sectors like energy and healthcare outperforming while materials and discretionary underperform.
DeGraaf discusses credit deterioration signals starting to appear. Triple-C spreads (the riskiest corporate debt) are elevated around 1200 basis points, but median spreads are much lower, meaning only about 25% of issuers (cable and hyperscaler companies) are driving the stress. The breadth of names trading below 80% of par—the dividing line between good and questionable credit—is around 7% and expanding. He frames this as 'stably deteriorating' rather than crisis, but notes it's consistent with a business cycle turn, though AI has kept the cycle extended longer than typical.
On private credit specifically, he explains how Dodd-Frank regulations pushed traditional bank lending into a 'shadow banking' structure now dominated by private equity firms offering loans with lighter covenants and more opacity. These loans were often struck when rates were much lower, and as borrowers reset to floating rates of 10% versus the 3-5% they originally locked in, many face existential pressure. Private credit funds have implemented redemption gates (limiting withdrawals to 5-10% quarterly) and using 'pay in kind' mechanisms to manage liquidity. He notes the distinction: 'I don't have a solvency problem, I have a liquidity problem. They're the same thing. If your liquidity problem goes on long enough, you have a solvency problem.' This structure creates opacity about when deterioration might become systemic.
DeGraaf emphasizes position sizing using Kelly Criteria and volatility adjustment, arguing most investors overlook proper position-sizing methodology. He also discusses trend-following rather than fundamental conviction, arguing that technical analysis allows practitioners to stress-test ideas daily and remain pragmatic rather than dogmatic. Finally, he notes positive technical signals in crypto and gold, with gold having completed its bubble wash-out phase and potentially setting up for a trend reversal, while crypto has held gains after diverging when Treasury Secretary Bessent mentioned yield curve tactics.
About this episode
My guest today is Jeff deGraaf, Chairman and Head of Technical Research at Renaissance Macro Research and a Hall of Fame technical analyst. In today’s episode, Jeff starts in 1873 with the line that John Bull can’t stand 2% and explains why real yields above 2% mean investors finally have an alternative to stocks. He also shares why November has become the best month of the year. To close, Jeff covers why private credit is deteriorating and what the credit markets are signaling today. Learn more about RenMac (0:00) John Bull and Real Yields (5:21) Seduction of Bubble Trades (11:06) Bonds, Volatility, and Allocation (15:27) Credit Spreads and Market Pressure (19:10) Semis and the Bubble Signal (28:38) Trading Around Equity Bubbles (31:26) Tape Reading and Regime Analysis (42:49) Private Credit and Stably Deteriorating ----- Follow Meb on X, LinkedIn and YouTube For detailed show notes, click here To learn more about our funds and follow us, subscribe to our mailing list or visit us at cambriainvestments.com ----- Follow The Idea Farm: X | LinkedIn | Instagram | TikTok ----- Interested in sponsoring the show? Email us at [email protected] ----- Past guests include Ed Thorp, Richard Thaler, Jeremy Grantham, Joel Greenblatt, Campbell Harvey, Ivy Zelman, Kathryn Kaminski, Jason Calacanis, Whitney Baker, Aswath Damodaran, Howard Marks, Tom Barton, and many more. ----- Meb's invested in some awesome startups that have passed along discounts to our listeners. Check them out here! ----- Editing and post-production work for this episode was provided by The Podcast Consultant (https://thepodcastconsultant.com).
Key Insights
- deGraaf argues that rising real yields above 2% represent a structural regime shift that finally provides genuine alternatives to equities, ending a 15-year period when suppressed rates forced investors into stocks despite unattractive risk-return profiles
- The bubble indicator framework reveals that after triggering (doubling from highs within two years), markets typically continue higher for three months with 80% probability, but the optimal strategy is to exit on the decline rather than try to pick tops, avoiding the psychological bias that affected even Sir Isaac Newton
- Technical confirmation of trend reversals provides superior allocation timing compared to using fixed thresholds like 2% real yields, combining 'fuel in the tank' (conditions) with 'spark' (technical triggers) to determine both position size and timing
- Private credit markets are experiencing 'stably deteriorating' credit conditions driven by refinancing shock as floating-rate loans reset from 3-5% original rates to 10% in a higher rate environment, creating opacity about when the problem becomes systemic versus contained
- The current market cycle clock position (high inflation, high growth) is the worst historical zone for equity returns at only 40 basis points annualized, yet technicals kept uptrends intact through much of the period, demonstrating why trend-following prevents premature capitulation
- Redemption gates and 'pay in kind' mechanisms in private credit funds mask underlying liquidity-to-solvency transitions, where short-term liquidity relief through gate restrictions can hide deteriorating fundamental credit quality
- Position sizing through Kelly Criteria and volatility adjustment remains underapplied among institutional investors, with many concentrating disproportionate capital in high-volatility positions without properly scaling exposure relative to risk
- deGraaf contends that semiconductor sector weakness stemmed not from valuation recognition alone but from missed regime shifts—specifically potential regulatory environment changes regarding AI compute—demonstrating how one-dimensional market focus creates blind spots even as technical indicators fire
Topics
Transcript
My resignation letter was the day of the high of the stock price at Lehman Brothers. That felt pretty good. You only get a few of those in your career. You just top tick something or bottom tick it. The bubble indicator is simply a doubling of an index within a two-year period of time from a high, not off a low. Sir Isaac Newton had money in the South Sea Company in December of 1719. By the end of February, he had quintupled his money. He took it out at the end of February, only to sit on his hands and watch it triple from that point. This is Sir Isaac Newton, the founder of Calculus. The technical term…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from The Meb Faber Show - Better Investing
SocGen’s Albert Edwards on 10% Yields and a 50% to 60% Drop | #656
Albert Edwards, a 44-year veteran strategist at SocGen, argues that despite compelling AI narratives driving current market optimism, structural headwinds—tightening liquidity, fiscal deficits, greedflation, and deteriorating breadth—will eventually force a 50-60% equity market decline and push US 10-year yields to 10%. He emphasizes that while the current bubble appears similar to past cycles, the real danger lies in corporate pricing power exhaustion and the Fed's need for aggressive rate hikes.
Cambria Fund Profile – Asset Allocation Suite
Cambria Investment Management presents three globally diversified ETFs—GAA, GMOM, and TRTY—each offering different portfolio philosophies and implementation strategies. The discussion emphasizes how global diversification with multiple asset classes can provide better risk-adjusted returns than traditional 60-40 portfolios, particularly during periods of high inflation and market stress.
StoneX' Vincent Deluard: The S&P Is Hiding a Bear Market | #655
Vincent Deluard from StoneX argues that despite S&P 500 all-time highs, a majority of individual U.S. stocks are trading below their 200-day moving averages, suggesting a hidden bear market. He's turning bearish on equities and bonds, citing rising real yields, understated inflation, and an unsustainable consumption model that parallels 2006-07, while identifying Europe as following Japan's deflationary playbook but in a messier, crisis-prone manner.
Meb 654 Dirk
Dirk Willer from Citi discusses the current AI-driven market bubble, defining it as an asset rising more than two standard deviations above its long-term trend. He believes we're in bubble territory but argues this is not a reason to be bearish—rather, investors should avoid over-leverage and recognize that bubbles eventually give back gains. Looking ahead, Willer expects the bubble to persist through 2024, with the Fed's hiking cycle and equity market peak timing being critical to monitor.
Andrew Ang: Should AI Agents Run Your Asset Allocation? | #653
Andrew Ang discusses how AI agents can improve asset allocation through specialized expertise, productive dissent, and continuous learning, while emphasizing that taxes represent a larger drag on investment returns than most investors realize—with a century of data showing Uncle Sam's cut averaging 350 basis points annually and potentially rising significantly in the future.