Topps Refuses To Acknowledge Their Own Card! | What Are Comps?? | & More Sports Card News!
Weekly sports card news covering Topps' inability to authenticate their own cards, pricing controversies about including shipping/commission in final sales prices, PSA queue improvements, major auction sales including a $1.7M Steph Curry card, and various grading and authenticity issues in the hobby.
Summary
In this episode of "Clearing the Bases," the host covers a slow news week in sports cards, beginning with a strange aggressive comment from a viewer. The episode then dives into several key topics: First, a heated debate on Hobby Twitter about whether shipping and commission costs should be included in stated card prices—with the host initially saying $100 for a $113.67 total purchase but evolving toward including all costs. Second, a case involving former Upper Deck assistant card issuing manager Edward Fronczak who pleaded guilty to stealing cards worth at least $500,000 and received 18 months supervised probation. Third, PSA's certification queue decreased by 800,000 cards in two weeks (from 9M to 8.2M), suggesting they still receive approximately 800,000 high-value cards monthly despite inflated prices. A major controversy featured Topps refusing to authenticate one of their own cards—a 2026 Bowman Chrome superfractor variant pulled from a hobby box that doesn't appear on the official checklist. When customer support was contacted, Topps stated they could only confirm documented cards and refused to validate the variant, suggesting collectors get it graded independently. The host criticizes this response, questioning Topps' purpose if they cannot authenticate their own products. The episode also covers multiple grading and authenticity issues: PSA reactivating a Barry Bonds PSA 10 card that had uneven edges after community reports, an MBA (autograph authentication) gold diamond on a card with unconfirmed authenticity, and a 1952 Willie Mays card with an MBA certificate that doesn't exist in their verification system. High-value sales highlighted include a $1.7M Steph Curry 2012 Panini Prizm gold PSA 10 card (most expensive public Curry sale), a $1.1M Kobe Bryant BGS 9.5 gold Prizm, and a $1.25M Lionel Messi 2026 Prizm card. The host also discusses eBay's mysterious purchase limits that one collector encountered, damaged Topps Chrome blue refractors sent as replacements on different paper stock, and an AI-generated autograph that altered Tim Kurkjan's signature to "Bernie." The episode concludes with various noteworthy auction items including vintage cards, memorabilia, and an observation that breaking (splitting cases to minimize individual losses) is "a way to split a $1,000 loss between 30 people so no one realizes how bad it was."
Key Insights
- Topps explicitly refused to authenticate a superfractor variant card pulled from their own hobby box that doesn't appear on their official checklist, claiming they can only confirm documented card data and cannot validate the card based on marketplace absence
- PSA's certification queue decreased by 800,000 cards in just two weeks, yet the hobby still receives approximately 800,000 cards valued at $60+ per month, indicating the market continues to submit high volumes despite inflated pricing
- PSA deactivated a Barry Bonds PSA 10 1986 Topps card with uneven edges after community members reported it didn't meet 10-point standards, demonstrating PSA's willingness to retroactively correct grades on cards already in circulation
- An MBA gold diamond was awarded to a card authenticated only for autograph authenticity without ever physically inspecting the card itself, raising questions about how grading agencies can rate cards they've only seen in holders
- The host argues that comparing the 1984 Star Jordan card to the 1952 Mantle is inappropriate because the Jordan card is 'ugly' and its high value derives primarily from PSA's recent willingness to grade it, whereas Mantle's iconic status stems partly from the card's exceptional design and photography
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] Good morning and happy Sunday to everyone, except for that one guy who left an extremely strange comment on my channel a week or so ago. I'll show that comment in a moment, but, uh, this is for those unfamiliar with my weekly episode of "Clearing the Bases," which airs every Sunday at about 8am, where I cover all the news, curiosities, bugs, and big auctions that have happened in our hobby over the past week. If this is your first time here, be sure to subscribe. Let's start [0:31] with that comment, because it's pretty funny in a very strange, evil way. And just a warning to parents watching this with their kids : there is profanity in…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Junk Wax Hero
Some SICK early refractors, more non-sports cards, and trying a fun new treat!
Mike opens a mail haul containing Red Sox autographs, rare refractor cards, and non-sports memorabilia from fans. He discusses his collecting strategy, budget constraints, and attempts a new Sour Patch Kids flavored Oreo snack while showcasing highlights from his acquisitions.
Beckett SUSPICIOUS Activity! | Hairy PSA Situation! | Insane Market! | & More Sports Card News!
This weekly sports card news update covers PSA's suspicious technical activity that kept their platforms offline for 3+ weeks, quality control issues with graded cards and damaged product shipments, significant high-value card sales including a $605,000 Sandy Koufax rookie, and various scams and authentication problems in the collectibles market.
When a $1 million sports card sale is disappointing...
Mike discusses why the Pete Crow-Armstrong MLB rookie debut patch auto card selling for just under $1.1 million is disappointing compared to recent NBA rookie cards that sold for significantly more ($2.3M-$8M), despite PCA's superior stats, position prestige, and MVP-caliber performance.
I completed a HUGE trade with Boston Card Hunter!
Mike completed a major trade with Boston Card Hunter (Nick Andrews), exchanging a 1989 Hall of Fame program signed by Yaz Carswell and three other inductees for a rare 1985 Topps Goonies autographed sticker card signed by Jeff Cohen. The video also showcases other recent mail pickups including a 1998 Pedro Martinez refractor, a PSA 10 Wayne's World card, and a Randy Johnson rookie autograph.
Why am I buying non-sports cards suddenly?? Plus: amazing gifts & eye appeal sticker!
Mike explains his recent shift toward collecting non-sports cards due to budget constraints and nostalgia, discusses his new Eye Appeal Ink sticker system for grading card eye appeal, and receives an incredibly generous gift of multiple signed Greg Maddox cards from a viewer named Dave.