StoryOpinion

Why am I buying non-sports cards suddenly?? Plus: amazing gifts & eye appeal sticker!

Junk Wax Hero

Mike explains his recent shift toward collecting non-sports cards due to budget constraints and nostalgia, discusses his new Eye Appeal Ink sticker system for grading card eye appeal, and receives an incredibly generous gift of multiple signed Greg Maddox cards from a viewer named Dave.

Summary

Mike addresses why he's been acquiring non-sports cards in his recent mail reviews. He clarifies that it's not because the non-sports market is skyrocketing, as buying into a rising market would be a mistake for long-term collectors. Instead, his card budget has shrunk significantly, and sports cards have become very expensive. Since he already owns most inexpensive sports cards under $50 that interest him, he's exploring non-sports cards focused on nostalgia—particularly movie and TV-related cards like Indiana Jones, The Blair Witch, Back to the Future, The Sopranos, and Breaking Bad rather than iconic collections like presidential or inventor cards. He demonstrates a Mark Bellhorn black refractor from his 2004 Red Sox collection that he acquired for around $8. Mike then discusses Eye Appeal Ink, a community-driven card grading system where users rate cards on a scale from F to "god level." Cards receiving 10 community reviews (recently changed to 7) that achieve hall of fame status receive a physical sticker. He shows a card that received a B+ from one reviewer for sky blending with the frame—a criticism he finds irrelevant to visual appeal—but earned an A+ overall from the council. The card received a D grade from Mike due to barely noticeable paper loss on the back letter L, which he finds inconsequential. The transcript concludes with an emotional moment where Mike opens gifts from a viewer named Dave, who identified himself as someone having worked with Greg Maddox for 15 years. Dave sent multiple signed Greg Maddox rookie cards in Topps Traded format and Topps Now boxes—cards that directly complement the Maddox card Mike featured the previous week. Mike expresses overwhelming gratitude for this generous gift.

Key Insights

  • Mike argues that buying non-sports cards when the market is skyrocketing would be a mistake, as collectors should buy when prices are falling if planning to hold long-term.
  • Mike's shift to non-sports cards is driven by his significantly reduced card budget and sports cards becoming very expensive, forcing him to reconsider his collecting strategy.
  • Mike states he prefers non-sports cards with nostalgia value from movies and TV shows rather than iconic collections like presidential or inventor cards, which don't appeal to him.
  • Eye Appeal Ink's software removes outlier reviews from its grading algorithm, presumably to account for revenge voting or other deviations from genuine assessment.
  • Mike received multiple signed Greg Maddox cards from a viewer named Dave who claims to have worked with Maddox for 15 years, which Mike describes as one of the most generous acts anyone has done for him.

Topics

Non-sports card collectingBudget management in card collectingEye Appeal Ink sticker systemCommunity-based card gradingNostalgia-driven collectingViewer gifts and generosity

Transcript

[0:00] Why am I suddenly getting so many unsportsmanlike cards? I thought it would be interesting to tell this story. Hey, Mike. Thank you for watching again. Lately I've been doing mail reviews where I get a lot of non-sports cards, and it's just great. Some say: " Mike, why are you suddenly so into non-sports cards?" Is it because the non-sports card market has skyrocketed? Well, that would be mostly pointless, although it is partly related . If I were to buy [0:32] non-sports cards just because the market is taking off, I would probably be making a mistake. You want to buy when prices are falling if you are a collector and plan to hold onto things for…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Junk Wax Hero

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.