When a $1 million sports card sale is disappointing...
Mike discusses why the Pete Crow-Armstrong MLB rookie debut patch auto card selling for just under $1.1 million is disappointing compared to recent NBA rookie cards that sold for significantly more ($2.3M-$8M), despite PCA's superior stats, position prestige, and MVP-caliber performance.
Summary
Mike opens by exploring how a $1 million card sale can be disappointing, then introduces the focus: the Paul Skenes rookie debut patch auto card that sold for $1.112 million about a year ago. He explains the innovation of debut patch cards—jerseys worn during a player's first game, autographed and inserted into cards by Fanatics/Topps. Mike notes that while Skenes benefited from marketing by Dick's Sporting Goods and his connection to Livvy Dunn, there were at least two serious bidders involved. He then pivots to Pete Crow-Armstrong's recent sale, which went for just under $1.1 million—essentially the same price as Skenes despite the market growing significantly over the past year. Mike had expected PCA's card to sell for $3-5 million. Mike argues that PCA should command a much higher price: he plays centerfield (one of baseball's most prestigious positions), had the third-highest defensive WAR in the National League, led the league in offensive WAR, and achieved 10 total WAR at just 24 years old. PCA is a reliable workhorse who played all 162 games in 2026 and 157 in 2025, is beloved by fans, plays for the Cubs in a legendary stadium, and just became the first Cubs player to reach 40-40, making him only the seventh player in MLB history to do so. He led the league with 45 home runs and is expected to win MVP. Mike expresses frustration that Cooper Flagg's NBA card sold for $8 million, Kon Knipel's for $2.3 million, and Dylan Harper's for $2.8 million—all significantly more than PCA despite inferior credentials. He acknowledges that the NBA has a larger global market and is very popular, but questions whether this price disparity makes sense. Mike concludes by suggesting that in 5-10 years, people will look back and call this situation madness, while expressing genuine appreciation for PCA as a player.
Key Insights
- Debut patch cards where players wear jerseys during their first game then autograph the card are described as probably the best innovation in sports cards of all time, with historically high selling prices.
- Pete Crow-Armstrong's card sold for just under $1.1 million, essentially the same price as Paul Skenes' card from a year prior, despite the market growing significantly and PCA having superior player credentials.
- Mike expected PCA's card to sell for $3-5 million based on his centerfield position prestige, 10 WAR achievement at age 24, 40-40 club membership, league-leading 45 home runs, and expected MVP award.
- NBA rookie cards (Cooper Flagg at $8M, Dylan Harper at $2.8M, Kon Knipel at $2.3M) sold for significantly more than PCA's baseball card despite PCA having objectively better on-court/on-field performance metrics and reliability.
- Mike predicts that in 5-10 years, looking back at PCA's card selling for less than Flagg and Harper's cards will be viewed as madness, suggesting current NBA market overvaluation relative to MLB player value.
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] Can a million-dollar sale ever disappoint ? I think that was exactly the case in this case . Hi, this is Mike. Thank you for watching again. First of all, we can all agree that selling for a million dollars is nonsense. Cards selling for over a million dollars are complete madness, but they sell. And very few of my viewers watching this video will ever buy a card for over a million dollars, have that opportunity, or even that kind of money. I know I will never own a [0:30] million dollar card. The chances of that are zero. But I like learning about these cards. And see how much they sell for, what the market is like,…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Junk Wax Hero
I completed a HUGE trade with Boston Card Hunter!
Mike completed a major trade with Boston Card Hunter (Nick Andrews), exchanging a 1989 Hall of Fame program signed by Yaz Carswell and three other inductees for a rare 1985 Topps Goonies autographed sticker card signed by Jeff Cohen. The video also showcases other recent mail pickups including a 1998 Pedro Martinez refractor, a PSA 10 Wayne's World card, and a Randy Johnson rookie autograph.
Why am I buying non-sports cards suddenly?? Plus: amazing gifts & eye appeal sticker!
Mike explains his recent shift toward collecting non-sports cards due to budget constraints and nostalgia, discusses his new Eye Appeal Ink sticker system for grading card eye appeal, and receives an incredibly generous gift of multiple signed Greg Maddox cards from a viewer named Dave.
Another CGC/JSA return and 10 autographed cards I'm sending!
The speaker shares recent CGC authentication results for a triple-autographed card graded 3, then previews approximately 10 autographed cards he's preparing to send to CGC for authentication, including emotionally significant childhood baseball cards and various Hall of Fame rookie cards.
Beckett Fall Down Go Boom! | Topps Chrome Duplicates AGAIN?! | & More Sports Card News!
A comprehensive Sunday sports card news episode covering major industry issues including Beckett's website collapse and infrastructure overhaul, duplicate Topps Chrome serial numbers discovered at DC Sports 87, and record-breaking sales across vintage and modern cards with prices ranging from hundreds of thousands to over $12 million.
Things keep going wrong with DCSports87 listings on eBay!
Mike discusses repeated listing issues with DC Sports87 on eBay involving a 1994 Action Packed WWF Randy Savage card (serial #44) that was sold multiple times over four weeks with varying prices, and a similar incident with an Adli Rachman card. He concludes these appear to be inventory management failures rather than deliberate scams, attributing them to the seller growing too fast without proper system infrastructure.