I completed a HUGE trade with Boston Card Hunter!
Mike completed a major trade with Boston Card Hunter (Nick Andrews), exchanging a 1989 Hall of Fame program signed by Yaz Carswell and three other inductees for a rare 1985 Topps Goonies autographed sticker card signed by Jeff Cohen. The video also showcases other recent mail pickups including a 1998 Pedro Martinez refractor, a PSA 10 Wayne's World card, and a Randy Johnson rookie autograph.
Summary
Mike opens by reflecting on his first adult trade from 2021-2022, where he traded a Derek Jeter PSA 5 rookie for a Shaq PSA 5 rookie. He then describes his recent major trade with Boston Card Hunter, sparked by Nick posting about acquiring a 1985 Topps Goonies autographed sticker of Chunk (Jeff Cohen) that graded PSA 9-10. Mike, expressing his deep love for the movie Goonies (his all-time favorite film that he rewatches yearly), expressed interest in buying the card. Nick offered to trade instead, requesting something Red Sox-related. Mike considered offering Ted Williams cards but ultimately proposed a 1989 Hall of Fame program signed by all four inductees that year, including Yaz Carswell, which was in excellent condition. To Mike's surprise, Nick accepted a one-for-one trade without negotiation or tension, which Mike appreciated given his prior hesitation about trading. Mike also reflects positively on Nick Andrews as a person, noting that despite being polarizing on social media, he is genuinely nice and easy-going in private interactions. In the remainder of the mail haul, Mike discusses a 1998 Topps Finest Pedro Martinez refractor in Red Sox uniform purchased cheaply, recommending Pennyslever sleeves for card storage. He then shares a nostalgic story about his Saturday Night Live obsession from 1989-1994, sneaking downstairs at 11:25 PM to watch the show, with Wayne's World being his favorite sketch. He shows a PSA 10 Wayne's World card from 1992 acquired for $50, noting the recent non-sports card boom. Finally, he reveals a Randy Johnson rookie autograph graded PSA 9-10 with an I Appeal Inc. sticker rating (A+), and displays a gift from TJ's Online: a signed photograph of Shelley Duvall from The Shining holding a Yaz bat, autographed by both Duvall and Yaz Carswell.
Key Insights
- Mike claims that his first experience trading with Boston Card Hunter was exceptionally smooth, with no negotiation friction or desire to 'win' the trade, unlike his prior assumptions about trading based on his limited experience.
- Mike asserts that Goonies is his all-time favorite movie that he rewatches every year, valuing it for its coming-of-age adventure themes and nostalgic connection to his own childhood experiences of creating adventure in the woods.
- Mike reveals he was obsessed with Saturday Night Live between 1989-1994, setting alarms to sneak downstairs at 11:25 PM to watch the show, with Wayne's World being his favorite recurring sketch.
- Mike suggests that the non-sports card market is experiencing a significant boom, noting that a PSA 10 Wayne's World card from 1992 sold for only $50, which he considers surprisingly inexpensive.
- Mike describes Boston Card Hunter's persona (Nick Andrews) as polarizing on social media but genuinely nice and easygoing as a private person, based on private conversations and a prior interview.
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] I completed the biggest trade of my life with Boston Card Hunter. Hey, it's Mike. Thanks for tuning back in. So, back in like 2022 or 2021, maybe even, uh, I completed a trade, the first trade of my adult collecting life. It was I traded a uh Derek Jeter rookie PSA five, the Topps rookie of Derek Jeter for a Shaq rookie in a PSA 5, also the Topps Shack rookie. [0:36] Completely fair trade. I think they were both worth like I don't know5 to$10 at the time. And uh it was somebody in a maybe a Facebook group I think and we just traded. And that was the first and only time I had ever traded…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Junk Wax Hero
Why am I buying non-sports cards suddenly?? Plus: amazing gifts & eye appeal sticker!
Mike explains his recent shift toward collecting non-sports cards due to budget constraints and nostalgia, discusses his new Eye Appeal Ink sticker system for grading card eye appeal, and receives an incredibly generous gift of multiple signed Greg Maddox cards from a viewer named Dave.
Another CGC/JSA return and 10 autographed cards I'm sending!
The speaker shares recent CGC authentication results for a triple-autographed card graded 3, then previews approximately 10 autographed cards he's preparing to send to CGC for authentication, including emotionally significant childhood baseball cards and various Hall of Fame rookie cards.
Beckett Fall Down Go Boom! | Topps Chrome Duplicates AGAIN?! | & More Sports Card News!
A comprehensive Sunday sports card news episode covering major industry issues including Beckett's website collapse and infrastructure overhaul, duplicate Topps Chrome serial numbers discovered at DC Sports 87, and record-breaking sales across vintage and modern cards with prices ranging from hundreds of thousands to over $12 million.
Things keep going wrong with DCSports87 listings on eBay!
Mike discusses repeated listing issues with DC Sports87 on eBay involving a 1994 Action Packed WWF Randy Savage card (serial #44) that was sold multiple times over four weeks with varying prices, and a similar incident with an Adli Rachman card. He concludes these appear to be inventory management failures rather than deliberate scams, attributing them to the seller growing too fast without proper system infrastructure.
8 great autos (and 1 fake!) and my first pedigree! CGC / JSA return!
The speaker shares their CGC/JSA autograph grading returns from 10 cards submitted in May, showcasing a mix of Hall of Fame rookie autographs and discussing CGC's customer service experience. One card failed authentication, revealing a Shaquille O'Neal ghost-signer issue discovered after submission.