Ken Fisher: What Really Causes Inflation
Ken Fisher argues that inflation is fundamentally caused by excess money creation, not by rising prices of individual goods like oil. While oil price increases may temporarily affect costs in the short term, they ultimately cause substitution effects rather than systemic inflation when the money supply remains stable.
Summary
Ken Fisher explains that while oil price increases might seem to drive inflation through higher production and transportation costs in the very short term (1-2 months), this represents a misunderstanding of what causes inflation long-term. He asserts that inflation is always and everywhere caused by excess money creation, not by rising prices of specific commodities. Fisher distinguishes between items with elastic demand (like bubble gum, which has many substitutes) and inelastic demand items (like oil and its derivatives, which are necessities). When oil prices rise, consumers cannot simply stop using gasoline or heating their homes, but instead engage in substitution—buying fewer luxury goods to compensate for higher energy costs. This reshuffling of consumption patterns brings down prices in other sectors rather than creating systemic inflation. The key insight is that if the money supply remains relatively stable, a single commodity's price increase redistributes spending rather than inflating the overall price basket. Fisher notes this substitution effect is occurring in real time as oil prices fluctuate.
Key Insights
- Fisher claims inflation is caused exclusively by excess money creation, always and everywhere, not by rising prices of individual commodities
- Fisher argues that when money supply stays stable, a single item's price increase has semi-predictable outcomes that don't necessarily increase overall inflation
- Fisher distinguishes that items with inelastic demand like oil have hard-to-reduce consumption even when prices rise significantly, unlike elastic goods like bubble gum
- Fisher contends that rising oil prices cause substitution effects where consumers reduce spending on luxury goods rather than creating systemic price inflation
- Fisher asserts that the reshifting of what consumers buy due to oil price increases changes relative prices but does not change overall inflation
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] If the price of oil goes up, wouldn't that feed into the cost of production and transportation of goods and thus lead to inflation? In the very short term, like a month or two, yes. In the longer term, no. Inflation is not caused by the price of oil going up or the price of anything else going up. Inflation is caused by excess money creation, always and everywhere. This notion that the price of X goes up, therefore that [0:30] pushes the basket of things we have up, misses the notion that if the quantity of money stays relatively stable, the price of one item going up, depending on what that item is, has a pretty semi-predictable outcome.…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Fisher Investments
This Week in Review | Fed Rate Hike, Tech Volatility & AI Risks, Bond Yields (Sept. 18, 2026)
This Week in Review covers three major market developments: the Federal Reserve's first rate hike since 2023 (25 basis points to 3.75-4%), tech sector volatility driven by AI safety concerns, and rising bond yields globally reaching levels unseen in decades. The hosts emphasize that these moves were largely expected, offer historical context for current yields, and remind investors to focus on broader fundamentals rather than short-term market swings.
Will Stocks Finish Strong in 2026?
Ken Fisher explains the 'Midterm Miracle' phenomenon, which shows that the fourth quarter of a president's second-term midterm election year and the subsequent two quarters historically represent the most consistently profitable nine-month period for stock markets. He expects strong market performance through the end of 2026 and into early 2027 based on this historical pattern.
Ken Fisher: Has This Bull Market Run Too Far, Too Fast?
Ken Fisher argues that the current bull market's 20% average return since October 2022 is not excessive relative to historical bull market performance. He contends that the concern about the market rising "too far, too fast" is a misguided perspective, since bull markets historically average 23% annual returns and this current market is performing in line with long-term bull market norms.
Ken Fisher on Market Crashes, US Debt, Construction and More
Ken Fisher addresses investor questions about market crashes, government debt, construction indicators, and risk management. He argues that there's insufficient evidence to determine whether crashes are less likely today, that debt-to-GDP ratios tell us nothing meaningful, and that construction trends are not particularly important economic indicators.
3 Things You Need to Know This Week | Fed Decision, US Retail Sales, Medicare (Sept. 14, 2026)
This episode covers three key financial topics: the upcoming Federal Reserve rate decision expected to be a 25 basis point hike, August retail sales data release that shouldn't be over-interpreted due to monthly volatility, and the Medicare annual enrollment period opening October 15th through December 7th.