OpinionResearch

How Might Midterms Influence Stocks?

Fisher Investments

The speaker explains the "midterm miracle," where stock markets historically perform exceptionally well in the fourth quarter of a president's midterm year and the following two quarters. This positive period occurs because reduced legislative activity after midterms decreases political risk, as the president's party typically loses power and gridlock increases, preventing major wealth-redistribution legislation that markets fear.

Summary

Ken Fisher discusses how midterm elections create predictable stock market patterns. The key mechanism is that presidents front-load controversial legislation into their first two years, knowing they'll lose relative congressional power in the midterms. After midterms occur, gridlock increases regardless of which party wins, because two-thirds of senators are freed from the incumbent president's influence and know they'll outlast his term. This reduction in the likelihood of major legislation—particularly wealth-redistributive policies that create winners and losers—reduces political risk aversion. Fisher notes that the fourth quarter of midterm years has been positive 88% of the time over the past 100 years, as political anxiety about major legislation fades. He acknowledges this pattern is documented primarily in his firm's data rather than mainstream financial literature. The speaker applies this framework to the current (2018) election landscape, noting Republicans have gained fundraising and redistricting advantages but face headwinds from President Trump's low popularity ratings. Regardless of midterm outcome, Fisher argues the gridlock effect will create an "anti-legislation oriented Congress," supporting the historically positive stock market environment.

Key Insights

  • Presidents deliberately concentrate major legislation into their first two years because they anticipate losing relative power to the opposition party in midterms and cannot pass controversial bills with less legislative support than they initially had.
  • The fourth quarter of midterm years has been positive 88% of the time over the past 100 years, a pattern Fisher claims is documented primarily in his data and rarely found elsewhere.
  • After midterms, gridlock increases because two-thirds of senators know they will outlast the current president's term and therefore feel liberated to pursue independent agendas rather than supporting the president's initiatives.
  • Markets fear major legislation disproportionately because people experience losses from wealth redistribution more intensely than they experience gains, creating political risk aversion during periods of significant legislative activity.
  • The gridlock effect supporting stock market gains occurs regardless of which party wins the midterms, because the mechanism depends on the sitting president's reduced power, not the composition of Congress.

Topics

Midterm election cycle effects on stock marketsPolitical risk and legislative gridlockPresidential term timeline and legislative strategyLoss aversion and market behaviorHistorical stock market performance patterns

Transcript

[0:04] The period of the fourth quarter of the second year of a president's term when we have midterms, ushers in a nine month period, that and the two subsequent quarters. That's the most positive period in all of stock market history. And it is the fourth quarter of the midterm year, first and second quarter of the third year of a president's term. And it is because for a series of reasons that I don't think are fully understood by most people [0:34] and pretty much will never be believed by most people, you usher in a period of quietness in major legislation, which takes down and reduces political risk and political risk aversion. So let me let me…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Fisher Investments

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.