OpinionDiscussion

Ken Fisher Discusses South Korean Stocks, Software Stocks, AI Debt, ETFs and More

Fisher Investments

Ken Fisher addresses investor questions on foreign stocks, South Korean markets, software stocks, AI-backed securitized debt, and ETF investing. He emphasizes that while history rhymes rather than repeats, most bear market causes remain fundamentally similar, and that blanket statements about entire sectors like software are unhelpful without microanalysis.

Summary

In this monthly mailbag Q&A, Ken Fisher discusses several investment topics with nuance and historical context. On John Templeton's famous quote about 'this time it's different,' Fisher agrees the phrase is dangerous but clarifies that history doesn't repeat perfectly—it rhymes. Markets are collective bids on future views, so if everyone could see disaster coming from past patterns, they would pre-price it, making obvious repetitions rare. The underlying causes of bull and bear markets remain consistent, only cosmetically different.

Regarding South Korean stocks, Fisher explains that the South Korean market index is misleading because it's heavily concentrated in two mega-cap stocks: Samsung and SK Hynix, which together are worth more than all other South Korean stocks combined. While these semiconductor companies have performed well due to AI-related demand, extrapolating their success to the broader South Korean market or globally would be incorrect. The rest of South Korea's stock market has not been robust.

On software stocks, Fisher rejects blanket characterizations, likening the question to asking if the ocean is too cold or hot—the answer depends on location and conditions. Software companies have disparate outcomes: some face AI displacement concerns, others are seen as AI beneficiaries, and some are unaffected. Individual microanalysis of how global developments impact specific companies is essential rather than sector-wide generalizations.

Concerning securitized debt based on GPUs and AI chips, Fisher draws parallels to mortgage-backed securities from 2007-2009 but provides crucial context. While the structural risk of bundled debt products is similar, the accounting rule changes implemented after the Great Recession make current risks lower. Post-2009, mark-to-market accounting rules were amended to be more benign, reducing the cascade effect where falling security prices force balance sheet write-downs that restrict bank lending and trigger recession.

On ETFs versus individual stocks for passive investors, Fisher clarifies that ETFs are legitimate for smaller investors who cannot achieve diversification with individual securities. For wealthier investors (originally $500,000, now closer to $1 million adjusted for inflation), individual stock ownership offers tax and cost advantages, but ETFs remain acceptable tools if used appropriately.

Key Insights

  • Fisher argues that if past patterns predictably led to disasters, all investors would pre-price those outcomes in advance, making obvious historical repetitions rare in markets; therefore history rhymes rather than repeats exactly.
  • The South Korean stock market index is structurally misleading because Samsung and SK Hynix comprise the majority of market capitalization, making index performance unrepresentative of the broader South Korean economy.
  • Software stocks cannot be analyzed as a monolithic category—some face AI displacement risk, others benefit from AI, and others are unaffected, requiring company-specific microanalysis rather than sector-wide statements.
  • The 2007-2009 financial crisis was not primarily caused by mortgage default volumes, which were too small relative to GDP; rather, 2007 mark-to-market accounting rules forced banks to write down securities, deteriorating balance sheets and restricting lending.
  • Post-2009 accounting rule amendments that reduced mark-to-market requirements mitigate systemic risk from current securitized AI and GPU debt products compared to the 2007-2009 mortgage-backed securities crisis.

Topics

Market history and pattern recognitionSouth Korean stock market concentrationSoftware stock sector heterogeneitySecuritized debt and AI chipsAccounting standards and systemic riskETF versus individual stock investingPassive versus active investing

Transcript

[0:00] The market is one of us looking at things collectively and bidding against each other based on our views about what the future will be, and if we all could see that this thing happened this way before leading to disaster. Well, we'd all pre-price that. So every month [0:30] people send in questions. I try to answer them quickly, which I'm not very good at. I tend to be ponderous normally, but here, here we got all these questions. Can you share your thoughts on Sir John Templeton's quote: "The four most dangerous words in investing are: This time it's different?" Well, yeah. First, I adored John Templeton. I met him a few times. He was a marvelous…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Fisher Investments

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.