OpinionInsightful

Beware Overreacting to Market Volatility

Fisher Investments

Market volatility should not trigger changes to investment strategy, as it is simply a characteristic of equities rather than a predictive signal. Unless investors have knowledge of significant negative developments unknown to the market, the historical three-to-one upside-to-downside ratio of stocks provides a logical basis for maintaining equity exposure rather than turning bearish.

Summary

Ken Fisher discusses how market volatility, particularly during periods like October and November, often causes investors to overreact and change their investment strategies unnecessarily. He emphasizes that volatility is an inherent feature of equity markets—people notice volatility during downturns but ignore it during upswings. Fisher argues that volatility is the price investors pay for the exceptional long-term returns that equities provide. He stresses that volatility by itself is not predictive and doesn't necessarily signal anything meaningful about future market direction. Fisher contends that investors often misinterpret volatility as a harbinger of negative changes, when in reality market movements driven by investor jitteriness have no meaningful information content. He presents the historical evidence that stocks rise approximately three times for every one time they fall, which creates unfavorable odds for betting against equities unless one possesses specific knowledge of major negative developments. Fisher explains that effective bearish bets require knowledge of something "big and negative" that isn't already widely known and priced into the market. Since market prices incorporate nearly all publicly available information and widely discussed viewpoints, changing strategy based solely on observed volatility lacks a rational basis. He concludes that volatility does not indicate where markets are headed or what investment decisions should be made, and this principle applies regardless of asset class.

Key Insights

  • Fisher argues that volatility is not a predictive signal but rather a standard feature of equities, and investors feeling jittery about price movements doesn't create meaningful information about future performance.
  • Fisher states that stocks historically rise approximately three times for every one time they fall, making it economically irrational to bet against equities without specific negative knowledge, as this creates three-to-one odds against the bearish bet.
  • Fisher contends that everything widely known, discussed, or debated about markets is already priced into stock valuations, so publicly available information cannot serve as a basis for profitable contrarian investment decisions.
  • Fisher distinguishes between volatility observation (which many investors experience) and volatility interpretation (which most investors mishandle by treating it as predictive rather than accepting it as inherent to equity markets).
  • Fisher argues that a rational basis for turning bearish requires knowledge of something "big and negative that other people aren't talking about," indicating that mere observation of market turbulence cannot justify strategy changes.

Topics

Market volatility and investor psychologyVolatility as a feature not a forecastLong-term equity return patternsInformation efficiency and market pricingInvestment strategy decision-making

Transcript

[0:05] Just lately, it's been volatile. In October, November. And as you get volatility, you get a fair number of people who think that because of the volatility, they ought to change their investment strategy somehow, some way. They envision volatility as a forecast, a harbinger, of what's to come. A sign that is indicative of some negative change that's occurred. [0:36] Let me just say stocks are volatile. People feel the volatility when it's on the downside, they don't feel the volatility when it's on the upside. But stocks are volatile. Smooth rides, smooth rides in the world of wealth and finance, are expensive to get. The fact is, volatility is the price that you pay for the exceptional…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Fisher Investments

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.