The Best Soundbars (Plus Lessons from 40 Years of Audio Testing)
Brent Butterworth, an audio testing expert retiring from Wirecutter after 40+ years in the industry, discusses soundbars as solutions for poor TV speakers. He explains what soundbars are, how they compare to full home theater systems, pricing tiers, testing methodologies, and provides specific product recommendations ranging from budget to premium options.
Summary
The episode opens with hosts Kyra Blackwell and Rosie Garan discussing the poor sound quality of modern televisions despite their high cost. Brent Butterworth explains that thin TV designs prioritize aesthetics over audio, leaving only about one-inch diameter speakers in thin plastic cabinets—inadequate for moving air and producing quality sound. Soundbars address this by being dedicated audio devices that deliver clear vocal reproduction, good bass, and surround sound effects approaching home theater quality.
Soundbar specifications range from $100-$2,000+, with price differences primarily reflecting volume capacity, surround speakers, and subwoofer size rather than fundamental sound quality. Entry-level soundbars ($150) sound significantly better than TV speakers, while higher-end models ($1,500+) add wireless surround speakers and larger subwoofers capable of shaking furniture. Butterworth emphasizes that most consumers benefit from affordable options with voice boost modes to enhance dialogue clarity—a common complaint.
For testing, Butterworth uses movies that push soundbar performance limits rather than conventional reviews. U-571 tests bass reproduction and dialogue clarity amid action sequences, Apocalypse Now evaluates surround sound immersion, and Matilda assesses dialogue clarity across varied vocal ranges. He recommends the TCL S55H ($150) for budget buyers, Vizio Elevate series ($300-500) for mid-range upgrades, and Samsung HWQ990H or Bose Lifestyle Ultra ($1,500-1,800) for premium setups.
The episode concludes with reflections on Butterworth's career, revealing he's tested approximately 2,000 products and credits Wirecutter's methodology of finding best-value products—rather than simply reviewing individual items—as transformative to his approach. He shares an anecdote about accidentally throwing a non-waterproof Bluetooth speaker into a pool, resulting in 45 minutes of screaming sounds.
About this episode
If you want better sound than your TV’s built-in speakers provide, a soundbar will help. Our audio expert explains everything you need to know.
Key Insights
- Modern television speakers fail because thin TV designs physically cannot accommodate speakers large enough to move adequate air, with speakers typically limited to one-inch diameter in thin plastic cabinets—a fundamental design constraint rather than a manufacturing oversight.
- Even budget soundbars at $150 represent an 'obvious huge improvement' over TV speakers, and price increases primarily buy volume capacity and surround speakers rather than fundamental sound quality improvements, making high-end purchases discretionary for enthusiasts rather than necessary for most viewers.
- Butterworth uses movies featuring diverse vocal ranges and complex soundscapes (like Matilda's varied character voices and U-571's dialogue-over-explosions sequences) specifically to expose soundbar limitations, arguing that testing should push equipment to failure points rather than showcase optimal performance.
- Butterworth attributes Wirecutter's distinct approach to prioritizing reader value over manufacturer perception and conducting more extensive comparative testing to find best products rather than simply reviewing individual items, which he credits with fundamentally changing his methodology from traditional audio journalism.
- High-end soundbars from competing manufacturers (Samsung HWQ990H vs. Bose Lifestyle Ultra) offer comparable audio performance but differentiate through aesthetics and design philosophy, with Bose prioritizing visual integration into living spaces at a $300 price premium for the subwoofer alone.
Topics
Transcript
If you're a parent of a teen or have teens in your life, it can be hard to figure out the right way to approach social media and technology. Ultimately, if you feel like your teens are ready, there are tools to help. Instagram teen accounts have automatic protections for what your teens see and who can contact them, plus time management tools like daily time limits and sleep mode. And Instagram will continue adding built-in safety features to help create age-appropriate experiences. Learn more about teen accounts and Instagram's ongoing work to protect teens online at Instagram.com slash teen accounts. That's Instagram.com slash teen accounts. I'm Kyra Blackwell. I'm Rosie Garan. And you're listening to The Wirecutter Show. Hi,…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from The Wirecutter Show
Choosing a Guest Bed People Will Actually Want to Sleep On
This Wirecutter podcast episode features seven home experts discussing various guest bed solutions, from mattress toppers and sleeper sofas to air mattresses, foam tri-folds, and Japanese futons. Each expert shares their testing experience and recommendations for making overnight guests comfortable without sacrificing permanent living space.
How to Prepare for Overnight Holiday Guests
In this episode of The Wirecutter Show, host Kyra Blackwell interviews Ivy Elrod, a home design writer and experienced host, about preparing for overnight holiday guests. They discuss practical strategies for making guests comfortable, from pre-arrival communication and bathroom setup to bedroom arrangements and kitchen accessibility, emphasizing that thoughtful hosting is about reducing anxiety and creating welcoming experiences rather than achieving visual perfection.
The Real Risks of Heated Clothes and Hand Warmers
Kyle Fitzgerald discusses the safety risks of battery-powered heated clothing and hand warmers, which can cause fires and burns due to lithium-ion battery thermal runaway, while providing guidance on safe product selection and traditional layering techniques for staying warm in winter.
Smarter Ways to Cook Easy One-Pot Dinners
The Wirecutter Show discusses one-pot meal cooking vessels with senior kitchen writer Leslie Stockton, comparing Dutch ovens, slow cookers, electric pressure cookers, and stovetop pressure cookers. Each vessel offers different advantages depending on cooking time availability, desired flavor outcomes, and lifestyle needs.
Wirecutter's All-Time Favorite Slippers
Wirecutter editors Christine Zierk-Lissette and Jen Hunter discuss how to choose the right slippers based on warmth level, material, and intended use, then review their top recommendations across different categories including luxury shearling, breathable wool, affordable options, and supportive styles.