DiscussionTechnical

The Real Risks of Heated Clothes and Hand Warmers

The Wirecutter Show22m 35s

Kyle Fitzgerald discusses the safety risks of battery-powered heated clothing and hand warmers, which can cause fires and burns due to lithium-ion battery thermal runaway, while providing guidance on safe product selection and traditional layering techniques for staying warm in winter.

Summary

In this episode of The Wirecutter Show, host Christine Cyr-Clicette interviews outdoor writer Kyle Fitzgerald about heated apparel and hand warmers powered by lithium-ion batteries. Fitzgerald explains that heated gear includes vests, jackets, gloves, socks, and insoles that use batteries to power resistive heating elements (similar to toaster heating). He acknowledges the appeal of these products for workers in cold environments, spectators at winter events, and people with poor circulation, noting they provide genuine warmth and comfort. However, the episode's central focus is on serious safety risks. Fitzgerald details how over 1.5 million Okupa hand warmers were recalled due to fires, hundreds of burn injuries, and one death. The risks stem from combining two fire-prone elements: lithium-ion batteries and resistive heating. Lithium-ion batteries pack tremendous power into small spaces, and when defective, dropped, dented, overcharged, or short-circuited, they can undergo thermal runaway—an uncontrolled chain reaction causing fires. Additionally, heated socks and insoles can cause burns and blisters when in contact with skin, especially during high-intensity activity with friction and moisture. Insoles pose particular danger because they're difficult to remove and subject batteries to constant foot-impact stress, with five recent recalls involving third-degree burns. Fitzgerald recommends checking the Consumer Product Safety Commission's recall database, looking for NERTL (Nationally Recognized Testing Laboratory) certification symbols from OSHA-recognized labs on batteries, avoiding unrecognizable "alphabet soup" brands on Amazon, and following manufacturer instructions carefully including charging in open areas, not overnight, avoiding overheating, and removing batteries before washing. He advises checking FAA travel guidelines before flying with heated gear since lithium-ion batteries cannot go in checked luggage. The episode then shifts to traditional warming strategies. Fitzgerald advocates a three-layer system: a moisture-wicking base layer (preferably merino wool), an insulating mid-layer (fleece, down vest, or down jacket) that traps air pockets for warmth, and an outer protective shell (shell jacket or rain jacket) to shield against wind, rain, and snow without compressing the insulation. For hands, he recommends mittens over gloves since grouped fingers retain heat better, suggests layering glove liners under mittens, and emphasizes proper fit to avoid compression of insulation. For feet, he stresses avoiding cotton socks in favor of heavyweight merino wool or alpaca wool that provide loft and insulation, recommends proper insulated winter boots over sneakers or rain boots, and notes that layering socks is less comfortable than investing in quality heavyweight options. Throughout, Fitzgerald emphasizes that while better gear helps, understanding layering principles and how air pockets trap body heat is equally important for staying warm without battery-powered solutions.

About this episode

Heated gear promises instant warmth, but burn and fire risks have led to recent recalls. Here’s what know before you buy.

Key Insights

  • Fitzgerald reports that over 1.5 million Okupa hand warmers were recalled due to fires, hundreds of burn injuries, and one death, products that Wirecutter had previously recommended before discovering these risks.
  • Heated gear combines two inherently fire-prone elements—lithium-ion batteries and resistive heating elements—positioned directly on or near the body, creating compounded risk compared to these components used separately.
  • Even products certified by major testing labs like UL can still pose long-term risks because certification testing is rigorous for immediate defects but doesn't necessarily account for defects that emerge after prolonged real-world use.
  • Heated insoles present a double threat: they're hard to remove in an emergency and subject embedded lithium-ion batteries to continuous mechanical stress from footsteps and body weight, leading to five recent recalls involving third-degree burns.
  • The principle behind staying warm through layering—trapping air pockets between layers using materials like fleece loft and down insulation—is the same physics principle that keeps people warm in layered bedding.

Topics

Lithium-ion battery thermal runaway and fire risks in heated apparelProduct recalls and safety certifications for heated gearBurn and blister injuries from heated socks and insolesNERTL certification and battery testing standardsThree-layer cold-weather dressing system with moisture-wicking and insulationProper fit and air pocket management in winter clothingTraditional alternatives to battery-powered heating

Transcript

What's amazing about the Neo frame is like if you look at it, it's actually easier to read than any other watch out. This one to me is that. It's a very classy piece. It's very sleek. I was just sitting here, you know, kind of thinking while you're speaking like the 1920s, that's 100 years ago, right? 1929 or ish. And that looks effectively the same as the one from 1929. Listen to the Framers from Audemars Piguet now on your favorite podcast platform. See how excited I am? I've always got a little higher just now. I'm Christine Sir-Closette, and you're listening to The Wirecutter Show. If you spend time outdoors, you might be familiar with the saying…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from The Wirecutter Show

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.