Smarter Ways to Cook Easy One-Pot Dinners
The Wirecutter Show discusses one-pot meal cooking vessels with senior kitchen writer Leslie Stockton, comparing Dutch ovens, slow cookers, electric pressure cookers, and stovetop pressure cookers. Each vessel offers different advantages depending on cooking time availability, desired flavor outcomes, and lifestyle needs.
Summary
In this episode of The Wirecutter Show, hosts Christine Cyr-Clicette and Kyra Blackwell interview Leslie Stockton, a veteran Wirecutter kitchen writer with over 10 years of experience testing cooking equipment. The discussion centers on selecting the right vessel for one-pot meals based on individual needs and circumstances.
The Dutch oven is presented as ideal for achieving deeply browned, well-reduced braises and stews. Its advantages include excellent browning capability, heat retention, and the ability to transition from stovetop to oven for hands-off cooking with proper evaporation that concentrates flavors. However, Dutch ovens are heavy, expensive, and require active cooking presence in the home. Stockton recommends investing in high-quality enamel options like Le Creuset to prevent chipping and discoloration, though Lodge offers a solid mid-range alternative.
Slow cookers, despite their popularity, receive lukewarm endorsement from Stockton. She notes they cannot brown meat or vegetables, making them less versatile than pressure cookers for true one-pot meals. Their main advantages are affordability (typically $40-50), ability to leave them unattended, and cultural tradition in potluck and church settings. The recommended model is the Hamilton Beach oval design, which accommodates larger pieces of meat.
Electric pressure cookers like the Instant Pot are praised for time-saving efficiency and the ability to walk away from cooking. They build pressure by heating steam to increase water's boiling point from 212°F to approximately 250°F, enabling faster cooking. However, Stockton notes that electric pressure cookers lack evaporation, resulting in less-concentrated flavors than Dutch oven braises, and require additional boiling down of liquids post-cooking. They take 10-15 minutes to reach pressure and can take similar time to depressurize naturally.
Stovetop pressure cookers receive Stockton's strongest endorsement for active cooks seeking speed and flavor complexity. They offer superior versatility through rapid depressurization (under 10 seconds when run under cold water), allowing for continuous flavor building by adding ingredients mid-cook. They're particularly valuable for people living at high altitude where lower boiling points make cooking slow. Stockton uses stovetop pressure cookers primarily for stocks and soups for freezing, and demonstrates their capability by describing cooking whole fish like Branzino in just five minutes total.
The conversation includes extensive guidance on adapting recipes across different vessels. Stockton emphasizes reducing liquid in pressure cooker recipes (maximum two cups for meat braises), pre-reducing wine to dryness to avoid raw alcohol flavors, and adding dairy products after pressure release to prevent curdling. She warns against cooking pasta in pressure cookers due to excessive heat and gumminess, and stresses following precise liquid-to-bean ratios when cooking dried beans to avoid scorching.
Recipe recommendations include carne guisada (stewed beef), risotto (seven minutes under pressure with no stirring), charro beans, and simple preparations like frozen chicken breasts with tomato sauce served over rice. Stockton also mentions her grandmother's drip beef sandwiches adapted for the Instant Pot, demonstrating how traditional slow-cooked recipes can transfer to modern equipment.
For recipe resources, Stockton recommends the New York Times Cooking website (which has over 900 one-pot recipes), Martha Stewart's site, Laura Pazaglia's Hip Pressure Cooking timetables, and Sarah Copeland's cookbook "Instant Family Meals."
About this episode
Our best advice on how to make the most out of Dutch ovens, slow cookers, and pressure cookers for one-pot meals. Plus easy recipe ideas you won’t want to miss.
Key Insights
- Leslie Stockton argues that the choice of cooking vessel should be determined entirely by what cooking outcome you're trying to achieve and what lifestyle constraints you have, not by brand preference or tradition.
- Stockton claims that Dutch ovens produce superior braises compared to pressure cookers because the imperfect seal allows evaporation that concentrates flavors, whereas pressure cookers trap all liquid with zero evaporation.
- Stockton asserts that slow cookers are functionally inferior to electric pressure cookers because both cook unattended, but pressure cookers cook faster and include browning capability that slow cookers lack.
- Stockton explains that electric pressure cookers take 10-15 minutes to reach pressure and another 10-15 minutes to depressurize naturally, meaning total cooking time is often longer than active time with stovetop models.
- Stockton demonstrates that stovetop pressure cookers provide superior versatility because they can depressurize in under 10 seconds when run under cold water, allowing cooks to add ingredients mid-process for flavor layering.
- Stockton contends that dairy products will curdle in pressure cookers if added before cooking because the temperature gets too hot, requiring them to be added only after pressure is released.
- Stockton argues that pressure cooking is essential for people living at high altitude (above 3,000 feet) because the boiling point of water decreases with elevation, making standard cooking times insufficient.
- Stockton claims that wine must be reduced to dryness before pressure cooking begins because there is no evaporation once the lid closes, otherwise the dish will taste raw and have an alcohol odor.
Topics
Transcript
This message is brought to you by AppleCard. The fall season always brings its fair share of surprises. Like the first snow. Or a late night trip to the store for your kid's school project. No matter what the season brings, AppleCard's got you covered. You can earn 2% daily cash back when you use AppleCard with ApplePay. Apply for AppleCard now and use in minutes with ApplePay. Subject to credit approval, AppleCard is issued by Goldman Sachs Bank USA Salt Lake City Branch. Terms and more at AppleCard.com That's the Instant Pot. Like it's not going to make the most delicious thing, but I mean, sometimes it will, but sometimes it won't. I mean, I don't have kids, but…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from The Wirecutter Show
Choosing a Guest Bed People Will Actually Want to Sleep On
This Wirecutter podcast episode features seven home experts discussing various guest bed solutions, from mattress toppers and sleeper sofas to air mattresses, foam tri-folds, and Japanese futons. Each expert shares their testing experience and recommendations for making overnight guests comfortable without sacrificing permanent living space.
How to Prepare for Overnight Holiday Guests
In this episode of The Wirecutter Show, host Kyra Blackwell interviews Ivy Elrod, a home design writer and experienced host, about preparing for overnight holiday guests. They discuss practical strategies for making guests comfortable, from pre-arrival communication and bathroom setup to bedroom arrangements and kitchen accessibility, emphasizing that thoughtful hosting is about reducing anxiety and creating welcoming experiences rather than achieving visual perfection.
The Real Risks of Heated Clothes and Hand Warmers
Kyle Fitzgerald discusses the safety risks of battery-powered heated clothing and hand warmers, which can cause fires and burns due to lithium-ion battery thermal runaway, while providing guidance on safe product selection and traditional layering techniques for staying warm in winter.
Wirecutter's All-Time Favorite Slippers
Wirecutter editors Christine Zierk-Lissette and Jen Hunter discuss how to choose the right slippers based on warmth level, material, and intended use, then review their top recommendations across different categories including luxury shearling, breathable wool, affordable options, and supportive styles.
Wirecutter Has a Book!
Wirecutter is releasing its first book titled "Clean Everything" on March 16th, featuring cleaning advice from dozens of Wirecutter experts. The book covers cleaning guidance for various household items and spaces, and is now available for pre-order across multiple retailers.