The CURRENT NFL QB Card Market. Good OR BAD?
A sports card analysis video examining the current NFL quarterback card market, ranking 8 QBs by statistics and tracking their card prices over the last 60 days. The host also showcases several high-value collectible items available on Fanatics Collect, including rare autographs and vintage cards from top athletes.
Summary
The video opens with an analysis of the NFL quarterback card market, focusing on 8 quarterbacks and their 2022-2023 Prism Base cards as tracked over the last 60 days. Brock Purdy of the 49ers ranks third statistically with 16 total touchdowns and a 110.1 passer rating, with his PSA 10 card up 137% to $183. Despite strong stats, quarterback cards are highly volatile and subject to win-loss streaks. Dak Prescott's 2016 Prism Silver card is down 22% at $214, while Trevor Lawrence's 2021 Prism Base (PSA 10) is down 10.6% at $160 despite strong early season performance. Bryce Young's 2023 Prism Base card surged 34.2% to $51, though the Panthers were subsequently blown out by Tampa Bay. Joe Burrow ranks second statistically with a relatively flat card price at $110, while Justin Herbert's card has plummeted 37.5% to $50, reflecting the Chargers' 0-6 record and his own poor performance (68.8 passer rating, 5 TDs to 8 INTs). Lamar Jackson leads in passer rating at 119.6 but is limited by injuries, with his 2018 Prism PSA 10 down 26% at $300+. Baker Mayfield's card is down 33% at $46.80 due to injury, while Josh Allen's 2018 Prism PSA 10 leads the gains at +66% to $800, reflecting the Bills' strong season and his remarkable rushing touchdown production (8 rushing TDs). The host notes the NFL QB market is challenging due to general spec cooling in the first 6-8 weeks of the season as injuries and underperformance emerge. The second half of the video showcases notable Fanatics Collect auctions: a 2023 Topps Chrome MLS Superfractor one-of-one of Lionel Messi at $1,075; a rare 2007 Exquisite Collection dual autograph of Brian Piccolo and Walter Payton at $210; a 2006 Ultimate Collection ensemble card featuring Ken Griffey Jr., Derek Jeter, and Albert Pujols (PSA 9 one-of-one) with no listed price shown; and a 1997 Flare Showcase Michael Jordan insert card numbered to 250 in BGS 9 at $330.
Key Insights
- Quarterback cards are highly volatile and act as a minefield for buyers because they fluctuate significantly based on team win streaks and losing streaks rather than individual performance alone
- There is typically a 6-8 week drop-off period early in the NFL season as speculation cools and teams underperform, injuries emerge, or teams don't live up to preseason expectations
- Justin Herbert's card declined 37.5% over 60 days despite his historical value, with the Chargers' 0-6 record and Herbert's 68.8 passer rating (worst among the 8 QBs analyzed) representing a cautionary tale of high-priced one-of-one cards like his million-dollar Shield autograph from 2020-2021
- Josh Allen's card gained 66% to $800 with the Bills performing strongly, driven partly by his unusual production of 8 rushing touchdowns alongside 9 passing touchdowns, showing how diverse quarterback skill sets can impact card appreciation
- Early-to-mid 2000s sports cards from 2000-2010 represent undervalued opportunities compared to heavily pushed 1990s cards, with products like 2007 Exquisite Collection and 2006 Ultimate Collection featuring rare multi-autograph ensembles that rarely come to market
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] And today we're going to talk about nine NFL QBs, their card market, some football cards. We're going to take a look at some football cards today and we're going to rank these quarterbacks too based on their stats so far this season and to talk through some of this stuff. And then make sure to stay on the back half of this video for some rad current items over there on Fanatics Collect at auction. If you are new to Fanatics Collect, Fanatics Live, make sure to sign up. I've got a link in the video description as well as the pinned comment to get you started. Remember, currently, if you're selling on Fanatics Collect and you're just…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from The Sports Card Dad
PSA Value Bulk COMING BACK + Topps MVP Buyback Program EXPANDS
The speaker discusses two major developments in the trading card hobby for 2027: PSA Value Bulk grading tiers are expected to return in December with potentially lower price points (possibly $25/card), and Topps has expanded its MVP Buyback Program for 2026 Chrome Football with debut patches, autographs, and guaranteed payouts at local hobby shops.
Will there be FUTURE Card Collectors?
Matt discusses whether future generations will participate in card collecting, arguing that the hobby is experiencing healthy growth and broadening participation beyond traditional middle-aged male collectors. He contends that most hobbyists don't follow social media content creators, and identifies significant growth opportunities in non-sports cards, Pokemon, and entertainment-related collectibles.
The CHALLENGE of Supply & Demand in Sports Cards
The transcript discusses supply and demand dynamics in sports card collecting, with focus on the iconic 1986 Fleer Michael Jordan card. It explores print run estimates, grading population data, price appreciation over the past decade, and how diverse collector preferences create market nuance. The speaker also showcases featured items from Fanatics Collect weekly auctions.
Nostalgia STILL DRIVING Card Collectors
Brad Noble, a card collector and dealer, discusses how nostalgia drove his return to collecting during COVID and how he's adapted his dealer strategy by working with repackers due to declining raw card sales at shows. He also shares his personal collecting focuses, including Orioles in-person autos and early 90s basketball inserts.
I Don't FEEL Like Myself TODAY
A Sports Card Dad YouTube host delivers a humorous video about the sports card collecting hobby while repeatedly insisting he is a normal human, despite exhibiting suspicious non-human characteristics and behaviors throughout. The video satirizes collector psychology, market trends, and grading debates while maintaining an absurdist premise that the host is malfunctioning or not what he claims to be.