DiscussionStory

Nostalgia STILL DRIVING Card Collectors

The Sports Card Dad

Brad Noble, a card collector and dealer, discusses how nostalgia drove his return to collecting during COVID and how he's adapted his dealer strategy by working with repackers due to declining raw card sales at shows. He also shares his personal collecting focuses, including Orioles in-person autos and early 90s basketball inserts.

Summary

The episode features an interview with Brad Noble, a card collector and dealer who was first met by the host at a National convention two years prior. Brad initially collected cards as a kid but stopped during high school and college, missing the major growth years around 2018. He re-entered the hobby during COVID when nostalgia hit and he realized his old cards had value. Since 2022, Brad has been setting up at card shows across the East Coast, from Philadelphia to Raleigh to New York and beyond. As a Ravens and Orioles fan, Brad's primary personal collection (PC) focuses on Orioles in-person autos and Hall of Famer autos on-card only, with Brooks Robinson being his favorite all-time Orioles player. Brad notes that Hall of Famer memorabilia, particularly from players like Brooks Robinson and Frank Robinson, is surprisingly affordable compared to modern players like Gunnar Henderson. Brad has also diversified into collecting 500 home run club cards from the year each player hit their milestone. Regarding his dealer business, Brad has observed a significant shift in the market throughout 2026. Raw card sales at shows have declined substantially, which he attributes partly to PSA's shutdown and general market correction. In response, he's begun working with repackers, both buying cards from the market to sell to repacker companies and purchasing from repackers himself. He works with multiple repacker sources—one for raw cards and one for graded material—but sources cards for middlemen rather than directly for major companies like Arena Club due to the high volume requirements (thousands of slabs per week). Repackers buy PSA slabs (occasionally Beckett) of relevant players across all categories, from modern rookies like Luis Robert to vintage cards. Brad explains that consumers have shifted away from breaks toward repacks because breaks, particularly in expensive products like Allen and Ginter, offer unpredictable returns (potentially zero hits for $275), whereas $250 repacks guarantee a card worth approximately $200, minimizing losses. For his own investing strategy, Brad focuses on early 2000s Tom Brady memorabilia cards and early 90s Michael Jordan basketball inserts in PSA 9-10 condition. He shared a recently acquired PSA 9 Stadium Club card that was mislabeled by PSA as a regular game card rather than a members-only card, requiring correction through PSA's process. Looking forward to 2027, Brad plans to continue his dealer activities, attend the National convention again, participate in a concert and card show weekend in Rehoboth Beach, Delaware in May, and capitalize on market dips to acquire undervalued Brady and Jordan cards.

Key Insights

  • Brad re-entered card collecting during COVID due to nostalgia and discovered his childhood cards had significant value, a pattern he attributes to his entire generation of collectors
  • Raw card sales at shows have noticeably declined in 2026, prompting dealers like Brad to pivot toward working with repackers who guarantee liquidity despite market corrections or PSA's shutdown
  • Repackers require thousands of PSA slabs per week and are willing to buy any relevant player across all card categories and eras, creating demand that dealers source through middlemen relationships
  • Consumers have shifted from breaks to repacks because breaks offer unpredictable returns (potentially losing $275 entirely) while $250 repacks guarantee a card worth approximately $200, providing better risk-adjusted returns
  • Hall of Famer vintage memorabilia from players like Brooks Robinson and Frank Robinson remains surprisingly undervalued compared to modern players, with in-person autos of Hall of Famers available for under $100 in some cases

Topics

Nostalgia driving hobby re-entry during COVIDShift from breaks to repacks in the hobbyCard dealing strategies and market adaptationPersonal collecting focus (Orioles autos, Hall of Famers, 500 home run club)Market dynamics and pricing of vintage memorabiliaCard show circuit and dealer operations

Transcript

[0:00] Alf, welcome back to another Focus on Collectors Friday. We have got another rad episode with Brad Noble, longtime card collector. Got back in thanks to Nostalgia. Got a great conversation here today, so make sure you hang all the way until the end. Big thanks today's video sponsor, Topps Fanatics Collect. There is a particular item on the weekly that I am watching here. Ends at time of recording in a few days, a couple of days. Payton Manning 1998 Upper Deck SP rookie card. It's a die cut. When we're talking about nostalgia, these are the [0:31] types of cards, man. I love diecut cards. It's numbered to 500. And this one is a BGS10. One of…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from The Sports Card Dad

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.