DiscussionOpinion

The CHALLENGE of Supply & Demand in Sports Cards

The Sports Card Dad

The transcript discusses supply and demand dynamics in sports card collecting, with focus on the iconic 1986 Fleer Michael Jordan card. It explores print run estimates, grading population data, price appreciation over the past decade, and how diverse collector preferences create market nuance. The speaker also showcases featured items from Fanatics Collect weekly auctions.

Summary

The episode opens with an in-depth analysis of the 1986 Fleer Michael Jordan card, examining the challenges of determining its true print run. While a Fleer executive reportedly told hobbyist Reed Kasoka in the late 1990s that approximately 250,000 of each card were printed, these figures remain unconfirmed. Baseball Card Exchange data from 2022 supports production in the hundreds of thousands per card, though exact numbers remain speculative. The speaker notes that basketball cards were printed in lower volumes than baseball cards during the 1980s, and Fleer's 1986 basketball set represented their return to the sport after 25 years since their 1961 release.

Grading data from gemrate.com reveals approximately 50,000 1986 Fleer Michael Jordan cards have been graded across all companies, with roughly 30,000 graded by PSA. The gem rate is approximately 1.8%, meaning PSA 10s are exceptionally rare. However, the speaker emphasizes that population reports can be misleading because collectors frequently crack and resend cards to pursue higher grades, inflating the numbers. PSA 10s number around 320-325, a figure that has remained relatively stable over the past five years.

The speaker highlights Michael Jordan's dominance in the hobby, arguing he is now the most collected player overall, surpassing even Mickey Mantle and Ken Griffey Jr. in breadth and demand. Historical price data shows the PSA 9 card traded around $3,000-5,000 for approximately 10-15 years (from roughly 2008 onwards), but has appreciated to the $30,000-50,000 range, representing roughly a 10x increase over the past decade. PSA 10 versions have similarly appreciated from around $20,000-40,000 to $300,000-400,000 range.

The speaker explains that sustained demand for high-grade versions stems from relatively limited supply coupled with significant hoarding by major collectors who own multiples of PSA 10s and hold them as buy-and-hold assets, similar to how large shareholders stabilize residential real estate or crypto whales influence Bitcoin prices. He notes the nuance within sports card collecting, where different collector segments pursue different Michael Jordan cards—some prefer 80s early cardboard, others focus on 90s inserts, numbered parallels, or specific team variations like his Wizard years.

The speaker predicts continued growth in mainstream interest, citing Emma Roberts' announcement of her own trading card company and noting that multiple non-collector acquaintances reached out about it. He emphasizes that manufacturers like Fanatics and Topps are building a marketing machine targeting broader mainstream audiences, with celebrities and athletes increasingly involved in the hobby.

The second half of the episode features highlights from Fanatics Collect's weekly auctions, including a 1998 Skybox Molten Metal Fusion KG card (PSA 8, numbered to 250) at $78; a 2013 Select Black Prism Dirk Nowitzki one-of-one BGS 95 at $400; 1995-96 Select Certified Mirror Gold Wayne Gretzky cards (PSA 10) at $56 and beyond; a 2000 Fleer EX Tom Brady rookie numbered to 1,500 (BGS 95) at $370; an 8 Skybox EX Essential Credentials Vince Carter rookie numbered to 89 (PSA 9) at $260; a 1997 Metal Precious Metal Gems Alpha green card numbered one of 10 (PSA 6) at $1,125; and a 2020 Joe Burrow Flawless Platinum one-of-one auto (10/10) at $1,400.

Key Insights

  • The 1986 Fleer Michael Jordan card's print run remains unconfirmed at approximately 250,000 units based on a Fleer executive's recollection rather than documented factory records
  • Population reports from grading companies significantly undercount unique cards because collectors repeatedly crack and resend the same card multiple times trying to achieve higher grades, inflating the recorded population numbers
  • The PSA 9 1986 Fleer Michael Jordan card appreciated approximately 10x over the past decade, rising from a stable $3,000-5,000 range for 10-15 years to the current $30,000-50,000 range
  • A small number of major collectors hoarding 10-20% of the PSA 10 population and holding them as buy-and-hold assets effectively stabilizes prices, similar to how large real estate shareholders and Bitcoin whales stabilize their respective markets
  • Michael Jordan is now the most-collected player in the entire hobby across all sports, surpassing Mickey Mantle and Ken Griffey Jr., with an exceptionally broad range of card variations and collector segments pursuing different versions

Topics

1986 Fleer Michael Jordan card supply and print run dataSports card grading population reports and limitationsPrice appreciation and demand dynamics for high-grade cardsMichael Jordan's dominance as most-collected player in hobbyMarket concentration and hoarding effects by major collectorsCollector segmentation and niche preferences within single playersMainstream expansion and celebrity involvement in trading cardsFanatics Collect weekly auction highlights and featured cards

Transcript

[0:00] In the morning to you, Alf. Today we're going to talk about supply and demand in the sports card hobby. >> As darkness falls, our imaginations take flight. >> In particular, we're going to talk about the 1986 Fleer Michael Jordan card. I love this card. It's an iconic Michael Jordan card, probably the most iconic card. I've got it in a PSA 6. Today is a discussion around supply and demand, and what does it mean for our larger long-term hobby outlook when it comes to buying slashspeculating in trading cards? So, how many 86 Fleer Michael [0:31] Jordan cards are out there? We don't exactly know. It would be amazing to have the print run numbers for…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from The Sports Card Dad

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.