'Collect What YOU LOVE' is LAZY Advice
The speaker critiques the generic advice to "collect what you love" as lazy and argues that successful collecting requires understanding your specific goals, budget level, and preferences within the hobby. He illustrates how collectors must do research to understand card sets, parallels, and rarity to make informed decisions, using examples like his $20,000 purchase of a 2012 Gold Prizm Drew Brees card.
Summary
The speaker opens by expressing frustration with the overused phrase "collect what you love," calling it trite and cliché advice that avoids giving direct guidance. He acknowledges that defenders of this phrase often use it to avoid engaging with people primarily motivated by quick profits rather than genuine passion for collecting.
The speaker argues that better advice requires understanding the collector's specific context. He uses Tom Brady as an example, illustrating how a collector needs to answer numerous detailed questions: Should they pursue rookie cards, Chrome cards, Panini cards, inserts, rare parallels, memorabilia cards with patches and autographs, or autograph-only cards? These decisions require knowledge of what options exist within a collecting niche.
He explains that collectors have various motivations and budget levels—some want fifty-cent dollar cards of their favorite team, others hunt for expensive graded cards, and some seek undervalued vintage cards from the 1950s-80s. Mid-range options exist too, like memorabilia cards with patches and autographs that can be obtained for under fifty dollars.
The speaker discusses how collecting tastes evolve over time and how learning about different card series happens through practice and exploration. He shares his personal experience purchasing an expensive 2012 Gold Prizm Drew Brees PSA 10 card for $20,000, explaining why this particular parallel is special: the 2012 Prizm set had very limited parallels (only Gold Prizm with 10 copies and two one-of-a-kind cards), whereas modern sets have proliferated to include around fifty different parallels.
He emphasizes that education about card sets, rarity, and historical context is crucial for collectors. The speaker notes that tools like Perplexity and ChatGPT now make research easier than the old days of forum crawling and random YouTube searching. He uses this knowledge to identify potentially underrated cards, such as modern Star Wars Topps products that receive less attention than vintage 1977 Topps Star Wars.
Finally, the speaker identifies different ways to enjoy collecting: box opening and breaks for adrenaline seekers, patient hunting for specific rare numbered cards, treasure hunting in dollar boxes, and various price points from cheap to elite. He emphasizes that collecting preferences change over time and that the hobby provides a rare area of personal control and pleasure for middle-aged collectors managing family responsibilities.
About this episode
How many times have we heard 'collect what you love'? Check out collectorinvestorauctions.com for the current auction details and add Sports Card Dad when you sign up for an account as the referral source please! $25 OFF your 1st PSA grading submission (1 Card Minimum!) Follow the link below and use promo code SCD25 to get started: #ad It is very important that you add the promo code at the "Shipping & Billing" screen to receive the discount Link: https://bit.ly/3MA7CHr PROMO CODE: SCD25 To learn more about PSA/Ebay consignment click here: https://tinyurl.com/PSA-SCD-youtube Don't forget to check out our website: http://sportscarddad.com/ CARD HOBBY PROMO CODES to Save You Money: *I May Receive a Commission from the use of these promo codes #ad $25 OFF 1st Sub at PSA: SCD25 Promo Code $25 OFF Premium Membership at NoOffseason.com: sportscarddad Promo Code 20% OFF Lifetime Market Movers Data Tool Membership: SCD Promo Code 10% OFF Order at BCW Card Supplies: SCD10 Promo Code 10% OFF SlabMags Order: sportscarddad Promo Code $25 OFF 1st $100 spent at Card Capsule Supplies: SCD25 Promo Code Contact: [email protected] IG: @sportscarddad Twitter: @sportscarddadYT Facebook Group: The Sports Card Dad News & Discussion Disclaimer: The channel is currently sponsored by PSA, Joopiter, CIA, Hake's Auction, REA and affiliate links with Market Movers, Ebay, Slabmags, Card Capsule, and BCW. This Content is for informational and/or entertainment purposes only. You should not construe any such information or other material as legal, tax, investment, financial, or other advice.
Key Insights
- The speaker argues that 2012 Prizm sets are historically significant because they contained only 2 parallels total (Gold Prizm with 10 copies and two one-of-a-kind cards), whereas modern 2025 Prizm sets now contain approximately 50 different parallels, making early sets fundamentally more exclusive.
- The speaker claims that generic advice to 'collect what you love' is often used as a defensive shield by experts to avoid engaging with people who are motivated purely by short-term financial gains rather than genuine passion for the hobby.
- The speaker states that collector preferences naturally evolve and change over time, with collectors potentially shifting from pursuing cheap cards to seeking expensive high-end cards as their interests develop.
- The speaker identifies multiple distinct collector personality types based on how they derive enjoyment: box breakers seeking adrenaline, disciplined hunters searching for specific numbered cards, and treasure seekers hunting dollar boxes like metal detector users on a beach.
- The speaker argues that AI tools like Perplexity and ChatGPT have fundamentally transformed card hobby research by making comparative analysis of different sets and parallels accessible, whereas collectors previously had to manually crawl forums and random YouTube videos.
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] Very often, when experienced card collectors are asked, “Hey, dude, what should I collect?” What would you recommend? The standard answer , which is heard throughout our hobby, is to collect what you love. And there's nothing that annoys me more than that phrase "collect what you love." It's so trite. It's so cliché. This is kind of a lazy way to avoid answering this question directly. But before I tell you how to answer this question differently, I want to defend the collectors who are asked these [0:30] questions, because there are also people who just want to make a quick buck and are trying to figure out what to buy. Hey, what should I buy? Not because…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from The Sports Card Dad
I Made $2500 Flipping a Card (NEVER HELD THE CARD)
A collectibles investor discusses flipping a 1995 Skybox Toy Story Woody card for $2,500 profit without ever physically holding it, demonstrating the volatility of non-sports card markets. The video also reviews several high-value cards available on the PSA eBay store, including vintage basketball, football, and basketball memorabilia.
Ohtani Card Prices FALLING
This video analyzes recent price corrections in Shohei Ohtani baseball cards across multiple grading levels and sets, showing 20-50% drops in high-volume cards while rare cards remain stable. Despite a 'mediocre' season by his standards (.277 BA, 30 HR, 8 pitching wins), Ohtani's legendary status and continued playoff heroics suggest long-term card value sustainability, though some market cooling is healthy.
Card Grading Has LOST ITS MIND
A content creator discusses the current state of card grading, defending its necessity despite criticism from some hobbyists. He analyzes BGS's new submission management strategy, critiques their website infrastructure, and reviews several high-value cards currently listed on PSA's eBay store.
The 90s Baseball Card Price BOOM
This video analyzes price trends for popular 1990s baseball rookie cards over the past 365 days, examining raw card values and PSA-graded versions for players like Sammy Sosa, Frank Thomas, Chipper Jones, and Juan Gonzalez. The host discusses which cards have appreciated significantly and attributes renewed interest to nostalgic collectors in their mid-40s revisiting their childhood collections.
"There are NO MORE Card Collectors"
Host Dustin interviews Jeff, an eclectic collector of Michael Jordan cards, action figures, and vintage memorabilia, discussing how their generation was uniquely positioned to appreciate 1980s-90s pop culture and how collectors are returning to childhood passions in their 30s and 40s rather than chasing flips.