NewsDiscussion

When Trix removed artificial colors a decade ago, sales declined. Now, brands are being forced to do the same

The Modern Retail Podcast34m 43s

Major food brands are phasing out artificial dyes in response to consumer demand, regulatory pressure from the new administration, and voluntary FDA initiatives, though companies are using strategies like separate product lines to avoid alienating consumers attached to original formulations. The shift represents a significant moment after a failed attempt a decade ago when Trix removed artificial colors and saw sales decline.

Summary

The podcast discusses the recent movement by major food brands to remove artificial food dyes and certified color additives from their products. Hosts Gabby Barco and guest Paris Martineau from Consumer Reports explore why this shift is happening now, a decade after Trix's failed attempt to remove dyes in 2015-2017.

The conversation identifies three key drivers: consumer demand for clean labels (particularly among millennial and Gen Z parents), retailer commitments from companies like Target and Walmart, and state-level regulations like California's AB418. However, the most significant catalyst has been the Trump administration's focus on food policy through RFK Jr. and HHS/FDA leadership, who have made artificial dyes a priority issue. This includes revoking authorization for red dye number three (announced January 2025) and establishing a voluntary program for industry to remove six synthetic dyes by end of 2026 (later extended to end of 2027).

Parineau explains that the FDA's approach uses both regulatory and voluntary mechanisms. The term "encouraged" rather than "banned" is crucial—the deadlines for compliance are not legally binding. Additionally, the FDA redefined "no artificial colors" labeling in February 2026 to allow products with natural color additives (like spirulina) but no FD&C certified colors to use this claim, though this potentially obscures the presence of other artificial additives like titanium dioxide.

A major theme is how companies are handling the visual change that results from switching to natural dyes. Rather than reformulating existing products, many are launching separate lines (like Cheetos Simply Naked or Doritos). The It's It ice cream example illustrates consumer resistance to the resulting duller colors—the Bay Area product changed from bright seafoam green to pale green when removing blue number one dye, causing local outrage despite the healthier formulation. PepsiCo reports these new lines attract customers who wouldn't normally buy the product, expanding rather than replacing their market.

The hosts question whether this time will be different from the Trix situation, noting that consumer comfort with change and nostalgia for familiar product appearances remain psychological barriers. They also discuss how industry argues the U.S. market's size and unique manufacturing processes justify delays, though naturally-dyed versions already exist in Canadian and European markets.

About this episode

As consumer demand for clean-label products grows, major food producers are increasingly phasing out artificial food dyes for natural and plant-based alternatives.  Driven by these shifting standards, retailers such as Target and Walmart have announced pledges to remove synthetic colors. These changes also come as state-level regulations take effect, such as California's AB 418 banning specific additives. As such, food brands across categories like cereals, snacks and confections are actively reformulating their core lineups. The movement has led legacy companies to navigate the complicated supply chain and visual challenges of revamping iconic products. To break down the latest policy changes on this week’s Modern Retail Podcast, senior reporter Gabi Barkho is joined by Paris Martineau, investigative reporter at Consumer Reports, who covers food safety policy and consumer harms.  In this episode: The latest with the FDA’s industry pledge tracker The decades-long history of U.S. food manufacturers attempting to remove food dye The solutions by brands like Doritos and Cheetos, including secondary product lines without artificial colors

Key Insights

  • The Trump administration's 2025 focus on food policy through RFK Jr. created a rare moment where FDA leadership actively prioritized artificial dyes as a policy issue, contrasting with the historical joke that 'the F in FDA was silent.'
  • Trix's removal of artificial dyes 10 years ago failed because consumers rejected the resulting duller colors within a year, causing the company to reintroduce a product with original dyes—establishing a cautionary precedent for current reformulation efforts.
  • The FDA's voluntary program for removing six synthetic dyes by 2026 (later extended to 2027) lacks regulatory enforcement, meaning compliance depends on manufacturer pledges rather than legal requirements, creating ambiguity about actual industry commitment.
  • Companies are using product line segmentation (separate 'naked' or 'simply' versions) rather than reformulating core products, which may satisfy regulatory goals but potentially limits consumer awareness of the healthier option and fragments market messaging.
  • The FDA's February 2026 redefinition of 'no artificial colors' labeling allows products containing non-FD&C additives like titanium dioxide to claim this label, potentially misleading consumers about the total absence of artificial color additives.
  • Generational shift toward label-reading and clean label preferences among millennial and Gen Z parents has changed what consumers perceive as 'table stakes' for retail environments like Whole Foods, making artificial dyes a marketing liability.
  • Natural color alternatives like spirulina produce significantly duller visual results than synthetic dyes, creating a fundamental product appearance trade-off that may trigger consumer resistance similar to the It's It ice cream case study.
  • Despite industry arguments about supply chain complexity justifying extended timelines, naturally-dyed versions of products already exist and are sold successfully in Canada and Europe, suggesting the U.S. delay is partly strategic rather than technically necessary.

Topics

Artificial food dyes removal trendsFDA policy and regulatory deadlinesConsumer behavior and product reformulationThe Trix precedent and failed removal attemptRFK Jr. and Trump administration influenceNatural vs. synthetic color additivesFood labeling and marketing claimsProduct line strategy and market segmentation

Transcript

Hello, and welcome to the Modern Retail Podcast. I'm senior reporter Gabby Barco, and here with me this week is Paris Martineau, investigative reporter at Consumer Reports, who covers food safety policy and consumer harms. Paris, welcome to the show, and thank you so much for joining us this week. Thanks for having me. Big fan of the show and big fan of you. So excited to dig in. I'm a big fan of yours also. And this is a good time to maybe tell the listener that we have known each other for a long time. So this is very exciting for me that our beats finally overlapped enough to do this. It's funny. We both began as tech…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from The Modern Retail Podcast

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.