Can we fix in-store shopping?
Hosts Gabby Varko and Julia Waldo discuss major pain points in modern in-store retail experiences, including self-checkout failures, locked-up products requiring employee assistance, staffing shortages, inventory visibility issues, and unclear signage. They examine both existing technology solutions like RFID and emerging innovations while acknowledging that most problems stem from insufficient staffing rather than lack of technology.
Summary
In this episode of the Modern Retail Podcast, hosts Gabby Varko and Julia Waldo analyze broken aspects of in-store shopping experiences as the holiday season approaches. They note that despite e-commerce growth, brick-and-mortar stores still drive 35% of holiday spending according to Teneo's 2026 outlook, making store experience quality increasingly important.
The conversation begins with self-checkout technology, which has been through significant evolution but remains frustrating for consumers. While some retailers like Uniqlo have successfully implemented RFID-based checkout systems where customers drop items into bins for automatic scanning, most stores still rely on outdated systems prone to errors. Waldo notes that CVS's self-checkout frequently triggers false "item in bagging area" alerts, requiring employee intervention. Though RFID technology isn't new, widespread adoption remains limited—even major retailers like Walmart are still in pilot phases with the technology due to the complexity of tracking thousands of SKUs.
A major frustration discussed is the proliferation of locked-up products in stores like CVS and Target. This security measure, intended to prevent theft, creates significant friction by requiring customers to wait for employees to unlock cases of basic items like deodorant or shampoo. Some retailers are testing solutions where loyalty program members can unlock items themselves using phones, but these remain in pilot phases. Waldo emphasizes how this practice forces workers to leave their current tasks (restocking, register work, customer service) to assist with unlocking, reducing overall store efficiency.
The hosts address broader staffing challenges, noting that retail workers now juggle multiple responsibilities including in-store pickup, pick-and-pack fulfillment, point-of-sale operations, and handling third-party services like FedEx/UPS drop-offs. This has been exacerbated by reduced seasonal hiring—this holiday season represents the lowest seasonal hiring in recent years, leaving stores chronically understaffed.
Inventory visibility emerges as a critical issue. With the split between customer-facing inventory and back-stock reserved for online order fulfillment, customers often discover desired items aren't available in-store. This particularly affects apparel shopping where size and color variety is limited. Waldo notes that GLP-1 medication adoption is even affecting size distribution in inventory forecasting, with retailers now stocking more smalls and mediums. Kohl's and other retailers are addressing this by improving in-store inventory management systems to provide better visibility into stock levels and specific sizing.
Signage and wayfinding problems are discussed as creating customer disorientation. Both Kohl's and Target are addressing this for the holidays by clearly marking prices and discount percentages to reduce checkout surprises where items ring up at different prices than labeled. Some retailers like Dick's Sporting Goods are implementing iPad-based shoe size requests to reduce fitting room wait times.
The in-store pickup experience is noted as confusing and inconsistent across retailers. While some brands like H&M, Home Depot, and Lowe's have implemented designated pickup lockers with secure access codes, many retailers lack clear pickup designations, leaving customers searching for their orders. This creates inefficiencies and potential security issues when orders sit unattended.
Waldo highlights H&M's experimental fitting room technology that uses RFID sensors to detect items brought into changing rooms, allowing customers to request additional sizes and colors via a digital interface without leaving the fitting room. However, she notes that Gen Alpha consumers prefer fitting rooms as social experiences with friends, potentially limiting the appeal of fully automated solutions. This technology remains in pilot phases in select cities (New York, Barcelona, Dubai).
Varko's proposed solution emphasizes the locked-product friction as the most impactful issue to address, suggesting that expanded security tag systems paired with exit verification could allow easier product access while maintaining loss prevention. Waldo counters with a more fundamental observation: the core problem is inadequate staffing and training. She notes that technological solutions have proven insufficient—retailers need more floor staff to address the interconnected service failures discussed throughout the episode.
About this episode
Despite the growth of online shopping, stores are still the major driver of retail sales. And with the holiday shopping season here, the Modern Retail staff is taking the opportunity to rank some of the worst aspects of the physical shopping experience. Many retailers claim they are solving these problems with solutions through technology or better store design. But from locked-up products to confusing self-checkout, it’s clear many shoppers’ expectations are still not being met. On this week’s Modern Retail podcast, Gabi Barkho is joined by senior reporter Julia Waldow to discuss the ways retailers have gone about fixing these problems. Discussed in this episode: The confusion surrounding self-checkout The problem of waiting around for associates to help Why stores never seem to have the right inventory mix compared to their e-commerce counterparts
Key Insights
- Despite e-commerce growth intended to relieve retail pain points, physical stores still drive major holiday sales (35% of budgets), meaning store experience quality directly impacts retail success.
- Self-checkout technology improvements like RFID bin systems (used by Uniqlo, Zara) have proven effective but remain limited in adoption due to high implementation costs and complexity of tracking thousands of SKUs across store networks.
- Locked-up products create a systemic efficiency problem: employees must interrupt other tasks (restocking, registers, customer service) to unlock items, fragmenting their work and reducing overall store productivity.
- Retail workers now manage multiple simultaneous responsibilities (point-of-sale, pick-and-pack fulfillment, in-store pickup, third-party service partnerships) that didn't exist a decade ago, with no corresponding increase in staffing.
- GLP-1 medication adoption is actively reshaping apparel inventory decisions, with retailers forecasting higher demand for smaller sizes and reducing stock of larger sizes, creating availability issues for some customers.
- In-store pickup infrastructure varies wildly across retailers—some have dedicated lockers while others lack clear designated pickup areas, causing customer confusion and preventing staff from securing orders against theft.
- Experimental fitting room technology using RFID sensors to enable remote size/color requests remains in pilots in only select cities despite showing promise, indicating slow adoption of promising innovations.
- The current holiday season shows the lowest seasonal hiring in recent years, representing a systemic shift where retailers are choosing to operate with fewer employees rather than scaling staff to meet demand.
Topics
Transcript
Hello, and welcome to the Modern Retail Podcast, our show where we look at the ways retail is changing and modernizing. I'm Gabby Varko, and here with me this week is senior reporter Julia Waldo. Julia, welcome back to the show. Thanks for having me. Excited to be here. Happy almost holidays. Can't believe we're here. Yeah, I feel like November always sneaks up on us, which is why we thought to do this episode pre-Black Friday. With the holiday shopping season upon us already, we wanted to take this week as an opportunity to rank some of the worst features that make in-store shopping feel broken today. So this is based on a blend of our reporting over the…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from The Modern Retail Podcast
When Trix removed artificial colors a decade ago, sales declined. Now, brands are being forced to do the same
Major food brands are phasing out artificial dyes in response to consumer demand, regulatory pressure from the new administration, and voluntary FDA initiatives, though companies are using strategies like separate product lines to avoid alienating consumers attached to original formulations. The shift represents a significant moment after a failed attempt a decade ago when Trix removed artificial colors and saw sales decline.
How delivery apps came to be 'discovery platforms'
Hosts Gabby Barco and Ana Hansel discuss DoorDash's proposed $17 billion acquisition of Instacart, analyzing how delivery platforms are repositioning themselves as "discovery platforms" rather than pure logistics providers. They explore the strategic implications of consolidation, AI-powered shopping assistants, retail media advertising, and competition with Amazon.
What constitutes a wellness brand?
Three retail and wellness industry experts debate how to define 'wellness' as the category expands across food, beauty, home, and other sectors. They discuss the blurring lines between wellness, health, and better-for-you products, ultimately concluding that true wellness should focus on longevity and quality of life rather than becoming a catch-all marketing term for any product.
The rise of 'Adultoween' and how adults are driving Halloween spending
Halloween has evolved into a multi-billion dollar retail phenomenon driven increasingly by adult consumers rather than children, with spending reaching $13.5 billion in 2024. Adults are celebrating Halloween year-round through elaborate parties, costumes, themed decor, and seasonal food and beverage products, fundamentally transforming the holiday from a single trick-or-treating night into an extended season-long celebration.
Why Depop is putting music at the center of its marketing, collaborating with Zara Larsson and Olivia Rodrigo
Depop's Senior Director of Brand and Creative Steve Duhl discusses how the peer-to-peer secondhand marketplace identified music as a key marketing growth engine, leveraging research showing 56% of their audience attends live music events. The strategy evolved from organic artist collaborations and shop-drop campaigns to larger activations like festival sponsorships and full-scale campaigns with artists like Zara Larsson and Olivia Rodrigo.