What constitutes a wellness brand?
Three retail and wellness industry experts debate how to define 'wellness' as the category expands across food, beauty, home, and other sectors. They discuss the blurring lines between wellness, health, and better-for-you products, ultimately concluding that true wellness should focus on longevity and quality of life rather than becoming a catch-all marketing term for any product.
Summary
The Modern Retail Podcast episode features Gabby Barco (senior reporter), Lexi Leipzak (Glossy correspondent), and Rachel Hirsch (managing partner at Wellness Growth Ventures) examining what constitutes a wellness product in an increasingly fragmented market. The conversation begins with Rachel's investment thesis—that wellness is broad but her fund focuses on narrower categories like nutritious food-as-medicine, with plans to expand the mandate over time. Lexi notes that beauty and wellness coverage has converged, making it difficult to distinguish between health and wellness products. Gabby covers the better-for-you food space and observes that traditional boundaries between supplements and food have collapsed, with companies like Unilever Wellbeing pushing the overlap further.
The panel uses Belly Welly as a case study—a brand that evolved from snack bars to a pure supplement company, demonstrating the fluidity between food and wellness categories. Rachel emphasizes that oral care (specifically Flouse electric flossers) represents the clearest wellness category because compliance produces measurable health outcomes affecting longevity, quality of life, and even beauty.
A significant tension emerges around fortified foods and functional products. Rachel expresses frustration that adding protein to Doritos doesn't make them healthy and warns against conflating "better for you" with "wellness." The panel agrees that GLP-1 drugs have created a market opportunity for fortified snacks and protein products, though the efficacy and long-term impacts remain unclear. They discuss whether everything—from humidifiers to skincare to breathing strips—can truly be wellness, with Gabby expressing concern that if everything becomes wellness, then nothing is wellness.
The conversation turns to skincare and beauty as wellness categories. The panel agrees that protective, strengthening skincare supports skin longevity and can be considered wellness, but anti-aging messaging targeting insecurities is questionable. Lexi notes that major beauty companies (Estée Lauder, L'Oréal) are acquiring wellness-focused startups and rebranding around longevity and biohacking rather than anti-aging.
A critical discussion examines the difference between health and wellness. Rachel argues that distinguishing between interior interventions (like inhalers) and exterior optimizations (like nose strips) is useful, though the lines remain blurred. Lexi raises the example of nicotine pouches marketed as cognitive enhancers—a trend she finds particularly problematic because it repackages harmful products as wellness based on limited studies.
Rachel defends the wellness industry, arguing that predatory greenwashing companies "hopping on the bandwagon" are not true wellness companies and should be excluded from the category. She positions genuine wellness companies as those genuinely advancing health outcomes, citing Fish Wife tinned fish as an example of a product where nutrition is a byproduct of pleasure and quality ingredients.
The panel concludes with a lightning round assessing whether specific products qualify as wellness: fragrance/olfactory claims (no), humidifiers (yes), and protein seltzer (no). They agree that many products marketed as wellness are simply "better for you" indulgences and shouldn't be conflated with genuine health and longevity benefits. The episode ends with acknowledgment that wellness definitions will continue evolving in real time.
About this episode
From oral care to shower filters, many categories are bleeding over into the so-called wellness space. That begs the question: What exactly constitutes a wellness product? This episode of the Modern Retail Podcast explores the blurring boundaries of the health and wellness market. To discuss this phenomenon, host Gabi Barkho is joined by Glossy West Coast correspondent Lexy Lebsack and Rachel Hirsch, founder and managing partner at Wellness Growth Ventures, which has invested in brands like BelliWelli and Flaus. The episode breaks down the definition of a wellness product as the category increasingly intersects with food, beverage, beauty and even home gadgets. The panel also delves into growth areas and trends to watch, including hormone health, oral care, gummy supplements and GLP-1 support, highlighting how major retailers and brands are adapting to this convergence. This episode dives into: Why everyone is cashing in on “wellness” How consumers’ longevity goals are driving CPG trends The line between a health product and wellness routines
Key Insights
- Rachel Hirsch's investment thesis treats wellness as broader conceptually but invests narrowly in nutritious food-as-medicine categories, with plans to expand the mandate like peeling an onion's layers over subsequent funds.
- Belly Welly's evolution from snack bars to pure supplement company exemplifies how brands oscillate between food and wellness categories based on market fit and consumer need.
- Rachel argues oral care represents the purest wellness category because compliance directly produces measurable outcomes (improved gum health, reduced dementia risk, better longevity) visible to consumers.
- Rachel contends that adding protein to Doritos is 'consumerism at its best' and actively harms society by allowing consumers to rationalize unhealthy consumption as wellness rather than progressing public health.
- Lexi observes that the beauty and skincare industries are appropriating wellness trends similarly to how they previously adopted clean beauty and skinification, potentially creating predatory marketing patterns.
- The panel agrees that nicotine pouches marketed as cognitive enhancers exemplify problematic wellness claims because they repackage harmful products based on preliminary studies, like discredited claims about daily wine consumption.
- Rachel distinguishes true wellness companies from predatory ones by whether they genuinely advance health outcomes—citing Fish Wife tinned fish as authentic wellness where nutrition enhances rather than masks indulgence.
- Gabby expresses concern that if 'everything becomes wellness,' then 'nothing is wellness,' mirroring how self-care evolved from meaningful personal care to justifying any consumer purchase by 2020.
Topics
Transcript
Hello, and welcome to the Modern Retail Podcast, our show about the ways the retail industry is changing and modernizing. I am senior reporter Gabby Barco. Every day we see more categories bleeding into so-called wellness. Everything from food, beverage, beauty, and even home gadgets are all now somewhat tied into health and wellness routines. That begs the question, what exactly constitutes a wellness product? Joining me today to discuss this trend is Lexi Leipzak, West Coast correspondent at our sister site, Glossy, and Rachel Hirsch, managing partner at Wellness Growth Ventures, which is invested in brands like Belly Welly and Flouse. Guys, thank you so much for joining us. I'm so excited to talk all things wellness with you…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from The Modern Retail Podcast
When Trix removed artificial colors a decade ago, sales declined. Now, brands are being forced to do the same
Major food brands are phasing out artificial dyes in response to consumer demand, regulatory pressure from the new administration, and voluntary FDA initiatives, though companies are using strategies like separate product lines to avoid alienating consumers attached to original formulations. The shift represents a significant moment after a failed attempt a decade ago when Trix removed artificial colors and saw sales decline.
Can we fix in-store shopping?
Hosts Gabby Varko and Julia Waldo discuss major pain points in modern in-store retail experiences, including self-checkout failures, locked-up products requiring employee assistance, staffing shortages, inventory visibility issues, and unclear signage. They examine both existing technology solutions like RFID and emerging innovations while acknowledging that most problems stem from insufficient staffing rather than lack of technology.
How delivery apps came to be 'discovery platforms'
Hosts Gabby Barco and Ana Hansel discuss DoorDash's proposed $17 billion acquisition of Instacart, analyzing how delivery platforms are repositioning themselves as "discovery platforms" rather than pure logistics providers. They explore the strategic implications of consolidation, AI-powered shopping assistants, retail media advertising, and competition with Amazon.
The rise of 'Adultoween' and how adults are driving Halloween spending
Halloween has evolved into a multi-billion dollar retail phenomenon driven increasingly by adult consumers rather than children, with spending reaching $13.5 billion in 2024. Adults are celebrating Halloween year-round through elaborate parties, costumes, themed decor, and seasonal food and beverage products, fundamentally transforming the holiday from a single trick-or-treating night into an extended season-long celebration.
Why Depop is putting music at the center of its marketing, collaborating with Zara Larsson and Olivia Rodrigo
Depop's Senior Director of Brand and Creative Steve Duhl discusses how the peer-to-peer secondhand marketplace identified music as a key marketing growth engine, leveraging research showing 56% of their audience attends live music events. The strategy evolved from organic artist collaborations and shop-drop campaigns to larger activations like festival sponsorships and full-scale campaigns with artists like Zara Larsson and Olivia Rodrigo.