Can We Still Believe Card Prices?
David Chase and Gregory Miller discuss concerns about card price manipulation and market credibility, particularly examining extreme price spikes in Pokémon cards and vintage sports cards. They explore how limited supply, comparison comps, and potential collusion could artificially inflate values, while emphasizing the importance of skepticism and questioning market fundamentals.
Summary
In this episode of 'Midlife Card Chase,' hosts David Chase and Gregory Miller explore troubling trends in card pricing, particularly extreme valuations that seem disconnected from any identifiable fundamentals. They reference a Pokémon Cresselia card that sold for $9,000 on September 25th and then $960,000 just 10 days later—a roughly 107x increase—as evidence that something may be broken in how cards are priced. Miller notes that while Card Ladder verifies these sales actually occurred, the magnitude of increases raises red flags about market manipulation.
The hosts examine how the hobby's reliance on recent comparable sales (comps) as the sole pricing mechanism creates vulnerability to manipulation. They propose a scenario where a group could accumulate a large percentage of scarce cards, artificially pump one sale to an extreme price, and then leverage that inflated comp to sell their inventory at massively higher prices—potentially through off-market cash deals that never appear in public comps. They draw parallels to the 1987 Fleer Michael Jordan market, noting that collector Paul Probstein publicly owns roughly 100 of the 350 PSA 10 copies and has stated he maintains a price floor by buying any cards offered below his target price.
Chase and Miller distinguish between genuine price appreciation based on emerging interest or scarcity (like Gary Vee discussing undervalued Shaquille O'Neal or Barry Bonds cards) versus artificial pumping, acknowledging that the line is blurry. They emphasize that while they believe in sports cards long-term, the current market environment—where prices can 10x in weeks with no fundamental change—is unhealthy and unsustainable.
The hosts recommend skepticism toward dramatic price spikes, particularly on limited-population cards. They suggest using smaller, less-mainstream auction houses (accessed through Auction Wire) to find more realistic pricing away from coordinated efforts. Miller notes his recent major purchase (a Jackie Robinson card) felt defensible because Jackie Robinson has genuine societal impact, making the card less susceptible to manipulation than Pokémon cards with no underlying narrative.
They warn that many newer collectors have never experienced a market correction and may face financial hardship if a recession forces mass liquidation of cards purchased on credit or from retirement funds. The episode concludes with card recommendations: David recommends a 1955 Topps Hank Aaron card (PSA 2, ~$400) as affordable yet meaningful, and Greg recommends a 1993 SP Foil Derek Jeter as an undervalued card with long-term potential.
Key Insights
- The Cresselia Pokémon card sold for $9,000 on September 25th and $960,000 ten days later, a 107x increase with no underlying change in fundamentals, suggesting the pricing mechanism itself may be compromised or manipulated.
- If a group owned 30 of 46 available copies of a scarce card and paid $3,000 each ($90,000 total), they could artificially pump one sale to $960,000 through collusion, then sell their 30 cards at that new comp price for $30 million total profit—demonstrating how limited-supply cards are vulnerable to market manipulation.
- Paul Probstein publicly owns approximately 100 of the 350 PSA 10 copies of the 1987 Fleer Jordan card and has stated he will maintain a price floor by purchasing any copies offered below his target price, essentially controlling the market comp for all lower-grade versions.
- The hobby's entire pricing system depends on recent comps as the sole mechanism for valuation, meaning that if even one or two people collude to create an inflated sale, that single transaction becomes the baseline for calculating value across entire inventory—making manipulation trivially easy.
- Many newer collectors entering over the past three years have only experienced upward price movement and have never witnessed a market correction, leaving them vulnerable to significant financial loss if a recession forces liquidation and flood of cards onto the market.
Topics
Transcript
[0:01] sports talk [music] all day. Wax packs big and we debate. So turn it and let the intro play. You're now rocking with the midlife car chase. The David Chase, what's up, brother? >> Nothing much. Gregory Miller, good to see you, my friend. >> You know my name's not actually Gregory, just for the record. >> Oh, it legally is Greg. Like Greg Nettles, huh? >> Yeah. Did you really think it was Gregory? >> I for I always feel like everyone's name [0:32] that is Greg is Gregory. >> No, I don't think anybody's is. >> Oh, well, I probably have called you Gregory seven times. This is the first time you've ever corrected me on it.…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Sports Card Clubhouse
Who Won The Hit List Vintage Card Value Challenge?
Jake and Matt from The Hit List Sports Card Clubhouse compare the performance of vintage baseball cards they selected six months earlier in a value challenge. Jake's high-end blue chip cards increased 31.4% in value, significantly outperforming Matt's more diversified picks which gained 11.27%, demonstrating stronger recent growth in premium-tier vintage cards.
Getting Caught in a Bidding War! + Mantle vs. Jackie + The Price of Letting Go
Jeremy Lee, David Chase, and Joe Perau discuss Jeremy's emotional experience selling three iconic baseball cards (Mickey Mantle, Jackie Robinson, Babe Ruth), getting caught in a bidding war over a Sydney Crosby hockey card, and debate the comparative investment potential of the 52 Topps Jackie Robinson versus the 52 Topps Mickey Mantle.
How Our Card Collecting Has Recently CHANGED!!
Mike and Greg discuss how their card collecting habits have evolved over the past 3-5 years, moving away from complete player runs and graded sets toward more selective, passion-driven collecting. They then review seven items from Greg's eBay watchlist, ranking them by desirability and discussing what these choices reveal about their shifting collector identities.
Investigating The Future Of Sports Card Values- MidLife Card Chase
David Chase and Greg Miller discuss the card hobby through a tier-based framework, comparing player and set hierarchies across 1950s baseball, 1990s basketball inserts, and modern cards. They argue that understanding tier structures helps identify undervalued collecting opportunities and provides a systematic approach to entering new collecting lanes.
Selling "Identity Cards"
In this episode of Turn Back the Clock, Adam and Shane discuss the concept of 'identity cards'—cards that define a collector's identity—inspired by Jeremy Lee's recent episode about selling major cards at the Toronto Expo. They explore their own collections, sharing examples of irreplaceable cards like Shane's Josh Gibson Super Fractor and Adam's 2009 Topps Chrome Gold Refractor Mickey Mantle, and showcase recent acquisitions including vintage Disney cards, buyback rookies, and non-sports memorabilia.