Who Won The Hit List Vintage Card Value Challenge?
Jake and Matt from The Hit List Sports Card Clubhouse compare the performance of vintage baseball cards they selected six months earlier in a value challenge. Jake's high-end blue chip cards increased 31.4% in value, significantly outperforming Matt's more diversified picks which gained 11.27%, demonstrating stronger recent growth in premium-tier vintage cards.
Summary
In this follow-up episode of Extra Innings on the Sports Card Clubhouse, hosts Jake T. O'Donnell and Matt from Providence review results from a vintage card value challenge filmed six months prior. Each host had selected five cards and tracked their PSA 3 average values over six months to determine whose picks performed better.
Jake's selections were high-end, iconic rookie and notable cards: 1949 Leaf Jackie Robinson (+22.15% to $21,195), 1951 Bowman Mickey Mantle rookie (+37.44% to $28,879), 1954 Topps Hank Aaron (+13.18% to $5,256), 1951 Bowman Willie Mays rookie (+27.7% to $9,393), and 1933 Gowdy Sport Kings Babe Ruth (+78.09% to $12,200). Jake acknowledges he got lucky with the Ruth card, which had no sales for over a year before selling for $12,200 two days after his initial valuation.
Matt's selections represented a more diversified approach with lower-tier cards: 1955 Topps Roberto Clemente rookie (+16.42%), 1939 Playball Joe DiMaggio (+15.59%), 1963 Topps Pete Rose rookie (+19.9%), 1969 Topps Mantle white letter (+5%), and 1914 Cracker Jack Ed Cicotte (no sales recorded). Matt chose two non-Hall of Famers and acknowledged his picks were made without preparation, contrasting with Jake's strategic selection of blue chip cards.
Overall results showed Jake's portfolio gained 31.4% compared to Matt's 11.27%. When excluding the lucky Ruth sale and the Cicotte with no sales data, the gap narrows to 29% versus 15%. Jake concludes that high-end blue chip vintage cards have appreciated at 25-30% rates over six months, while mid-tier cards show 15-20% growth, suggesting the premium card market remains strong. Both hosts express interest in repeating the challenge, with Matt suggesting he would prepare more thoroughly for the next iteration.
Key Insights
- Jake's 1951 Bowman Mickey Mantle rookie increased 37.44% in value, which both hosts identified beforehand as having significant room to move in the market
- Jake got lucky with the 1933 Gowdy Babe Ruth card because it had no PSA 3 sales for over a year before one sold for $12,200 just two days after his initial valuation, inflating his portfolio gains
- High-end blue chip vintage cards appreciated at a 25-30% rate over six months, while the next tier down cards showed 15-20% appreciation, indicating differentiated market performance by card tier
- Matt chose two non-Hall of Famers (Pete Rose and Ed Cicotte) and made his selections without preparation, acknowledging this strategic difference from Jake's prepared blue chip approach
- The 1954 Topps Hank Aaron showed the lowest appreciation rate among Jake's cards at 13.18%, suggesting concerns about whether the highest-priced cards maintain consistent growth rates
Topics
Transcript
[0:08] [music] [music] Welcome to Extra Innings on the Sports Card Clubhouse with The Hit List. That is Matt from Providence. >> And that is Jake T. O'Donnell. Don't don't forget the T. It's just Okay, there it is. >> All right. >> So you got to show towards the camera [0:39] and then to the right. It looks left. It's it's that way. >> I I never do it right. >> backward. It's like a mirror. >> Uh welcome welcome back. Uh we are doing a bit of a We're doing a follow-up here. >> So you know how I was kind of late to showing up to this because it took me a few more minutes than and…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Sports Card Clubhouse
Get Fired Up!
In this rapid-fire 30-minute episode of "Turn Back the Clock," the hosts showcase and discuss their favorite card acquisitions, including rare 1996-1997 Topps Chrome refractor cards of Mickey Mantle and Jackie Robinson, Negro League player cards, and affordable Kobe Bryant Pacific rookies. The episode emphasizes the historical significance of parallels versus inserts and highlights the growing popularity of modern parallels with low print runs.
Getting Caught in a Bidding War! + Mantle vs. Jackie + The Price of Letting Go
Jeremy Lee, David Chase, and Joe Perau discuss Jeremy's emotional experience selling three iconic baseball cards (Mickey Mantle, Jackie Robinson, Babe Ruth), getting caught in a bidding war over a Sydney Crosby hockey card, and debate the comparative investment potential of the 52 Topps Jackie Robinson versus the 52 Topps Mickey Mantle.
How Our Card Collecting Has Recently CHANGED!!
Mike and Greg discuss how their card collecting habits have evolved over the past 3-5 years, moving away from complete player runs and graded sets toward more selective, passion-driven collecting. They then review seven items from Greg's eBay watchlist, ranking them by desirability and discussing what these choices reveal about their shifting collector identities.
Investigating The Future Of Sports Card Values- MidLife Card Chase
David Chase and Greg Miller discuss the card hobby through a tier-based framework, comparing player and set hierarchies across 1950s baseball, 1990s basketball inserts, and modern cards. They argue that understanding tier structures helps identify undervalued collecting opportunities and provides a systematic approach to entering new collecting lanes.
Selling "Identity Cards"
In this episode of Turn Back the Clock, Adam and Shane discuss the concept of 'identity cards'—cards that define a collector's identity—inspired by Jeremy Lee's recent episode about selling major cards at the Toronto Expo. They explore their own collections, sharing examples of irreplaceable cards like Shane's Josh Gibson Super Fractor and Adam's 2009 Topps Chrome Gold Refractor Mickey Mantle, and showcase recent acquisitions including vintage Disney cards, buyback rookies, and non-sports memorabilia.