DiscussionOpinion

Getting Caught in a Bidding War! + Mantle vs. Jackie + The Price of Letting Go

Sports Card Clubhouse

Jeremy Lee, David Chase, and Joe Perau discuss Jeremy's emotional experience selling three iconic baseball cards (Mickey Mantle, Jackie Robinson, Babe Ruth), getting caught in a bidding war over a Sydney Crosby hockey card, and debate the comparative investment potential of the 52 Topps Jackie Robinson versus the 52 Topps Mickey Mantle.

Summary

The episode opens with announcements about the Strongsville card show relocating to Columbus, Ohio on April 16-18, 2027, and plans for Sports Cards Live to broadcast from the Front Row Card Show in Pasadena that Saturday. Jeremy discusses the emotional toll of selling his long-held cards—the Mickey Mantle (owned 20 years), Jackie Robinson (13 years), and Babe Ruth (2 years)—at the recent Toronto card show. He expresses genuine grief about parting with the Mantle and Jackie despite receiving substantial payment, drawing parallels to ending a long-term relationship. Jeremy explains that the monetary gain doesn't compensate for losing cards he loved and had invested decades in owning. He reflects on lessons learned, noting he would have priced these cards higher to avoid selling them, and plans to bring high-value cards to future shows with security protection. The discussion shifts to comparing the 51 Bowman Mantle and 52 Topps Jackie Robinson cards. Joe raises questions about whether the Jackie could eventually surpass the Mantle in value and prestige, referencing conversations from recent podcast content. David provides market data showing a PSA 3 52 Topps Jackie sold for $30,000 while a PSA 3 52 Topps Mantle sold for $170,000—approximately 5.6 times higher. They reference Adam Gray's 2022 collector survey ranking the 51 Bowman Mantle at #14 most iconic and the 52 Topps Jackie at #24, though a 1990 book ranked the 51 Bowman Mantle at #12 without the Jackie in the top 100. The group debates whether this gap will tighten or if the Jackie has fewer alternative investment options compared to Mantle (which has the 51 Bowman, 53 Topps, 56 Topps, Red Heart, and other options). Jeremy acquired a 52 Topps Jackie Robinson to partially replace the sold Jackie, viewing it as undervalued with strong future growth potential. The final major topic covers Jeremy getting caught in an emotional bidding war while live-streaming on Fanatics for a 2024 Fleer Ultra Medallions Sidney Crosby one-of-one card, eventually paying $5,000—significantly more than expected. David criticizes this approach, explaining he researches maximum bid prices the day before auctions to remain disciplined and unemotional. Jeremy defends his method, arguing that his 45 years of experience allow him to rely on gut instinct, though he did pause mid-auction to verify the card's value. He explains that he's comfortable with moderate losses on cards since ownership enjoyment has intrinsic value comparable to attending movies or sporting events. Joe mediates by noting that Jeremy is now collecting active players and one-of-ones more seriously. The show concludes with logistics for the Saturday broadcast at 7 PM Pacific/10 PM Eastern and an invitation for viewers to introduce themselves at the show.

Key Insights

  • Jeremy argues that owning cards for extended periods creates intrinsic value beyond financial returns—20 years with the Mantle and 13 with the Jackie created emotional bonds he cannot replace with similar-grade copies, and money from the sale does not compensate for the void in his collection identity
  • The 52 Topps Jackie has significantly lower population (2,200) compared to other iconic cards like the 51 Bowman Mantle (4,300), 48 Leaf Jackie (3,000), and other tier-one vintage cards, yet trades at a substantial discount to the Mantle despite being recognized as a culturally significant card for over 15 years
  • Jeremy contends that while the 52 Topps Jackie may eventually surpass the 52 Topps Mantle in value within 20-30 years due to Jackie Robinson's greater historical and cultural significance to American society, the gap is unlikely to close in the near term due to Mantle having more desirable alternative vintage options for collectors
  • Jeremy admits to getting caught in emotional bidding wars while live-streaming, bidding 'just out of principle' without a predetermined maximum price, though he eventually paused mid-auction to research comparative values before committing to the final $5,000 Crosby purchase
  • David Chase argues that disciplined auction buyers should research and write down maximum bids the day before auctions to remove emotional decision-making, which causes him to lose some desired cards but prevents the significant overpayment that can occur when bidding live during competitive auctions

Topics

Selling high-value vintage cards and emotional attachmentComparison of 51 Bowman Mantle vs 52 Topps Jackie Robinson investment potentialBidding war psychology and auction disciplineCard grading, population counts, and market value analysisActive player and modern one-of-one card collectingStrongsville card show relocation announcement

Transcript

[0:00] We ready to get started here? >> Yeah. >> Well, I just I have one question. What is the latest report on grieving the three the three main cards that he lost? I know >> find out on the show. >> No, but at one point it was the Ruth, but then >> Joe, save it for the show. We're taping. This is the questions that you're going to be asking them. Are you ready, Joe Perau? >> I guess you you better get more pumped up for that. This is your first time you're on the show in a long time. Let's do this. [0:31] >> The hangover. [music] [music] What is going on? Welcome guys to Hangover…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Sports Card Clubhouse

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.