NewsOpinion

PSA / FedEx heist impact has GROWN, but PSA is being quiet about it!

Junk Wax Hero

Mike discusses how PSA's handling of the October 13th FedEx heist has expanded beyond initial reports, with PSA quietly discovering additional stolen items weeks later without proactive notification to affected sellers. PSA continues to lack transparency about the full scope of the theft and has not updated their public list despite identifying a second wave of affected shipments.

Summary

Mike opens his Wednesday video discussing a PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator) situation involving a FedEx truck robbery that occurred on October 13th. He shares multiple accounts from sellers who discovered their cards were part of the theft weeks after the incident, with PSA failing to notify them proactively. The first case involves a seller who had 11 cards stolen, discovered the theft nearly three weeks later only by checking their account status when payments weren't received. PSA never sent notification emails, and the seller had to investigate independently.

Mike highlights several additional similar cases where sellers graded cards through PSA and sold them via eBay or PSA's vault system, only to discover they were on the stolen FedEx truck. These sellers received delayed responses from PSA, with some being told to "sit tight" and wait for further updates. The common thread is that PSA's different departments failed to communicate—when cards were stolen in transit, PSA's vault system didn't connect with their sales platform to identify the problem.

A crucial discovery occurred when Neo pointed out that PSA quietly added an editor's note on November 10th (nearly three weeks after the original incident) to their October 23rd update, revealing they had identified additional parcels impacted by the theft through reconciliation of shipment records. This indicates PSA initially missed many stolen items and only discovered them through audit processes. The note mentions items were insured and owners would be compensated, but PSA has been contacting affected parties slowly and only after sellers reached out themselves.

Mike expresses concern that the original estimate of $968,000 in stolen goods is far too low, given that additional items are still being discovered. He questions whether it was just a pallet and a half as initially reported, or if multiple pallets or the entire truck was involved. He speculates there may be additional waves of discoveries in the coming months. Despite PSA publishing a 93-page list of 6,451 items from the original theft, they have not yet updated this list with the newly discovered items from the second wave. Mike criticizes PSA's response as reactive rather than proactive, noting that they should have discovered all affected items initially by cross-referencing their systems. He concludes by expressing skepticism that this situation will ever be fully resolved, drawing parallels to other unsolved crimes in the collecting hobby that fade from public attention without clear resolution.

Key Insights

  • PSA's different internal departments failed to communicate when cards were stolen in transit, allowing auctions to complete and payments to process despite items being part of the theft
  • PSA quietly added a significant editor's note nearly three weeks after the original incident revealing they discovered additional stolen parcels through shipment audits, indicating the initial investigation missed many items
  • Multiple sellers discovered their cards were stolen only by independently checking their accounts when payments weren't received, as PSA failed to proactively notify affected parties
  • The original $968,000 theft estimate is likely significantly understated based on the discovery of additional waves of affected shipments, raising questions about whether more than one pallet or the entire truck was involved
  • PSA has not updated their published 93-page list of 6,451 stolen items despite discovering a second wave of affected shipments, leaving the full scope of the theft undisclosed to the public

Topics

PSA FedEx heist October 13th theftSeller notification failures and communication gapsScope and value of theft expandingPSA internal departmental communication failuresLack of transparency and delayed discovery of affected itemsInsurance and compensation for affected sellersComparison to unresolved crimes in collecting hobby

Transcript

[0:01] Hey everybody, it is Mike. It's Wednesday and uh I talked about this on Sunday. Well, I guess it was my Monday episode. Clearing the bases generally comes out on Sunday. I said, you know, I'm kind of monitoring this situation and I might do a video midweek about it. I'm going to share my screen here and show you what I'm talking about because uh it it has risen to the level in my opinion of something that needs covering. And Neo covered this this morning. First of all, this is the one I [0:31] talked about. This person Parker PM Commerce tag PSA on uh this was nine days ago saying, "Just found out I had 11…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Junk Wax Hero

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.