DiscussionOpinion

Huge Boston card show PACKED! But were collectors buying?

Junk Wax Hero

Mike attends the Greater Boston Sports Collectors Convention and finds it packed with foot traffic but observes that collectors are spending less money than before. He discusses market trends with dealers, explores the show's inventory of vintage and modern cards, and reflects on broader market dynamics affected by recent pullbacks and seasonal patterns.

Summary

Mike visits the Greater Boston Sports Collectors Convention at the Shriners Auditorium with his friend Oliver and young collector Cody, a 12-year-old who had saved money to purchase a 1989 Upper Deck Kangri Jr. rookie card. The show is extremely well-attended with packed parking lots and crowded aisles, though Mike notes the crowd thins out by early afternoon.

Despite the high foot traffic, conversations with both collectors and dealers reveal a spending slowdown. Dealers confirm people are not purchasing as much, though attendance remains strong. Mike discusses this trend on Sports Car Clubhouse with Teapot, attributing it to typical November market pullbacks. He notes that recency bias affects how people view short-term price declines (down 20% in three months) while ignoring longer-term gains (up 100% over the year).

Mike emphasizes that the unprecedented market boom of the past 18 months, which continued through the previous November unlike historical patterns, created unrealistic expectations. He expects a possible uptick around Christmas but not a return to the sustained growth seen since 2021. He remains neutral on the market's direction and views price declines as potential buying opportunities rather than cause for concern.

The show features extensive vintage inventory including rare cards like Pistol Pete autographed rookie, 1957 Topps basketball packs, multiple Jackie Robinson 1948-49 Leaf cards, Babe Ruth cards, and vintage programs from classic games. Mike notes an increase in non-sports collectibles including Rocky, Star Wars, Beatles, and Three Stooges packs. He purchases only one card—an iconic 1980s autographed card to complete his collection goals—and receives generous gifts from Cody and other viewers.

Key Insights

  • Dealers report strong foot traffic at the show but confirm that people are not spending as much money, suggesting a disconnect between attendance and actual purchasing behavior
  • The unprecedented 18-month market boom that continued through the previous November (breaking historical patterns) created unrealistic expectations that November 2023 would see similar growth
  • Short-term price declines of 20% in three months are being perceived as catastrophic despite cards being up 100% over the year, demonstrating how recency bias affects collector perception of market health
  • Non-sports collectibles inventory appears to have increased noticeably at the show, including items like Rocky, Star Wars, Beatles, and Three Stooges packs, possibly reflecting broader hobby expansion during the boom period
  • Mike maintains market neutrality regardless of direction, viewing price declines as buying opportunities rather than reasons for concern, suggesting a long-term collection perspective rather than short-term investment mentality

Topics

Card show attendance and market spending patternsSeasonal market trends and recency biasVintage card inventory and pricingYoung collectors and collector communityNon-sports collectibles growth

Transcript

[0:00] Card shows are still seeing a lot of foot traffic, but are people still spending a lot of money at them? Hey, it's Mike. Thanks for tuning back in. So, yesterday, Saturday, uh I went to the Greater Boston Sports Collectors Convention or whatever it's called. Uh it's at the Shriners Auditorium. It used to be called I don't even know what it used to be called. It's changes hands. It changes names. It is a big show. It's a very well-run show. It's in the big huge Shriner's Auditorium. A lot of [0:31] vintage sports cards, a lot of a lot of modern, too. Very little Pokemon, so it's kind of perfect for a guy like me. A…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Junk Wax Hero

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.