The PSA / FedEx truck heist fallout is likely bigger than is being reported!
A FedEx truck heist resulted in the theft of three pallets of graded trading cards from PSA, with total losses potentially exceeding $1 million. PSA is offering significantly lowball compensation based on vague valuations, often far below the actual card values and fees customers paid, while customers are legally advised not to share settlement details.
Summary
On Wednesday, the speaker covers the massive PSA/FedEx truck heist involving stolen graded trading cards. A FedEx driver left a truck parked near PSA for 60-90 minutes, during which the truck's lock was broken and packages containing valuable graded cards were stolen from three pallets. The incident reportedly involved hundreds of customers with losses potentially exceeding $1 million.
A major concern is PSA's compensation offers, which appear significantly undervalued. Examples cited include: an order with 169 items valued at $4,223 (approximately $25 per card, which doesn't even cover the $5,000 in PSA grading fees alone), and a collector losing cards valued at $15,000+ but receiving a $4,200 offer. Another customer with 50 high-end cards describes PSA's handling as incompetent or deliberately attempting bad-faith settlement. Seth Feifer reportedly lost approximately $70,000 in value, and SkyBards lost over $100,000 in cards.
PSA's initial compensation language stated "fair market value or maximum insured value, whichever is less," but the official statement shifted to only mentioning "fair market value." There's ambiguity about whether PSA's insurance covers items once handed to FedEx. Customers report that PSA is sending wrong valuations, failing to provide itemized breakdowns, and requiring confidentiality agreements that prevent sharing settlement details.
The speaker notes that many collectors knew the card grades before shipment since they had already been graded and registered in PSA's system. Multiple people are advising others to withdraw high-value cards from PSA vaults to avoid similar shipping risks. The speaker also discusses alternative shipping methods like USPS registered mail, which offers better security and makes theft a federal crime. There's discussion about whether this was an inside job, though details remain unclear pending video evidence.
Key Insights
- PSA's compensation offer to one customer was $4,223 for 169 items, which amounts to approximately $25 per card and doesn't even cover the customer's $5,000 in grading fees alone, indicating extreme lowballing
- The FedEx driver left the truck parked near PSA for 60-90 minutes unattended before the lock was broken and packages were stolen, raising questions about whether this was an inside job or negligence
- PSA changed its compensation language from stating 'fair market value or maximum insured value, whichever is less' to only mentioning 'fair market value,' potentially to avoid higher payouts based on max insured value
- Customers are reportedly being advised legally not to share specifics of PSA's settlement offers, creating a situation where affected parties cannot publicly compare or challenge valuations
- USPS registered mail offers superior security compared to FedEx, including tamper-evident stamps, single-key custody, chain of custody documentation, and making theft a federal crime rather than a state crime
Topics
Transcript
[0:01] Good morning and happy Wednesday. Today's Wednesday. Uh I don't usually do clearing the bases on Wednesdays, but there's this whole PSA FedEx truck heist has been massive news and I have way too much stuff here to not cover it in a midday clearing the bases. So, we're going to jump in. And first of all, I want to acknowledge there's still a lot that we don't know and there's a ton of speculation and I'm really excited to see the video. I I know there's no word of a video yet, but [0:33] in today's day and age, Neo showed a map yesterday on his video. Uh it feels like there has to be a video of…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Junk Wax Hero
I'd never heard of these cards before!
Mike opens mail from his PO box featuring video game and sports cards, with particular excitement about a 1993 Ben Presto Super Mario Kart card. He discusses his collection of Nintendo-related cards and games, displays various graded cards in penny sleeves, and thanks viewers for their generous contributions while seeking identification of mystery cards.
PSA / FedEx heist impact has GROWN, but PSA is being quiet about it!
Mike discusses how PSA's handling of the October 13th FedEx heist has expanded beyond initial reports, with PSA quietly discovering additional stolen items weeks later without proactive notification to affected sellers. PSA continues to lack transparency about the full scope of the theft and has not updated their public list despite identifying a second wave of affected shipments.
Topps Messed Up ANOTHER Chase Card! | Dad Left Child Alone For Cards?? | & More Sports Card News!
A weekly sports card industry news episode covering Topps' major error with missing chase cards in their Cosmic Chrome baseball release, a disturbing incident of a father leaving his young daughter unattended at a Pokemon card event, and various other industry news including grading statistics, auction records, and authentication issues.
Huge Boston card show PACKED! But were collectors buying?
Mike attends the Greater Boston Sports Collectors Convention and finds it packed with foot traffic but observes that collectors are spending less money than before. He discusses market trends with dealers, explores the show's inventory of vintage and modern cards, and reflects on broader market dynamics affected by recent pullbacks and seasonal patterns.
FOUND: man discovers family's two very rare tickets to Jackie Robinson's debut game!!
A man discovered two adjacent tickets to Jackie Robinson's historic debut game on April 15, 1947, while going through his father's and grandfather's belongings in October. With only about a dozen such tickets known to exist, these tickets are extraordinarily rare and valuable, with comparable tickets selling between $300,000 and $480,000 depending on condition.