PSA Reopens Value - But For How Long?? | $3 Million Repack Hit! | & More Sports Card News!
In this weekly sports card news roundup, the host discusses PSA's surprising reopening of value-tier grading at $39.99, debunks false reports about a $50 million Mickey Mantle sale, covers the PSA FedEx heist fallout with missing high-value cards, and showcases major sales including a $2.2 million Kobe Bryant jersey and a $1.5 million 1962 Topps football set. The episode also highlights quality control issues with Topps card errors and discusses emerging fraudulent schemes targeting card shops.
Summary
The host opens with personal Halloween commentary before diving into major sports card industry news. First, he addresses confusion from the previous week about an alleged $50 million PSA 10 Mickey Mantle sale that Darren Rovell reported as agreed in principle. Ken Goldin publicly stated this was "false news" and that no such deal has been finalized, though the host speculates a deal may still happen around 2027.
The most significant news involves PSA unexpectedly reopening their value tier grading service at $39.99, a 33% drop from their previous $60 standard tier. The host expresses shock at this aggressive pricing, noting it's only a 21% increase from the $33 tier they offered six months ago before shutting down. He predicts PSA will likely close submissions again before year-end due to overwhelming orders at this price point.
Regarding the PSA FedEx heist, specific stolen cards are being identified, including a Shohei Ohtani super factor card, a Connor Griffin rookie autograph, and historically significant cards like a 1935 Bronko Nagurski rookie and 1933 Goudey Babe Ruth. The host discusses reported values and notes that vigilante identification of supposedly stolen cards on eBay initially led to false accusations against an innocent seller who was simply liquidating his own PSA-graded cards from the heist.
A significant crime wave is also documented, with criminals targeting New Jersey trading card shops using a sophisticated fraud scheme: attempting contactless payments, requesting manual credit card entry when that fails, then disappearing with merchandise before fraudulent transactions are discovered weeks later. The FBI is warning retailers about this coordinated pattern.
In major sales, a 1962 nearly-complete Topps football set with a 9.337 grade point average sold for $1.5 million, a Kobe Bryant high school jersey from 1994-95 sold for $2.2 million, a 1952 Jackie Robinson PSA 5 set an all-time record at $70,360, and a Bo Jackson PSA 10/10 Topps Tiffany rookie was listed at approximately $2,000. A Cooper Flag logo man one-of-one sold for $2.16 million despite being player-worn rather than game-worn.
The host extensively covers Topps quality control failures, including: a Chris Sale 2018 World Series card claiming he struck out the side in the 10th inning when it was actually the 9th, a Dustin Pedroia card depicting him with the 2013 trophy but labeled as the 2007 World Series win, and duplicate "first card one of one" Klay Thompson cards in 2025 Topps. He also discusses a potentially fraudulent uncut sheet of Topps All Aces cards where every card is marked one of one, suspected to be an alignment test sheet that may have been backdoored.
Interesting non-sports collectibles are also featured, including a complete 1989 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles PSA 10 set for $22,000, Rocky IV boxing shoes signed by Stallone, Weathers, and Lundgren for $81,000, and early 1990s Prism cards of Super Mario and Street Fighter II. The host also covers a unique Topps World Series card featuring a champagne cork from the Brewers celebration, which Topps initially claimed was a first but which sparked debate about previous cork memorabilia in trading cards.
Key Insights
- PSA's decision to drop pricing 33% from $60 to $39.99 for value tier grading is strategically risky given they still have 7 million cards in backlog, and the host predicts they will close submissions again before year-end due to overwhelming orders at this aggressive price point
- An innocent eBay seller was wrongly accused of trafficking in stolen PSA heist cards when he was actually a victim whose auto-listed cards from his own PSA order were part of the FedEx theft, demonstrating the dangers of rushing to publish accusations without verification
- Sophisticated criminal rings are targeting New Jersey card shops using a coordinated fraud scheme where they attempt contactless payments, request manual credit card entry when that fails, then flee with merchandise before retailers discover fraudulent transactions weeks later
- Topps has significant quality control failures in recent releases, including incorrectly describing Chris Sale striking out the side in the 10th inning instead of the 9th, and using wrong-year World Series trophy photos in player moment cards
- Low-grade cards with exceptional eye appeal can represent substantially better value than high-grade lower eye appeal cards, as evidenced by comparison sales where a PSA 2 with Hall of Fame eye appeal rated favorably against a PSA 9 with below-average eye appeal
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] Good morning and happy Sunday, everybody. It's the day after Halloween. I hope you all had a very safe Halloween and fun. My family sits out in the driveway. We go We're in a big neighborhood, and we sit out in the driveway and hand out candy for a couple hours, probably. I'm recording this on Saturday morning, well, right at noon on Saturday. We'll probably give out candy to 400 kids tonight. And there will be more. We just don't have enough candy to give it to the 5 or 600 that come by. [0:32] Uh if you're new here, this is my weekly, every Sunday morning, Clearing the Bases episode, where I cover all the news, all…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Junk Wax Hero
I'd never heard of these cards before!
Mike opens mail from his PO box featuring video game and sports cards, with particular excitement about a 1993 Ben Presto Super Mario Kart card. He discusses his collection of Nintendo-related cards and games, displays various graded cards in penny sleeves, and thanks viewers for their generous contributions while seeking identification of mystery cards.
PSA / FedEx heist impact has GROWN, but PSA is being quiet about it!
Mike discusses how PSA's handling of the October 13th FedEx heist has expanded beyond initial reports, with PSA quietly discovering additional stolen items weeks later without proactive notification to affected sellers. PSA continues to lack transparency about the full scope of the theft and has not updated their public list despite identifying a second wave of affected shipments.
Topps Messed Up ANOTHER Chase Card! | Dad Left Child Alone For Cards?? | & More Sports Card News!
A weekly sports card industry news episode covering Topps' major error with missing chase cards in their Cosmic Chrome baseball release, a disturbing incident of a father leaving his young daughter unattended at a Pokemon card event, and various other industry news including grading statistics, auction records, and authentication issues.
Huge Boston card show PACKED! But were collectors buying?
Mike attends the Greater Boston Sports Collectors Convention and finds it packed with foot traffic but observes that collectors are spending less money than before. He discusses market trends with dealers, explores the show's inventory of vintage and modern cards, and reflects on broader market dynamics affected by recent pullbacks and seasonal patterns.
FOUND: man discovers family's two very rare tickets to Jackie Robinson's debut game!!
A man discovered two adjacent tickets to Jackie Robinson's historic debut game on April 15, 1947, while going through his father's and grandfather's belongings in October. With only about a dozen such tickets known to exist, these tickets are extraordinarily rare and valuable, with comparable tickets selling between $300,000 and $480,000 depending on condition.