Probstein used Ai images for an eBay sports card listing??
Mike investigates Probstein's use of AI-generated images in a 1993 Don Russ Elite Series baseball card eBay listing, highlighting numerous AI artifacts and defects in the card depictions. The lot sold for $43.78 despite potentially containing high-value cards, violating eBay's policies requiring truthful and accurate images that depict the exact physical item.
Summary
Mike discusses a discovery by Ryel's Mint Collectibles that Probstein, a major sports card auction company, used AI-generated images to list a lot of 1993 Don Russ Elite Series baseball cards on eBay. The AI images contain numerous hilarious and obvious defects: Don Mattingly has a shrunken head with eyeballs appearing on his cheeks, Ryan Sandberg has no mouth, Frank Thomas (listed as Frank Tomar) appears cross-eyed and confused, and several cards show mismatched names and images (Barry Larkin's face with Andre Dawson's name, Eddie Murray's image with Daryl Strawberry's name, and Barry Bonds in a Twins uniform labeled as Edert Cater). The lot ultimately sold for $43.78, raising questions about what the buyer actually received and whether individual cards like a potentially included Barry Bonds card (which recently sold for $61 alone) were significantly undervalued. Mike notes that eBay's policies explicitly require images to be truthful, accurate, and depict the exact physical item, making this listing a clear violation subject to 'item not as described' returns. While acknowledging this could be a one-off human error or misuse of eBay's AI background enhancement tool, Mike criticizes Probstein's failure to mention or address the AI images throughout the week-long listing process. He contextualizes this incident within Probstein's troubled history, including past allegations of shill bidding, their failed Snipe platform that collapsed within a week last November amid similar allegations, and potential data breach issues. Mike expresses skepticism about whether eBay should have welcomed Probstein back to the platform. He concludes by arguing that sellers should not use AI to clean up card images and invites viewer opinions on both Probstein and the broader question of AI image enhancement in collectibles sales.
Key Insights
- The AI-generated lot of 17 cards sold for $43.78 total, but if a Barry Bonds card was included (which recently sold for $61 alone), the entire lot was significantly undervalued, suggesting potential financial harm to consigners or buyers
- Probstein allowed the listing with AI images to go through the entire sales process for a week without mentioning, acknowledging, or addressing the problematic images anywhere in the listing description
- eBay has built-in AI background enhancement tools for sellers to clean up card photos, and the AI image failure could have resulted from misuse of this legitimate feature going 'wonky' on the entire image
- Probstein's use of AI images in this listing constitutes potential malpractice by an effectively auction company, particularly if they were consigning cards from third parties who expected proper photography and higher returns
- Probstein's history includes past allegations of shill bidding, a failed Snipe platform that collapsed in less than a week in November with more shill bidding allegations, and potential data breach issues that may not have been handled well
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] Did probes team break eBay's rules by using AI images to sell sports cards? [music] Hey, it's Mike. Thanks for tuning back in. So, Ryel's Mint Collectibles tagged me in a tweet a couple days ago or yesterday, whatever it was, that Probstein was selling 1993 Don Russ uh Elite Series baseball cards using an AI image or multiple AI images. And it makes me wonder why. Why would they do [0:31] this? And we'll talk about it. First, let's go through some of these images because they are hilarious as a lot of AI images are. So, first of all, you have Don Mattingly, I guess, and poor guy. Either his head was squished or his eyeballs have…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Junk Wax Hero
I'd never heard of these cards before!
Mike opens mail from his PO box featuring video game and sports cards, with particular excitement about a 1993 Ben Presto Super Mario Kart card. He discusses his collection of Nintendo-related cards and games, displays various graded cards in penny sleeves, and thanks viewers for their generous contributions while seeking identification of mystery cards.
PSA / FedEx heist impact has GROWN, but PSA is being quiet about it!
Mike discusses how PSA's handling of the October 13th FedEx heist has expanded beyond initial reports, with PSA quietly discovering additional stolen items weeks later without proactive notification to affected sellers. PSA continues to lack transparency about the full scope of the theft and has not updated their public list despite identifying a second wave of affected shipments.
Topps Messed Up ANOTHER Chase Card! | Dad Left Child Alone For Cards?? | & More Sports Card News!
A weekly sports card industry news episode covering Topps' major error with missing chase cards in their Cosmic Chrome baseball release, a disturbing incident of a father leaving his young daughter unattended at a Pokemon card event, and various other industry news including grading statistics, auction records, and authentication issues.
Huge Boston card show PACKED! But were collectors buying?
Mike attends the Greater Boston Sports Collectors Convention and finds it packed with foot traffic but observes that collectors are spending less money than before. He discusses market trends with dealers, explores the show's inventory of vintage and modern cards, and reflects on broader market dynamics affected by recent pullbacks and seasonal patterns.
FOUND: man discovers family's two very rare tickets to Jackie Robinson's debut game!!
A man discovered two adjacent tickets to Jackie Robinson's historic debut game on April 15, 1947, while going through his father's and grandfather's belongings in October. With only about a dozen such tickets known to exist, these tickets are extraordinarily rare and valuable, with comparable tickets selling between $300,000 and $480,000 depending on condition.