I sold all my Shohei Ohtani rookie cards! How'd I do?
Mike discusses his decision to sell all his Shohei Ohtani rookie cards after purchasing them in 2023 when they were affordable. He sold four cards through Heritage Auctions for significant profits, reinvesting the proceeds into other vintage cards he's more passionate about.
Summary
Mike explains that in 2023, he began collecting Shohei Ohtani rookie cards in PSA 10 condition when they were very affordable, acquiring around 310-410 copies. As the cards appreciated dramatically in value, he reconsidered whether he wanted to hold them long-term, especially after a conversation with Greg where he realized he wouldn't pay current market prices for cards he originally purchased for $100. He sold four specific Ohtani cards: a 2018 Topps Heritage PSA 10 purchased for $100 and sold for $542 (442% ROI); a 2018 Bowman PSA 9 obtained for $1 and sold for $82 (310% ROI); a 2018 Chrome Update PSA 10 bought for $120 and sold for $781 (551% ROI); and the most iconic 2018 Chrome pitching card in PSA 10 purchased for $180 at the Shrine show in April 2024 and sold for $1,120 (522% ROI). He also mentioned a 2018 Topps Silver Pack 1983 Promo card he bought raw for $90 and sold for $471 after grading as a PSA 10 in July 2025. All sales were conducted through Heritage Auctions (CIA). Mike used the substantial profits to purchase vintage cards he values more highly, including a Rickey Henderson rookie autograph, Billy Ripken FF error autograph, and Wilt Chamberlain card. He acknowledges that some cards continued appreciating significantly after he sold them but maintains he made the right decision based on his comfort level with valuations at the time of sale. He plans to potentially rebuy the pitching card in a PSA 9 grade at a lower price point in the future, particularly during slower market periods like December-January.
Key Insights
- Mike bought Ohtani rookie cards in PSA 10 condition for $100 each in 2023 when they were very affordable, but declined to sell them immediately even when they appreciated to $600-$800, waiting until he felt comfortable with market valuations
- Greg's question of whether Mike would repurchase a card at its current market price rather than what he paid became the primary decision-making framework for determining when to sell his Ohtani cards
- The 2018 Topps Silver Pack 1983 Promo card with a population of only 900 PSA 10s appreciated to $1,400 after Mike sold it for $471 in July 2025, representing the card that 'got away' with the most significant missed upside
- Mike prioritizes owning cards he genuinely enjoys long-term over maximizing portfolio value, reinvesting Ohtani profits into vintage autographed cards like Rickey Henderson and Billy Ripken despite knowing he may have left potential gains on the table
- Mike plans to rebuy the iconic 2018 Chrome pitching Ohtani card in PSA 9 condition at significantly lower cost than PSA 10s during seasonally weak periods like December-January rather than hold the higher grade
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] I sold all of my Show Otani rookie cards. Let's talk about how I did. Hey, it's Mike. Thanks for tuning back in. So, uh, I went through CIA for most of these sales, and CIA obviously is the the auction house of choice for me. I I think they're amazing. We're going to [clears throat] talk through the four sales of Showhe cards, um, and why I did it. So, at some point back in 2023, I [0:31] decided I wanted to collect Show Otani rookie cards. And I wanted I wanted them in PSA 10s. They were really affordable back then. And so, I started buying them. And I got to 410, I think, or 310, something…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Junk Wax Hero
PSA Is FLYING! | But Fake PSA Slabs Are Taking Over! | & More Sports Cards News!
A weekly sports card news roundup covering PSA's improving turnaround times and new crossover pricing, the proliferation of counterfeit PSA slabs and labels being sold online, and various card market anomalies including misprints, valuation issues, and collector mishaps.
I'd never heard of these cards before!
Mike opens mail from his PO box featuring video game and sports cards, with particular excitement about a 1993 Ben Presto Super Mario Kart card. He discusses his collection of Nintendo-related cards and games, displays various graded cards in penny sleeves, and thanks viewers for their generous contributions while seeking identification of mystery cards.
PSA / FedEx heist impact has GROWN, but PSA is being quiet about it!
Mike discusses how PSA's handling of the October 13th FedEx heist has expanded beyond initial reports, with PSA quietly discovering additional stolen items weeks later without proactive notification to affected sellers. PSA continues to lack transparency about the full scope of the theft and has not updated their public list despite identifying a second wave of affected shipments.
Topps Messed Up ANOTHER Chase Card! | Dad Left Child Alone For Cards?? | & More Sports Card News!
A weekly sports card industry news episode covering Topps' major error with missing chase cards in their Cosmic Chrome baseball release, a disturbing incident of a father leaving his young daughter unattended at a Pokemon card event, and various other industry news including grading statistics, auction records, and authentication issues.
Huge Boston card show PACKED! But were collectors buying?
Mike attends the Greater Boston Sports Collectors Convention and finds it packed with foot traffic but observes that collectors are spending less money than before. He discusses market trends with dealers, explores the show's inventory of vintage and modern cards, and reflects on broader market dynamics affected by recent pullbacks and seasonal patterns.