StoryOpinion

Did eBay & PSA fix their loose card problem?? (And I got my Puckett rookie auto!!)

Junk Wax Hero

Mike opens mail from an eBay Authenticity Guarantee card and discusses whether PSA has fixed their long-running packaging issue with loose cards. He also showcases his recent acquisitions including a Kirby Puckett autographed rookie card and other items from his collection.

Summary

Mike begins by addressing a persistent problem with eBay Authenticity Guarantee cards (handled by PSA) where raw cards in semi-rigid holders don't fit properly during shipping and stick out of packaging. He notes this issue has been ongoing for at least a couple of years despite PSA's repeated promises to fix it. Mike then opens his mail delivery, which includes a Kirby Puckett 1985 Topps autographed card graded PSA 67. He explains that after leaving a national card show with $800 to spend, he specifically searched for either a Puckett or Gwynn autographed rookie card. Though the highly valuable 1984 Fleer Update Puckett rookie was out of reach at $5,000-$10,000, he found this 1985 version and won it for $689 after bidding $812. A viewer named Patrick helped him find the auction through AuctionWire, a search tool. Mike expresses satisfaction with the card's quality and centering, and notes it's now only missing a Gwynn to complete his 1980s Hall of Fame autograph rookie card collection. Regarding the packaging improvement: Mike received an older-style eBay packaging, but two other collectors (Juo and "the hook") received new improved PSA boxes with raw cards. These new boxes appear similar to standard PSA packaging and represent a significant improvement. Mike notes this appears to be a phased rollout and expresses hope it extends to all shipments soon. He also receives and showcases several other cards including a 2001 Brian Dobach gold refractor, Nomar cards from longtime viewer Brock, and a Theo Epstein 2005 Topps autographed card. Mike mentions he's collecting all 2004 Red Sox rookie autographed cards and estimates he's at 60-80% completion, though most aren't yet professionally authenticated.

Key Insights

  • PSA has acknowledged the eBay Authenticity Guarantee card packaging problem multiple times and promised fixes, but the issue persisted for at least a couple of years without resolution
  • PSA appears to be rolling out new improved box designs for shipping cards, with some collectors receiving the new packaging while others still receive older standard eBay packaging
  • Mike budgeted $800 for a Puckett or Gwynn autographed rookie after the national card show and won the Puckett 1985 Topps for $689, well under budget
  • Mike estimates he has completed 60-80% of his 2004 Red Sox rookie autographed card collection goal, with most cards not yet professionally authenticated
  • A viewer named Patrick notified Mike about the Puckett auction through Instagram after it didn't appear in Mike's AuctionWire searches due to a search configuration issue

Topics

eBay Authenticity Guarantee packaging issuesPSA shipping and packaging improvementsKirby Puckett autographed card acquisitionCollecting 1980s Hall of Fame autograph rookiesMail day unboxing and collection updates2004 Red Sox rookie autographed cards collection

Transcript

[0:00] Have eBay and PSA fixed their long longunning issue of eBay authenticity guarantee cards sticking out of the holders when they get mailed to customers? Let's take a look. Hey, it's Mike. Thanks for check thanks for taking a look. Thanks for turning [snorts] [laughter] Thanks for tuning back in. I've only been saying it in over a thousand videos over the years. Uh yesterday I received notice that [0:31] this this item here from eBay authenticity guarantee program hit my PO box. And I also received a message from add Sports Cards. This Juo uh Juo runs the account, great member of the community. and he showed me that he received something from eBay authenticity guarantee that I'm…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Junk Wax Hero

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.