Did a PSA 10 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle ALREADY sell for $50 million?!?
A sports card collector discusses rumors that a PSA 10 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle card sold for $50 million, citing insider sources and social media confirmation from plugged-in hobby figures. The speaker explores the implications for the collectibles market and speculates on potential market impacts if the sale is verified.
Summary
The speaker opens by discussing emergency 'rumblings' from industry insiders heard approximately one month prior about a 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle PSA 10 selling for $50 million. While hesitant to report unconfirmed rumors, the speaker notes that Ryan Stadler, a well-connected hobby figure, tweeted about this possible rumor, specifically stating it involved one of the PSA 10 Mantles (not the famous Ken Kendrick or Marshall Fogle copies). Stadler tagged Darren Rell (founder of Collect, with 25 years of collectibles writing experience) and Will Stern (former journalist now leading Collect's strategy), asking if there was truth to the claim.
The speaker mentions Patrick Bet David, a businessman and podcaster known for high-value sports card collecting, who previously made a $19 million offer for a 1952 Topps Mantle. Crucially, Darren Rell responded to Stadler's inquiry with "It was agreed to in principle," which the speaker considers more concrete than mere rumors—a definitive statement about a deal in principle rather than speculation.
The speaker then explores the two most famous PSA 10 copies: Ken Kendrick's (criticized for being slightly off-center but still grading a 10) and Marshall Fogle's (in an older slab, potentially relabbed). A third PSA 10 copy exists with unknown ownership, previously sold 25 years ago via Superior Sports Auctions for $275,000. The speaker notes this $275,000 investment would have grown to $2.7 million in an index fund, but the Mantle significantly outperformed that return.
Regarding market implications, the speaker uses Card Ladder as a reference tool and predicts that if verified, a $50 million sale would boost all 1952 Topps Mantle values significantly. The speaker also anticipates a 'trickle-down' effect where collectors unable to afford a top-tier PSA 10 would pursue lower-grade Mantles or adjacent cards like 1951 Bowman or 1953 Topps Mantles. The speaker concludes by speculating on potential buyers and reiterating that the story requires close follow-up.
Key Insights
- Darren Rell's statement that the $50 million deal was 'agreed to in principle' represents more concrete confirmation than previous rumors about the sale, suggesting actual negotiation progress rather than speculation
- A $275,000 investment in the third PSA 10 Mantle 25 years ago would have grown to $2.7 million if placed in an index fund, but the actual card significantly outperformed stock market returns
- Ken Kendrick's PSA 10 Mantle faces criticism for being slightly off-center or diamond-cut, yet still grades a 10, contradicting collector expectations that a 10 should be perfect
- A verified $50 million sale would create a 'trickle-down' effect where collectors unable to afford top-tier PSA 10 Mantles would pursue lower-grade examples or adjacent vintage Mantle cards like 1951 Bowman or 1953 Topps
- Only two of the three known PSA 10 1952 Topps Mantles have publicly identified owners (Kendrick and Fogle), with the third copy's owner remaining unknown despite being sold 25 years ago through Superior Sports Auctions
Topics
Transcript
[0:01] Good evening and happy Monday. This is a very weird thing. It's an emergency. Clearing the bases on a Monday evening. It's not really an emergency. This is more of a well, this is really interesting and could be something, but I don't have any breaking news. It's more of uh some really interesting nuggets along with some speculation and uh other things. But about a month or so ago, I started hearing rumblings from industry insiders that they had heard [0:31] that a Mickey Mantel 1952 Tops PSA 10 had sold for $50 million. And that's a rumor that's even though they are insiders, insiders saying that they have heard is probably them just being cautious and like…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Junk Wax Hero
PSA Is FLYING! | But Fake PSA Slabs Are Taking Over! | & More Sports Cards News!
A weekly sports card news roundup covering PSA's improving turnaround times and new crossover pricing, the proliferation of counterfeit PSA slabs and labels being sold online, and various card market anomalies including misprints, valuation issues, and collector mishaps.
I'd never heard of these cards before!
Mike opens mail from his PO box featuring video game and sports cards, with particular excitement about a 1993 Ben Presto Super Mario Kart card. He discusses his collection of Nintendo-related cards and games, displays various graded cards in penny sleeves, and thanks viewers for their generous contributions while seeking identification of mystery cards.
PSA / FedEx heist impact has GROWN, but PSA is being quiet about it!
Mike discusses how PSA's handling of the October 13th FedEx heist has expanded beyond initial reports, with PSA quietly discovering additional stolen items weeks later without proactive notification to affected sellers. PSA continues to lack transparency about the full scope of the theft and has not updated their public list despite identifying a second wave of affected shipments.
Topps Messed Up ANOTHER Chase Card! | Dad Left Child Alone For Cards?? | & More Sports Card News!
A weekly sports card industry news episode covering Topps' major error with missing chase cards in their Cosmic Chrome baseball release, a disturbing incident of a father leaving his young daughter unattended at a Pokemon card event, and various other industry news including grading statistics, auction records, and authentication issues.
Huge Boston card show PACKED! But were collectors buying?
Mike attends the Greater Boston Sports Collectors Convention and finds it packed with foot traffic but observes that collectors are spending less money than before. He discusses market trends with dealers, explores the show's inventory of vintage and modern cards, and reflects on broader market dynamics affected by recent pullbacks and seasonal patterns.