StoryOpinion

8 great autos (and 1 fake!) and my first pedigree! CGC / JSA return!

Junk Wax Hero8m 18s

The speaker shares their CGC/JSA autograph grading returns from 10 cards submitted in May, showcasing a mix of Hall of Fame rookie autographs and discussing CGC's customer service experience. One card failed authentication, revealing a Shaquille O'Neal ghost-signer issue discovered after submission.

Summary

The speaker received back 9-10 autographed cards from CGC/JSA that were submitted approximately 3.5 months prior (around 70 business days), which they note is significantly faster than competitors. They praise CGC's customer service, noting the company immediately credited them when they were incorrectly charged for eight pedigrees instead of the one they ordered. The speaker is adding these authenticated cards to their personal collection rather than selling them.

The collection includes notable cards: a Luis Tiant rookie with a 3.5 card/10 auto grade; a Sandy Koufax 1966 Topps signed at an event (card graded 1, auto authenticated) with pedigree attribution to 'Southern Collector 14'; a 1953 Bowman Johnny Pesky (grade 2); a 1992 SI for Kids Mia Hamm rookie (8 card/10 auto); a Bert Blyleven rookie TTM autograph (3.5 card/10 auto); a Jim Palmer 1960s card (5 card, auto authenticated only due to streakiness); a Chipper Jones (9 card/10 auto); and a Todd Helton 1993 Topps Traded (8.5 card/10 auto).

The speaker discusses their ongoing personal collection projects building runs of Hall of Fame rookie autographs from different decades (1960s, 1970s, 1990s). Notably, one Shaquille O'Neal card failed authentication, marked as 'secretarial' with questionable authenticity. The speaker explains they discovered after submission that Shaq had a ghost signer handling autographs, so this result was expected. The speaker also highlights that CGC's grading appears appropriately rigorous despite some criticism of being too lenient, and mentions they still have additional TTM cards pending submission.

About this episode

I sent 9 great autographed cards off to CGC / JSA. One of them came back as fake! I also got one with a pedigree (@SouthernCollector14) I am a huge fan of Card Ladder, and you can use my code HERO for a free month at signup! https://app.cardladder.com/signup?via=hero For my FREE weekly sports card recap newsletter: https://www.junkwaxhero.com/subscribe If you want to support my channel, you can sign up for a $2/month membership: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRfWi9L4EOSYtXoW_nc-X-g/join Follow me on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/junk.wax.hero/ And Twitter: https://twitter.com/JunkWaxHero79 #sportscards​ #tradingcards​ #baseballcards

Key Insights

  • The speaker received a billing error from CGC where they were charged for eight pedigrees when they only ordered one, but the company immediately credited them after being notified, demonstrating responsive customer service compared to competitors
  • The speaker discovered after submitting Shaquille O'Neal autographed cards that Shaq used a ghost signer, resulting in failed authentication marked as 'secretarial' with questionable authenticity, which was not entirely surprising given prior knowledge of the ghost signing arrangement
  • The speaker is building decade-specific Hall of Fame rookie autograph collections (1960s, 1970s, 1990s) and prioritizes authentication over grading on certain cards with questionable autograph quality, such as Jim Palmer where they explicitly did not want the autograph graded due to streakiness

Topics

CGC/JSA autograph grading and authenticationSports card collectingHall of Fame baseball rookie autographsAuthentication failures and ghost signersCustomer service experiencePedigree documentationTTM (Through The Mail) autographsCard grading standards

Transcript

[0:00] I have another CGC JSA autograph return today of 10 I think it's 10 No, it's actually nine cards. Maybe it's 10. I don't remember. Uh and I'm excited to get through them. Um I sent these back in May. So, it took 3 and 1/2 months, I think. So, what's that? 70-ish business days. Much better than if you're going through the other guys. Uh and I I like CGC. I'm not selling. I'm putting them in my [0:31] personal collection and they look better. Um So, let's see how we did. And I will say I got the I got the invoice showing me what they charged me for. I haven't looked at the grades yet, but…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Junk Wax Hero

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.