Portland's Proposed Massive Increase to the CEO Pay-Ratio Surtax—and Oregon's Other Tax Debates
Portland is proposing a massive increase to its CEO pay-ratio surtax, potentially raising it from 10-25% to as high as 500%, which could generate $80 million annually. The proposal faces significant constitutional challenges regarding equal protection, commerce clause issues, and Portland's charter authority to impose taxes without voter approval.
Summary
The podcast discusses Portland's proposed expansion of its CEO pay-ratio surtax, originally enacted in 2016 as a small tax on publicly traded companies based on their SEC-reported CEO-to-average-wage ratios. The current proposal would dramatically increase the surtax from its original nuisance-tax levels to potentially 500%, generating an estimated $80 million annually compared to the original $6.5-7 million. Jeff Newgard explains that the original tax went unchallenged for a decade because the financial impact was minimal and companies faced political backlash for fighting it, but the proposed increase fundamentally changes the litigation calculus. The tax raises multiple constitutional concerns: it applies only to publicly traded companies (equal protection issues), uses a worldwide CEO-to-employee ratio that includes workers and executives outside Portland (commerce clause problems), and would tax companies with no Portland presence or employees. The tax also mismatches with Oregon's federal consolidated group filing requirements, creating additional compliance confusion. Beyond the technical issues, Newgard raises concerns about Portland's charter authority to impose taxes without voter approval, citing the 2017 HomeAway case that established Portland lacks unilateral inherent authority to tax. There's also uncertainty about whether the original business license tax was ever approved by voters. Additional litigation is already pending on Portland's clean energy surcharge and arts tax increase. Newgard notes Portland voters have become tax-fatigued, with Multnomah County showing declining support for non-traditional taxes in recent years, particularly after disappointing outcomes from the Metro personal income tax and Multnomah County income tax. The podcast also covers Eugene's proposed clean energy surcharge on the ballot, which faces similar preemption and constitutional challenges. At the state level, progressive advocates filed a financial assets tax (wealth tax) initiative petition for November 2028, explicitly stating it was designed to apply pressure on lawmakers rather than as a genuine ballot measure. Newgard expresses skepticism about this strategy, noting it conflicts with Metro's need to renew its regional taxes in 2028 and could trigger voter backlash. The discussion concludes with mention of Oregon's Universal Healthcare Governance Board proposing a $69-70 billion state-managed insurance system requiring virtually doubled personal income tax and significant corporate tax increases, which could also appear on a 2028 ballot.
About this episode
<p class="xxmsonormal" style="margin-left: .5in;"><span style="font-family: 'Calibri',sans-serif;"> On the latest episode of the GeTtin' SALTy podcast, host Nikki Dobay welcome backs guest Jeff Newgard of Peak Policy to discuss a proposal to sharply increase Portland's CEO pay-ratio surtax, which was enacted in 2017.<span> </span> While the surtax has always raised legal and constitutional issues, the proposed increase is likely to renew those concerns, resulting in potential litigation and budget implications. </span></p> <p class="xxmsonormal" style="margin-left: .5in;"><span style="font-family: 'Calibri',sans-serif;"> They also examine the proposed a clean-energy surcharge (similar to the Portland CES) in Eugune, Oregon, the state's proposed annual financial-assets tax, and a universal-healthcare plan that could bring significant new taxes. </span></p> <p class="xxmsonormal" style="margin-left: .5in;"><span style="font-family: 'Calibri',sans-serif;"> Throughout, they consider how voter fatigue and questions about local taxing authority may shape what happens next.</span></p> <p class="xxmsonormal" style="margin-left: .5in;"><span style="font-family: 'Calibri',sans-serif;"> <em>Note:<span> </span> As of the time of the recording of the podcast, the election had not yet taken place.<span> </span> As an update, the Eugene clean energy surcharge was passed by voters.</em><span><em> </em></span><br /> <!-- [if !supportLineBreakNewLine]--><br /> <!--[endif]--></span></p>
Key Insights
- The original 2016 Portland CEO pay-ratio surtax remained unchallenged for a decade because the $6.5-7 million annual revenue was immaterial compared to the political cost of litigation, but the proposed 500% surtax increase to $80 million changes this calculus significantly.
- Portland's CEO pay-ratio tax is fundamentally untethered to Portland business activity because it taxes companies based on worldwide employee and CEO ratios reported to the SEC, including employees in Vietnam or other foreign locations entirely unrelated to Portland operations.
- The federal district court's 2017 HomeAway decision established that Portland lacks unilateral authority to impose taxes without voter approval, creating retroactive vulnerability for the 2016 CEO pay-ratio surtax and other recent taxes like the clean energy surcharge.
- Oregon voters, particularly in Multnomah County, have become significantly more resistant to non-traditional taxes like income taxes since 2017, as evidenced by declining support for the Metro regional government's personal income tax and a failed state capital gains tax ballot measure.
- Progressive advocates filed Oregon's 2028 financial assets tax initiative explicitly as political leverage to pressure lawmakers in the 2027 legislative session rather than as a genuine ballot measure, which Newgard argues suggests proponents don't believe the wealth tax is actually viable.
Topics
Transcript
This podcast episode reflects the opinions of the hosts and guests and not of Greenberg-Choreg LLP. This episode is presented for informational purposes only, and it is not intended to be construed or used as general legal advice nor a solicitation of any type. Jeff, you're here because Portland's up to some shenanigans. Hello, and welcome to Gittin' Salty, a state and local tax policy podcast hosted by Greenberg-Choreg. My name is Nikki Dovey, shareholder in the Portland, Oregon and Sacramento, California offices. I am very pleased to have one of our regulars back on the show, Jeff Newgard. Jeff is the founder and CEO and president of Peak Policy here in Oregon. So thank you so much for being…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from GeTtin' SALTy Podcast
After the Election: State Tax Policy and the Road to 2027
Following the recent election, Democrats gained significant control at the state level, with 30 Democratic governors, six new trifectas, and 300+ new fiscal committee members and chairs. The hosts discuss implications for 2027 state tax policy, emphasizing the critical need for business community education of incoming legislators and highlighting key states to watch including Maryland, Pennsylvania, Minnesota, and Washington.
Is Public Law 86-272 Still Relevant? Joyce, Finnigan, and New State Tax Challenges
Hosts Nikki Dobay and John Ormondi discuss the continued relevance of Public Law 86-272, focusing on recent court cases including the Massachusetts Appellate Tax Board decision striking down Finnegan apportionment rules, and examining how state tax policies may violate federal protections for interstate commerce.
EPR Litigation Update: Oregon Court Upholds Packaging Law as Challenges Continue
Oregon's federal court upheld the state's Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) packaging law against constitutional challenges, rejecting arguments about interstate commerce burdens, due process violations, and improper delegation to the Circular Action Alliance. The decision marks the first litigation outcome on packaging EPR laws, with appeals pending at the Ninth Circuit and similar cases proceeding in Colorado and California.