After the Election: State Tax Policy and the Road to 2027
Following the recent election, Democrats gained significant control at the state level, with 30 Democratic governors, six new trifectas, and 300+ new fiscal committee members and chairs. The hosts discuss implications for 2027 state tax policy, emphasizing the critical need for business community education of incoming legislators and highlighting key states to watch including Maryland, Pennsylvania, Minnesota, and Washington.
Summary
The podcast episode explores the substantial political shifts resulting from the recent election and their implications for state tax policy heading into 2027. Morgan Scarborough reports that Democrats made unexpected gains across all levels of government: they flipped six gubernatorial seats, now controlling 30 governorships versus 20 Republican-held positions, meaning 75% of Americans live under Democratic gubernatorial control. Additionally, Democrats now control trifectas (governor and both legislative chambers) in six states: Arizona, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. Nine states experienced changes in legislative control, and Republicans lost supermajorities in several states while Democrats gained supermajorities in others.
The hosts discuss how trifectas, while theoretically enabling faster action, don't necessarily guarantee smooth governance due to intra-party divisions between progressive and moderate factions. Examples like Virginia and New York demonstrate that having unified control still leads to significant budget negotiations and delays. On ballot initiatives, the results were mixed. Californians rejected Proposition 40 (the billionaire's tax) but voted to maintain the state's high income tax rates on millionaires, suggesting voters prefer known tax structures over novel ones. Washington's millionaire tax and Colorado's graduated income tax amendment passed, while Florida's property tax exemption succeeded despite similar measures failing in Midwestern states.
The hosts emphasize that approximately 700-1,000 new state legislators will take office, with roughly 300 fiscal committee members and chairs being new to their positions or departing entirely. This represents a critical knowledge gap, particularly given that state legislators are typically part-time, lack extensive staff resources, and must rely on external expertise. Morgan highlights specific examples of significant departures: Minnesota's Senate tax chair Ann Rest retiring, Oklahoma losing 13 fiscal committee members, South Dakota losing its House tax chair and vice chair plus eight others, and Utah losing leaders in both chambers.
The hosts stress the importance of business community education and engagement before legislative sessions begin in January. They recommend that companies work closely with government relations teams to identify new fiscal committee leadership, translate technical tax concepts into simple language, and establish trusted relationships early. Morgan warns against overwhelming legislators with excessive code citations and jargon, emphasizing the need for clear communication about how proposals impact constituents and state revenue.
Morgan's national prediction for 2027 is that data center tax exemptions will be the most heavily discussed tax topic, with varying state definitions creating risks for non-data-center businesses. Key states to watch include Maryland (facing severe fiscal challenges with newly elected progressive legislators), Pennsylvania and New York (with Democratic trifectas pursuing long-delayed proposals like combined reporting), Minnesota (losing a moderating influence with Ann Rest's retirement), and Washington (planning a comprehensive tax system overhaul including potential replacement of the B&O tax with a margins tax). In Washington specifically, Representative April Burke is exploring a Texas-style margins tax proposal with more deliberate implementation than prior reform attempts, moving away from the previously unpopular five-year B&O phase-out approach.
About this episode
<p class="MsoNormal"><span style="font-size: 11.0pt; font-family: 'Calibri',sans-serif;">In this episode of the GT's GeTtin' SALTy podcast, Nikki Dobay welcomes Morgan Scarboro of MultiState Associates to discuss how the election reshaped state political landscape—and what that could mean for tax policy. They review key ballot measures, the influx of new legislators and fiscal committee members, and why early, clear communication with policymakers will matter. Morgan also shares her 2027 outlook, including potential data center tax legislation and states to watch, such as Maryland, Pennsylvania, Minnesota, and Washington. In Washington, they discuss the proposed overhaul of the state's tax system and the importance of following how the proposal develops.</span></p>
Key Insights
- Democrats now control trifectas in six states and 30 governorships total, with 75% of Americans living under Democratic gubernatorial control, representing an unexpected reversal of Republican dominance that existed after 2010.
- Having unified partisan control (trifecta) does not automatically eliminate legislative friction; intra-party divisions between progressive and moderate factions create different kinds of fights and can still lead to budget delays and compromise complications.
- Approximately 300 fiscal committee members and chairs across the country are new or departing, combined with 700-1,000 new state legislators overall, creating a significant expertise vacuum that leaves lawmakers dependent on external business and advocacy community guidance.
- Voters rejected California's novel billionaire's wealth tax while voting to maintain existing high income tax rates, suggesting voter preference for tested, familiar tax mechanisms over experimental approaches despite supporting higher taxation of wealthy individuals.
- Washington state is pursuing a comprehensive tax system overhaul including potential replacement of the B&O tax with a margins-based tax, with Representative April Burke deliberately slowing the implementation timeline after a previously unpopular five-year phase-out proposal generated universal business community opposition.
Topics
Transcript
This podcast episode reflects the opinions of the hosts and guests and not of Greenberg-Schorig LLP. This episode is presented for informational purposes only, and it is not intended to be construed or used as general legal advice nor a solicitation of any type. I am very pleased to welcome back Morgan Scarborough, Vice President and Chief Operating Officer and Executive of Multi-State Associate. Morgan, thank you so much for being here. Hi, Nikki. Thank you for giving me a better and better title every time I join. I do have to tell your listeners that that is not correct, but that's fine. I appreciate the honor which with you bestowed me. I know. I just, in my mind, you…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from GeTtin' SALTy Podcast
Portland's Proposed Massive Increase to the CEO Pay-Ratio Surtax—and Oregon's Other Tax Debates
Portland is proposing a massive increase to its CEO pay-ratio surtax, potentially raising it from 10-25% to as high as 500%, which could generate $80 million annually. The proposal faces significant constitutional challenges regarding equal protection, commerce clause issues, and Portland's charter authority to impose taxes without voter approval.
Is Public Law 86-272 Still Relevant? Joyce, Finnigan, and New State Tax Challenges
Hosts Nikki Dobay and John Ormondi discuss the continued relevance of Public Law 86-272, focusing on recent court cases including the Massachusetts Appellate Tax Board decision striking down Finnegan apportionment rules, and examining how state tax policies may violate federal protections for interstate commerce.
EPR Litigation Update: Oregon Court Upholds Packaging Law as Challenges Continue
Oregon's federal court upheld the state's Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) packaging law against constitutional challenges, rejecting arguments about interstate commerce burdens, due process violations, and improper delegation to the Circular Action Alliance. The decision marks the first litigation outcome on packaging EPR laws, with appeals pending at the Ninth Circuit and similar cases proceeding in Colorado and California.