Is Public Law 86-272 Still Relevant? Joyce, Finnigan, and New State Tax Challenges
Hosts Nikki Dobay and John Ormondi discuss the continued relevance of Public Law 86-272, focusing on recent court cases including the Massachusetts Appellate Tax Board decision striking down Finnegan apportionment rules, and examining how state tax policies may violate federal protections for interstate commerce.
Summary
In this episode of Gettin' Salty, a state and local tax policy podcast, hosts Nikki Dobay and John Ormondi examine Public Law 86-272 and its modern applicability despite being enacted in 1959. Ormondi explains how he entered state and local tax practice through his interest in constitutional law and the commerce clause, appreciating both the mathematical and constitutional components of the field.
The hosts discuss Finnegan and Joyce rules, which are state apportionment methodologies originating from California State Board of Equalization cases. Finnegan rules allow states to tax combined group members when any member exceeds 86-272 protection by reassigning sales to the numerator of taxable entities. Joyce rules operate differently by excluding protected entity sales from the numerator while including the entity's income in the combined base and denominator. These rules are used in approximately 20 states despite being commonly misunderstood, as exemplified by failed legislative attempts in Oregon.
A Massachusetts Appellate Tax Board decision found that the state's Finnegan rule violated the supremacy clause of 86-272. The tribunal focused on two key issues: whether states can tax other combined group members related to protected entity activities, and whether 86-272 applies to individual persons or entire combined groups. The court held that income earned by protected persons is exempt from tax regardless of which entity the tax is imposed on, emphasizing the statute's use of the word "income" rather than "person." The court distinguished previous cases (Central Newspapers, Disney New York, Citicorp, and Deluxe) by arguing those focused on apportionment rather than 86-272 preemption.
Ormondi traces California's history with these rules, noting that Joyce (1966) initially found Finnegan-style taxation violated 86-272, but Finnegan (1990) involved a throwback rule context that may not directly implicate preemption. The 1992 Huffy decision overruled Finnegan and NutraSuite, but the 1999 California legislature codified the Finnegan approach for tangible personal property through Revenue Tax Code Section 25135. Ormondi argues this statute is now at risk of preemption under the supremacy clause based on the Massachusetts reasoning.
The hosts discuss additional cases involving 86-272. The American Catalog Mailing Association v. New York Department of Taxation upheld a regulation permitting consideration of internet activities and digital customer support when evaluating 86-272 protection, though the court left room for as-applied challenges. A related California case involving the same parties struck down the Franchise Tax Board's guidance as an underground regulation under state law, preventing the court from reaching the merits. The FTB subsequently removed significant guidance, and the hosts speculate the agency did not appeal to avoid a broader ruling on underground regulations affecting its legal rulings more generally.
The State Tax Assessor v. Fifth Generation case involved an out-of-state liquor supplier arguing that state regulatory requirements for bailment exceeded 86-272 protections. The Maine court held that states can impose regulatory regimes with valid police purposes even if they cause businesses to exceed 86-272, citing Cubaland and Wrigley's Supreme Court precedent. However, states cannot deliberately design regulations specifically to defeat 86-272 protections.
The ASAP Cruises case, denied review by the Supreme Court, raised the interesting argument that 86-272's protective scope might extend beyond tangible personal property to services. The hosts note that when 86-272 was enacted in 1959, services were sourced based on cost of performance rather than market-based sourcing, so Congress likely did not need to explicitly exclude services. This historical context suggests the statute's protections may be broader than commonly assumed.
Ormondi and Dobay discuss how states are redefining tangible personal property (with California treating digital goods as tangible personal property beginning January 1, 2027), which could affect 86-272 protections. The hosts also note the MTC's broad functional website standards for determining nexus and suggest taxpayers should creatively respond to such aggressive positions. The episode concludes with both hosts sharing their preferences for California wines made in French Bordeaux style, citing superior value compared to French wines and referencing the historical 1979 Judgment of Paris wine competition.
About this episode
<p class="MsoNormal"><span style="font-size: 11.0pt; font-family: 'Calibri',sans-serif;"> On this episode of Greenberg Traurig's GeTtin' SALTy podcast, host Nikki Dobay and guest John Ormonde explore recent developments involving Public Law 86-272 and the limits it may place on state income-taxing authority. </span></p> <p class="MsoNormal"><span style="font-size: 11.0pt; font-family: 'Calibri',sans-serif;"> They explain the difference between Joyce and Finnigan apportionment approaches, discuss why the Massachusetts Appellate Tax Board found that the state's Finnigan rule conflicted with 86-272, and consider potential implications for combined groups and other states. </span><span style="font-size: 11.0pt; font-family: 'Calibri',sans-serif;"> </span></p> <p class="MsoNormal"><span style="font-size: 11.0pt; font-family: 'Calibri',sans-serif;"> Their conversation also covers state treatment of internet activities and other services under 86-272, California's underground-regulation ruling, a Maine liquor case, and whether the statute's protections could extend beyond sales of tangible personal property. </span></p> <p class="MsoNormal"><span style="font-size: 11.0pt; font-family: 'Calibri',sans-serif;"> Nikki and John wrap with a discussion of their favorite wine regions.</span></p> <p class="MsoNormal"><span style="font-size: 11.0pt; font-family: 'Calibri',sans-serif;"> Tune in!</span></p> <p class="MsoNormal"><em><span style="font-size: 11.0pt; font-family: 'Calibri',sans-serif;"> We note the Massachusetts Appeal Board decision has been appealed with a direct review to the Massachusetts Supreme Court pending.</span></em></p> <p class="MsoNormal"><em><span style="font-size: 11.0pt; font-family: 'Calibri',sans-serif;"> </span></em></p>
Key Insights
- The Massachusetts Appellate Tax Board held that 86-272 exempts income derived by protected persons regardless of which combined group member the tax is imposed on, basing this interpretation on the statute's use of the word 'income' rather than 'person'
- The Massachusetts court distinguished previous cases by arguing that California's Citicorp and Deluxe decisions focused on apportionment methodology rather than 86-272 preemption analysis, and that Joyce (1966) actually did recognize 86-272 protections while Finnegan (1990) involved a throwback rule context
- California's 1999 legislative codification of the Finnegan approach for tangible personal property sales (Revenue Tax Code Section 25135) is potentially at risk of being preempted under the supremacy clause based on the reasoning in the Massachusetts case
- The FTB likely did not appeal the American Catalog Mailing Association decision striking down its guidance as an underground regulation because a Court of Appeal ruling could establish a broader precedent affecting the deference owed to all FTB legal rulings, not just the challenged guidance
- When 86-272 was enacted in 1959, services were sourced based on cost of performance rather than market-based sourcing, suggesting Congress did not need to explicitly exclude services from the statute's protections, potentially making the statute's scope broader than commonly assumed
- State regulatory regimes with valid police purposes (such as alcohol distribution requirements) do not violate 86-272 even if they cause businesses to exceed the statute's protection thresholds, but states cannot deliberately design regulations specifically targeting 86-272 protections
- Approximately 20 states have adopted Finnegan-style rules, but these rules are commonly misunderstood even among legislators and tax administrators, as evidenced by failed legislative attempts to enact such rules in Oregon
- The ASAP Cruises Supreme Court petition denial suggests the Court may not be ready to expand 86-272 protections beyond tangible personal property, despite arguments that the statute's historical context and introductory language support broader application
Topics
Transcript
This podcast episode reflects the opinions of the hosts and guests and not of Greenberg-Schrodinger LLP. This episode is presented for informational purposes only and it is not intended to be construed or used as general legal advice nor a solicitation of any type. When I had to make my mind up between criminal defense and state and local tags, I knew that the clients were going to be much nicer in state and local tags. We do have some really nice clients. nicer in states. We do have some really nice clients. Hello, and welcome to Gettin' Salty, a state and local tax policy podcast hosted by Greenberg Traurig. My name is Nikki Dobay, shareholder in the Portland, Oregon…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from GeTtin' SALTy Podcast
After the Election: State Tax Policy and the Road to 2027
Following the recent election, Democrats gained significant control at the state level, with 30 Democratic governors, six new trifectas, and 300+ new fiscal committee members and chairs. The hosts discuss implications for 2027 state tax policy, emphasizing the critical need for business community education of incoming legislators and highlighting key states to watch including Maryland, Pennsylvania, Minnesota, and Washington.
Portland's Proposed Massive Increase to the CEO Pay-Ratio Surtax—and Oregon's Other Tax Debates
Portland is proposing a massive increase to its CEO pay-ratio surtax, potentially raising it from 10-25% to as high as 500%, which could generate $80 million annually. The proposal faces significant constitutional challenges regarding equal protection, commerce clause issues, and Portland's charter authority to impose taxes without voter approval.
EPR Litigation Update: Oregon Court Upholds Packaging Law as Challenges Continue
Oregon's federal court upheld the state's Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) packaging law against constitutional challenges, rejecting arguments about interstate commerce burdens, due process violations, and improper delegation to the Circular Action Alliance. The decision marks the first litigation outcome on packaging EPR laws, with appeals pending at the Ninth Circuit and similar cases proceeding in Colorado and California.