DiscussionOpinion

The Strongman Loser

Geopolitical Cousins1h 15m

Three hosts discuss recent global elections in Serbia, Brazil, and Israel, analyzing how populist and strongman leaders are losing power despite high turnout, and then pivot to predicting the U.S. midterms where they expect a Democratic wave due to high enthusiasm gaps and Republican unpopularity.

Summary

The episode opens with discussion of recent elections across multiple countries, beginning with Serbia's unique student-led protest movement. Marko Papic explains how Serbian students, responding to a railway station canopy collapse that killed 16 people, created a non-partisan political movement using direct democracy methods to field 250 independent candidates rather than supporting an existing party. President Vučić conceded the election, possibly due to pressure from European leaders including Viktor Orbán. The hosts distinguish between autocratic regimes and illiberal democracies, noting that figures like Orbán, Vučić, and others have consistently allowed peaceful transfers of power despite their authoritarian practices, contradicting narratives that they pose existential threats to democracy.

The discussion then shifts to Brazil's surprising two-round presidential election. In the first round, Bolsonaro's right-wing coalition won the Chamber of Deputies convincingly, but in the second round, Lula defeated him. The hosts attribute this to several factors: lower first-round turnout among Lula voters, Bolsonaro's poor campaign messaging on the economy, and potentially strategic voting by Brazilians who wanted a right-wing Congress balanced by a moderate president. Matt Gertken argues voters understood the republican system of checks and balances and voted accordingly. The hosts caution against over-generalizing about right-wing movements in Latin America, noting that Milei in Argentina and other conservative candidates won due to economic desperation, not ideological momentum.

Regarding Israel, Jacob Shapiro emphasizes that the election results reflect demographic reality: with roughly 20% of the population Arab, no government can form without either working with Arab parties or having Netanyahu step aside. He notes that Arab parties achieved their highest representation ever with 77.7% turnout. The hosts discuss how Netanyahu has been myopically focused on Iran for decades while neglecting other regional threats like Turkey. Marko Papic argues that American geopolitical support has distorted Israeli decision-making, creating what he calls 'geopolitical QE' that has allowed the country to ignore demographic constraints and international opinion. He predicts the Israeli center-left will eventually swing back into power as American support inevitably declines.

The final section analyzes the U.S. midterms. The hosts note that polls are unreliable because they require turnout assumptions, and they predict a significant Democratic wave based on high enthusiasm gaps, low unemployment coexisting with high disapproval of Trump (65%), and shifting battlegrounds that now include traditionally Republican states like South Carolina, Mississippi, and Kansas. They go through individual Senate races state-by-state, predicting Democratic victories in most contested races. Matt Gertken points out that the Iran war and resulting gas price increases have driven Trump's disapproval to levels not seen since Nixon and Vietnam. Jacob Shapiro argues the midterms are less consequential than 2028, where he expects the economy to be the decisive factor and believes JD Vance's political career has been damaged by Islamophobic rhetoric from Republican candidates. Marko Papic concludes that Trump has effectively expelled 60-70% of Americans from his coalition through divisive rhetoric, ensuring Republican losses.

About this episode

<p>Mailbag episode next week!!! This week - Elections. Everywhere. Everybody wants a strongman story but the strongmen keep losing and going home! Lula came back from behind against Flávio Bolsonaro. Israel turned out 77.7% of their entire voter base and <em>still </em>nobody has 61 seats. The US is about to do some real soul-searching, and Cousin Matt Gertken of BCA Research joins the cousinly love to call the Senate. My cousin in Christ, polls can't model turnout. And this year, turnout is angry.</p><p><strong><u>Important Notes:</u></strong></p><p>Serbia held a snap parliamentary election on October 25. The Student List, a slate of non-party experts assembled by the movement that formed after the November 2024 canopy collapse at Novi Sad's railway station, won a majority of the 250 seats. Aleksandar Vučić, who had stepped down as president in September to lead his party's campaign, conceded that night.</p><p>Brazil's runoff was the same day. Lula, who trailed Senator Flávio Bolsonaro, Jair's son, in the first round, won about 51.7% to 48.3%. Flávio has disputed the result.</p><p>Israel voted on October 27. Turnout was 77.7%, the highest since 1999. Netanyahu's bloc won 53 seats, the opposition around Gadi Eisenkot about 48 and the Arab parties 19, so no camp has the 61 it needs to govern.</p><p></p><p><strong><u>Timestamps:</u></strong></p><p>(00:00) - Intro/Welcome</p><p>(01:03) - Serbia's students beat Vučić</p><p>(06:59) - Strongmen, autocrats and who leaves office</p><p>(13:14) - Brazil and the "strongman loser"</p><p>(30:33) - Israel: record turnout, no majority</p><p>(43:51) - Geopolitical QE and Israel's next decade</p><p>(51:46) - Where polls come from</p><p>(55:43) - Quick-fire Senate predictions</p><p>(01:07:28) - Final thoughts: the midterms and 2028</p><p>--</p><p><strong><u>Referenced in the Show:</u></strong></p><p>Matt Gertken - <a href="https://www.bcaresearch.com/strategists/matt-gertken" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://www.bcaresearch.com/strategists/matt-gertken</a></p><p>Elections - <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth</a></p><p>--</p><p><strong>Geopolitical Cousins</strong> is produced and edited by Audiographies LLC. More information at <a href="https://audiographies.com" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">audiographies.com</a></p><p>--</p><p><strong>Jacob Shapiro</strong> is a speaker, consultant, author, and researcher covering global politics and affairs, economics, markets, technology, history, and culture. He speaks to audiences of all sizes around the world, helps global multinationals make strategic decisions about political risks and opportunities, and works directly with investors to grow and protect their assets in today’s volatile global environment. His insights help audiences across industries like finance, agriculture, and energy make sense of the world.</p><p><strong>Jacob Shapiro Site:</strong> <a href="https://jacobshapiro.com" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">jacobshapiro.com</a></p><p><strong>Jacob Shapiro LinkedIn: </strong><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/jacob-l-s-a9337416" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">linkedin.com/in/jacob-l-s-a9337416</a></p><p><strong>Jacob Twitter:</strong> <a href="https://x.com/JacobShap" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">x.com/JacobShap</a></p><p><strong>Jacob Shapiro Substack: </strong><a href="https://jashap.substack.com/subscribe" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">jashap.substack.com/subscribe </a></p><p>--</p><p><strong>Marko Papic</strong> is a macro and geopolitical expert at BCA Research, a global investment research firm. He provides in-depth analysis that combines geopolitics and markets in a framework called GeoMacro. He is also the author of Geopolitical Alpha: An Investment Framework for Predicting the Future.</p><p><strong>Marko’s Book &amp; Newsletter:</strong> <a href="https://www.geopoliticalalpha.com/marko-papic" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">www.geopoliticalalpha.com/marko-papic </a></p><p><strong>Marko’s Linkedin:</strong> <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/marko-papic-geopolitics/" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://www.linkedin.com/in/marko-papic-geopolitics/</a></p><p><strong>Marko’s Twitter:</strong> <a href="https://x.com/Geo_papic" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://x.com/Geo_papic</a></p><p><strong>Marko’s Macro &amp; Geopolitical Research at BCA:</strong> <a href="https://www.bcaresearch.com/marketing/geomacro" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://www.bcaresearch.com/marketing/geomacro</a></p>

Key Insights

  • Vučić in Serbia conceded the election immediately, possibly only after European leaders like Orbán called him warning that masked thugs were preparing to beat protesters, demonstrating that even illiberal leaders face real constraints from international pressure and domestic resistance.
  • Serbian students created an unprecedented political movement by nominating 250 independent experts—engineers, former central bank governors, poets, and athletes—rather than forming a party, using 19th-century direct democracy methods like soviets and drum circles to govern.
  • Western media coverage of Serbian elections obsessed over EU flags at protests and whether the new government would be pro-Russia or pro-West, despite the student movement's 11 demands being entirely about domestic corruption, media freedom, and human rights with no mention of Russian sanctions or EU accession.
  • In Brazil's first round, turnout was the lowest since 1998, but in the second round it jumped to the highest ever, suggesting voters who didn't care enough to show up in round one came out specifically to prevent Bolsonaro from becoming president.
  • Brazilian voters demonstrated sophisticated understanding of the republican system by voting for a right-wing Congress in round one but then electing Lula as a counterbalance in round two, showing they strategically used checks and balances rather than voting purely based on ideology.
  • Israel's election with 77.7% turnout (highest since 1999) produced a hung Knesset where no faction has a majority, forcing the country to confront the demographic reality that roughly 20% of its population is Arab and cannot be excluded from coalition-building.
  • The taboo against Jewish parties working with Arab parties in Israel has never been broken except once under Naftali Bennett, meaning either Netanyahu must fall or this 70-year-old norm must collapse for stable governance to emerge.
  • Marko Papic argues that American geopolitical support has created 'geopolitical QE' that distorts Israeli decision-making, allowing the country to ignore demographic constraints and international opinion because it believes America will always back it unconditionally.
  • In U.S. polling, the coefficient assigned for voter turnout is essentially made up using historical modeling with no actual data, which explains why polls consistently miss when enthusiasm gaps are large, as appears to be the case favoring Democrats in the midterms.
  • Trump's disapproval rating of 65% matches levels seen during the 2008 financial crisis, the Iraq War, and Nixon during Vietnam, and he is now polling worse than Biden on inflation despite inflation having been 8% under Biden's administration.
  • Republican candidates and Trump have made Islamophobic attacks on Democratic candidate Abdul El-Sayed the centerpiece of their strategy, but Marko Papic argues this signals Republican desperation and tilt, comparing it to a poker player making irrational bets after losing consecutive hands.
  • Jacob Shapiro argues the real consequential election is 2028, not the midterms, because the midterms have failed to constrain Trump's behavior and the next cycle will be determined by whether the U.S. economy cracks before then.

Topics

Global elections and democratic transitionsStrongman leaders and illiberal democraciesSerbian student-led political movementBrazilian two-round presidential electionIsraeli demographics and coalition politicsU.S. midterm election predictionsPolling methodology and turnoutEconomic factors in voting behaviorRepublican internal collapseAmerican geopolitical overreachChecks and balances in republican systemsIslamophobia as political strategy

Transcript

Jacob Shapiro: 00:04 All right, listeners, we're- we've got all your questions. We're gonna do the mailbag episode, but we had to get Cousin Matt on the show to talk about midterms and just election madness in the world in general, because we've had Serbian elections we've had Israeli elections, we've had Brazilian elections the midterms are coming. There's all sorts of other stuff going on. So Cousin Matt, thanks for coming on the show and lending your expertise as usual. Matt Gertken: 00:27 Oh, man, it's always great to hang out with you guys. Jacob Shapiro: 00:30 Yeah. It's pretty fun. Marko, I think we should start … I mean we have the f- one of the foremost experts…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Geopolitical Cousins

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.