DiscussionOpinion

Orgy of Aneurysm

Geopolitical Cousins1h 14m

Jacob Shapiro and Marco Papic discuss France's current protests and broader Western geopolitical tensions, arguing that rising costs of living driven by energy prices and military spending on Ukraine and Iran are creating populist backlash. They contend that something must give in Western policy—either military commitments, social spending, or AI/energy infrastructure buildout—as governments cannot simultaneously fund all priorities.

Summary

The episode opens with discussion of a potential movie/TV series project about geopolitical events and figures, exploring how to tell macro stories through individual characters (citing examples like The Last Emperor, The Battle of Algiers, and Killing Them Softly). They emphasize that fiction often better captures historical moments than documentaries.

The main focus shifts to France's current protests and whether they represent a 1968-level crisis. Papic provides historical context, noting France has experienced major protests in 1995-96, 2005-06, 2010, 2023, and the Yellow Vest movement—none initially appeared existential. He explains the 1968 protests led to de Gaulle nearly fleeing the country, but afterwards workers made a deal with the government, leading to a rightward political shift. He contends current polling shows 60% of French people prioritize reducing debt and deficits (up from 30% five years ago), suggesting the silent majority may elect Marine Le Pen who will pursue German-style debt brakes.

Shapiro argues this differs from 1968 because elite overproduction (via AI and economic constraints) means young people lack clear paths to success. He suggests AI anxiety and the threat to white-collar employment now complement traditional working-class concerns, creating broader societal pressure.

Papic identifies the root cause as cost-of-living pressures stemming from energy costs and geopolitical spending, particularly on Ukraine and Iran. He argues these are wars of choice, not existential threats, and that Western publics are rejecting them. He cites polling showing Americans' views of Iran as a threat have dropped 25-30 percentage points, and notes Trump's loss of popularity correlates with foreign military involvement.

They discuss the fundamental budget constraint: Western governments are simultaneously trying to fund AI infrastructure buildout, energy transition, social welfare expansion, military rearmament, and supply chain reshoring. Papic argues something must be cut and predicts military spending on Ukraine and Iran are the easiest targets because they lack domestic political constituencies and genuine existential justification.

Shapiro counters that defense spending is entrenched via the military-industrial complex and that geopolitical theater around Russia and China justifies continued military investment. He suggests cutting pensions and wealth taxes are more likely than military cuts.

Papic argues defense is nevertheless unsustainable given other priorities and that either peace must be made with China or conflicts in Ukraine/Iran must be reduced. He notes that polling increasingly supports peace with Russia even at cost of territorial concessions, particularly in Europe.

They conclude that something will break in markets or policy, but timing is uncertain. Shapiro emphasizes policymakers prioritize kicking the can down the road until genuine crises force difficult decisions. Papic suggests Trump's recent efforts to broker an end to Ukraine are instinctive recognition that both wars cannot be sustained simultaneously.

About this episode

<p>Look, France has had a riot in the streets every few years this century. Pensions in '95. The banlieues in 2005. Students in 2006, pensions again in 2010, the Yellow Vests, pensions again in 2023. In May '68 the president flew to Baden-Baden and nobody could find him. This is not the end of France, because it's the most French thing ever. Try: data centers eating the world's capital, energy eating paychecks, two wars nobody voted for. Something has to give.</p><p>Jacob thinks it's your grandmother's pension.</p><p>Marko thinks it's guns.</p><p></p><p>--</p><p><strong><u>Timestamps:</u></strong></p><p>(00:00) - Intro/Welcome</p><p>(01:25) - The movies somebody should make</p><p>(17:09) - Geopolitical video games</p><p>(18:57) - Is this France's 1968?</p><p>(19:52) - A century of French protests</p><p>(25:45) - Giscard techno and the Le Pen scenario</p><p>(29:47) - Workers, AI and why geopolitics isn't a trade</p><p>(33:30) - It's energy, not AI</p><p>(38:54) - Elite overproduction</p><p>(44:30) - The big short</p><p>(53:08) - Who gets cut first</p><p>(59:40) - Iran, Ukraine and the wars of choice</p><p>(01:09:05) - Trump's tragic flaw</p><p></p><p>--</p><p><strong><u>Referenced in the Show:</u></strong></p><p>GiscardPunk -<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KKhnDzRgsW8" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank"> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KKhnDzRgsW8 </a></p><p>--</p><p><strong>Geopolitical Cousins</strong> is produced and edited by Audiographies LLC. More information at <a href="https://audiographies.com" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">audiographies.com</a></p><p>--</p><p><strong>Jacob Shapiro</strong> is a speaker, consultant, author, and researcher covering global politics and affairs, economics, markets, technology, history, and culture. He speaks to audiences of all sizes around the world, helps global multinationals make strategic decisions about political risks and opportunities, and works directly with investors to grow and protect their assets in today’s volatile global environment. His insights help audiences across industries like finance, agriculture, and energy make sense of the world.</p><p><strong>Jacob Shapiro Site:</strong> <a href="https://jacobshapiro.com" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">jacobshapiro.com</a></p><p><strong>Jacob Shapiro LinkedIn: </strong><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/jacob-l-s-a9337416" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">linkedin.com/in/jacob-l-s-a9337416</a></p><p><strong>Jacob Twitter:</strong> <a href="https://x.com/JacobShap" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">x.com/JacobShap</a></p><p><strong>Jacob Shapiro Substack: </strong><a href="https://jashap.substack.com/subscribe" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">jashap.substack.com/subscribe </a></p><p>--</p><p><strong>Marko Papic</strong> is a macro and geopolitical expert at BCA Research, a global investment research firm. He provides in-depth analysis that combines geopolitics and markets in a framework called GeoMacro. He is also the author of Geopolitical Alpha: An Investment Framework for Predicting the Future.</p><p><strong>Marko’s Book &amp; Newsletter:</strong> <a href="https://www.geopoliticalalpha.com/marko-papic" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">www.geopoliticalalpha.com/marko-papic </a></p><p><strong>Marko’s Linkedin:</strong> <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/marko-papic-geopolitics/" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://www.linkedin.com/in/marko-papic-geopolitics/</a></p><p><strong>Marko’s Twitter:</strong> <a href="https://x.com/Geo_papic" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://x.com/Geo_papic</a></p><p><strong>Marko’s Macro &amp; Geopolitical Research at BCA:</strong> <a href="https://www.bcaresearch.com/marketing/geomacro" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://www.bcaresearch.com/marketing/geomacro</a></p>

Key Insights

  • Papic argues that France's current protests are part of a long historical pattern of French social unrest rather than an existential crisis comparable to 1968, noting six major protest movements in the last 25 years.
  • Papic claims that in 1968, French workers cut a deal with de Gaulle's government specifically to prevent communist revolution, after which the country veered rightward for 12 years—establishing a pattern of how public unrest ultimately produces conservative political outcomes.
  • Shapiro suggests that elite overproduction via AI and economic constraints means young people today lack clear pathways to success, creating different generational anxiety than in previous protest eras.
  • Papic identifies cost of living driven by energy prices and geopolitical spending as the root cause of Western populist backlash, arguing this affects voters more immediately than abstract concerns about China or AI.
  • Both analysts agree that Western governments are attempting to simultaneously fund AI infrastructure, energy transition, social welfare, military rearmament, and supply chain reshoring—an impossible combination that will force prioritization.
  • Papic argues that Ukraine and Iran represent wars of choice rather than existential threats, and that reducing commitment to these wars is the path of least resistance for policymakers facing budget constraints.
  • Shapiro counters that the military-industrial complex and geopolitical theater around Russia and China create strong incentives to maintain defense spending despite public opinion, making other budget items more vulnerable to cuts.
  • Papic claims that polling shows European support for peace with Russia is increasing even at the cost of territorial concessions, particularly in countries like Poland previously seen as hawkish.
  • Papic observes that Trump's recent attempts to broker an end to Ukraine reflect instinctive recognition that both major geopolitical conflicts cannot be sustained simultaneously given resource constraints.
  • Shapiro contends that policymakers' primary strategy is extending time through bread-and-circuses politics rather than making difficult decisions, and that genuine crisis-driven mandates for austerity or cuts are not yet politically available.
  • Both analysts note that the geopolitical situation can be correct while market valuations and investment outcomes remain disconnected, making timing and tactical positioning distinct from strategic analysis.
  • Papic argues that society has become more skeptical of geopolitical narratives after experiencing false WMD claims and fake war propaganda, making traditional justifications for military action less effective with the public.

Topics

France protests and political trajectoryGeopolitical spending vs. domestic prioritiesUkraine and Iran as unsustainable wars of choiceAI anxiety and elite overproductionEnergy costs as driver of populist backlashConstraints on Western government budgetsMovie/fiction as medium for understanding historyPublic opinion on foreign military engagementDefense industry and military-industrial complexMultipolarity and security spending implications

Transcript

Jacob Shapiro: 00:11 Hello, listeners. Welcome to another episode of Geopolitical Cousins. I have no notes. Take care of the people you love. Enjoy the episode. We'll see you out. Our listeners, before we get started, one last chance to get your mailbag questions in. A bunch of you have sent questions in. I think next episode will probably be a mailbag episode or soon, but keep sending them in. We're getting them. If I don't reply to you, don't worry, I have gotten them, but there's just a lot of them. I'm saving them in a folder. They're very good. Cuz and I, we're recording Friday, October 23rd. This will probably come out Monday, I would guess based on…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Geopolitical Cousins

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.