OpinionDiscussion

Ken Fisher: Good Intentions Can Cause Bad Bear Markets

Fisher Investments

Ken Fisher explains that bare markets are typically caused by three main factors: government interventions with good intentions that backfire, excess market sentiment without recession, or a combination of both. He illustrates how regulatory decisions like mark-to-market accounting in 2007-2009 forced massive write-downs that triggered credit crunches, while the 2022 bear market resulted purely from recession expectations that never materialized.

Summary

Ken Fisher outlines a framework for understanding bear market causes, emphasizing that the most common triggers involve government actions implemented with good intentions but producing negative outcomes. He uses the 2007-2009 financial crisis as a primary example, explaining how FASB and international accounting standards' mark-to-market requirements forced banks to write down trillions in loans, which weakened their balance sheets regulatorily and constrained their lending capacity. This credit contraction then cascaded into economic constriction and recession.

Fisher distinguishes between different types of bear markets based on their root causes. Minor bear markets can occur from sentiment shifts alone without any recession, as exemplified by 2022 when widespread recession expectations prompted businesses and individuals to engage in preventative "house cleaning" that ultimately avoided the predicted downturn. Despite avoiding recession, the deteriorated sentiment still produced a bear market.

He identifies three primary bear market scenarios: government actions causing bear markets with recession, excess expectations causing recessionless bear markets through sentiment deterioration, and the "mother of all bear markets" combining both excess expectations and governmental missteps or dislocations that trigger recession. Fisher suggests this three-tier framework captures the primary mechanisms driving bear market cycles.

Key Insights

  • The most common bear market causes stem from government actions implemented with good intentions that produce unintended negative consequences, often involving regulatory coordination across institutions.
  • Mark-to-market accounting rules in 2007-2009 forced banks to write down trillions of dollars in loans, which weakened their regulatory balance sheets and reduced their lending capacity, creating a credit crunch.
  • Bear markets can occur purely from sentiment deterioration without any recession, as happened in 2022 when anticipated recession expectations caused businesses to preemptively reduce operations but the recession never materialized.
  • Excess expectations alone can generate recessionless bear markets as sentiment cools off, representing a category of market decline distinct from recession-driven downturns.
  • The most severe bear markets result from a combination of excess sentiment and government policy errors or dislocations occurring simultaneously, which triggers both market decline and economic recession.

Topics

Bear market causes and mechanismsGovernment regulatory interventionsMark-to-market accounting policyMarket sentiment and expectationsCredit markets and lending dynamics2007-2009 financial crisis2022 bear market without recession

Transcript

[0:00] market. I'm going to make this real simple. The most common things that cause a bare market, not the only things, but the most common things are something big and bad done with good intention by governments often in coordination that they think is going to improve things that actually make things worse. If you go back for example to 200789, it was regulatory features associated [0:30] with concerns about mortgages and particularly FASB and international FASB coordinating marktomarket accounting that forced banks to write down quite literally trillions of dollars of loans. Therefore making them with their restated balance sheets in a regulatory sense unable to lend at the levels that they normally would be lending at which…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Fisher Investments

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.